5 ms·
I still can't get past the feeling that this is another Moller Aircar type project. Something to string investors along forever while you bilk them out of mone
by jandrese 10y ago
I still can't get past the feeling that this is another Moller Aircar type project. Something to string investors along forever while you bilk them out of money.
The proposals aren't even all that similar to the original Hyperloop proposal. Gone is the ducted fan setup and instead they're just building high speed rail in a tube. And the cost estimates still make no sense whatsoever. I will be frankly shocked if any of these companies ever lay anything more than a short test track somewhere.
- Animats 10y agoMost of the workable plans, such as the MIT prototype, are "maglev on a track in a vacuum tube", rather than the original Musk "flies at a 0.5 to 1.3 mm height on aerodynamic lift" plan. That low flying height would require a really smooth tube, with no millimeter-sized sags in the middle of tube sections. Not impossible, just expensive. The whole point of the Hyperloop system is that that the tube is supposed to be cheap. Dubai Ports World might build a system between Abu Dhabi and Dubai. The route is flat and empty. and not too long. Dubai already has two monorail systems and a metro rail system, all beautiful and underutilized.[1] It may cost too much, but that probably won't be a problem. A maglev doesn't need the tube below 200MPH or so. One way to build a useful system might be to run in a vacuum tube for long, straight runs, and switch to open track in congested areas. This would allow bringing the tracks much further into cities. Musk's original plan called for ending the LA-SF system in Fremont, near Tesla's plant. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=615x7e8wXNU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=615x7e8wXNU
- jandrese 10y agoThe idea of creating a miles long pressure vessel "for cheap" always seemed to be the most insane part of the project. It is certainly technically possible to build a structure like that, but I have no idea how they plan to make it affordable.
- Animats 10y agoThat's a classic problem with monorail enthusiasts. Early drawings of proposed monorails used to show single lightweight elevated rails on thin pylons.[1] Pictures of successful operating monorails, such as Tokyo Haneda, show double tracks on heavy pylons.[2] Often there's an emergency walkway alongside. (There are a surprising number of operating monorail systems in the world now. The US is way behind in this. The few in the US are airport systems or tourist attractions, but Japan and China, and now Brazil, have city-sized systems.)
- kalleboo 10y ago> The US is way behind in this I wouldn't worry about this - I've never ridden a monorail I liked. They always seem slower and much bumpier than a traditional track - see something like the Bangkok BTS SkyTrain for the type of system you really want.
- pitaj 10y agoIt's not that low of a pressure, really. The pumps to keep it at a pressure, even with leakage accounted for, only need to be at the ends of the tube so it's fairly cheap.
- na85 10y agoIt's almost as if PayPal founder Elon Musk doesn't necessarily always know best regarding manufacturing and vehicle dynamics.
- lightbritefight 10y agoHe didnt found PayPal. He founded an early competitor to PayPal that merged with it, giving him huge equity in Paypal itself. If you want to talk manufacturing and vehicle dynamics, he also founded Telsa, an electric vehicle company, and SpaceX, a Spaceship company. Anything about those two vehicle manufacturing companies that might lend you to believe he knows something about manufacturing and vehicle dynamics? He undoutably doesn't have the concept fully sorted, but at least vilify the man for actual faults, not ones you want to make up.
- dragontamer 10y ago> he also founded Telsa Musk gave Series A funding to Tesla. Martin Eberhard and Marc Tarpenning founded Tesla. At best, Musk bought Tesla really really early. But he wasn't one of the original founders. > SpaceX I'll give you that one. But Musk doesn't get Tesla in my eyes.
- Diederich 10y agoIn 2003, Musk did indeed gave Series A (as well as B and C) seven months after the company was incorporated. At the same time, in early 2004, he took up direct operational control of the company, and has stayed in that position since. The first Roadster arrived 4 years after he took over.
- na85 10y agoHe's still not a mechanical or aerospace engineer. At least lionize him for actual qualities, not ones you project onto him.
- giblfiz 10y agoSo that's a really interesting statement... He has an B.S. in physics and an Honorary doctorate in Aerospace Engineering, and an Honorary doctorate of Engineering from Yale. So I'm not sure what exactly it takes to count as an aerospace engineer, but it seems like he has both the bit of paper, and the employment history.
- foenix 10y agoI wonder how such a system would handle earthquakes and the like.
- cossatot 10y agoThe tube might keep the train from flying off the tracks, but will possibly lose vaccuum. But maybe not. The trans-Alaska pipeline crosses the Denali fault, which is a big strike-slip fault similar to the San Andreas. The pipleline is on rail-mounted pylons that allow for several meters of lateral motion near the fault. The fault had a M 7.9 earthquake in 2002, and the pylons slid as intended, bending but not breaking the pipeline[1]. Now, I don't know that much about the Hyperloop design, but I imagine that the earthquake-induced deflection in the tube may render it unusable for some amount of time. However, the the example goes to show that somewhat similar infrastructure can be built to withstand large seismic events, as long as the faults are known about ahead of time (which is the case in southern California but not everywhere on earth). [1]: http://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/2003/fs014-03/pipeline.html http://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/2003/fs014-03/pipeline.html
- babyrainbow 10y ago>rather than the original Musk "flies at a 0.5 to 1.3 mm height on aerodynamic lift" plan.... So what was that exactly? And where does that 0.5 to 1.3 mm height come from?
- Animats 10y agoIt's from section 4.1.4 of Musk's original paper. Air bearings are usually that thin, but at the proposed speeds, the inside tube surface can't have any irregularities. [1] http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-20130812.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-201...
- trhway 10y ago>I still can't get past the feeling that this is another Moller Aircar type project. Something to string investors along forever while you bilk them out of money. i wonder why such animosity toward Moller. His approach on the last incarnation of the car has some technical mistakes which made it a dead end, yet looking into his history and the overall history of VTOL i wonder how people may see that as a scam. It is pretty obvious today that we will have human carrying 8/12/16-copters in the next few years (we actually already have them as actually flying prototypes today) and that is pretty much where Moller was in 198x-199x just adjusting for the non-availability of modern hardware and electronics back then (so he went for complicated double-engine-same-shaft design with minimum of controlling electronics - the approach which doomed the last incarnation. I do fail to see a scam here.)
- jandrese 10y ago> i wonder why such animosity toward Moller. 50+ years and $100m in R&D no viable prototypes might have something to do with it. Maybe the approach was doomed from the start, but that didn't stop Moller from promising that you would be commuting to work by air in 10 years for decade after decade.
- trhway 10y ago>50+ years and $100m in R&D tell this to fusion guys :) >no viable prototypes i find this for example as looking very viable back at the time https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MwxVAZuFOs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MwxVAZuFOs and actually if you add more props (possible with electric today not so much with gas engines back then) and much-much better control electronics you'll get the modern multi-copters : volocopter prototype https://youtu.be/L75ESD9PBOw?t=97 https://youtu.be/L75ESD9PBOw?t=97 and pre-production https://youtu.be/VAEy0NltoFQ?t=78 https://youtu.be/VAEy0NltoFQ?t=78 >Maybe the approach was doomed from the start, but that didn't stop Moller from promising that you would be commuting to work by air in 10 years for decade after decade. only the last one, m400 was doomed as i mentioned above (and it wasn't actually that clear from the start, m400 was actually pretty logical and reasonable move forward - only after first tests one could see it clear). Put yourself at his place at any point in the history of his flying car development and those 10 years would look like a reasonable estimate. I personally actually say today that in 5 years we'll have the Volocopter likes flying around.
- the_watcher 10y agoIt seems to me like there's a fairly strong case for using them for transporting goods, at least. Much more durable than humans, tracks can be laid in places that would be far too risky to run humans through.
- vosper 10y agoBut what goods need to be moved so quickly? Autonomous vehicles are going to bring plenty of improvements to shipping and delivery, and are happening right now.
- the_watcher 10y agoReducing the time of shipping is a pretty common goal of many companies. It's not about need, it's about a clear improvement.
- Shivetya 10y agohonestly, its the solar powered roadways for the technology oriented crowd. the science is beyond the majority of readers but who would want to admit they truly don't understand what they are supporting and look bad among peers who support it? look, it might be technically possible but it in no means is viable. it does sound really cool though.
- JKCalhoun 10y agoOr worse — billionaire trolling to try to subvert a state (CA) initiative.
- dmix 10y agoSuggesting a faster, most likely more cost effective alternative to a notoriously overpriced state project = subversion? If that's the case then subversion is a good thing we should encourage because there's a serious lack of it happening these days.
- kilroy123 10y agoI'd like to think it's possible to make this work. However, I've lost faith in this group to make it happen based on the wackiness I've read so far. https://www.wired.com/2016/08/hyperloop-one-lawsuit-bambrogan-pishevar/ https://www.wired.com/2016/08/hyperloop-one-lawsuit-bambroga...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- disposablezero 10y agotl;dr - it's a nice attempt but completely unfeasible as per below: https://youtu.be/RNFesa01llk https://youtu.be/RNFesa01llk https://m.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/4udgd2/the_hyperloop_one_busted_by_the_youtube/?utm_source=mweb_redirect&compact=true https://m.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/4udgd2/the_hyperl...
- nkoren 10y agoHey, you say that they're just doing high-speed rail in a tube. Do you have a source for that claim? I see lots of people saying it, but nothing from the company or journalistic sources to confirm that. And what's on their blog seems to contradict it: https://hyperloop-one.com/blog/a-wheel-revolution-in-transportation https://hyperloop-one.com/blog/a-wheel-revolution-in-transpo... This says that they are using passive magnetic levitation rather than air pressure, so it is a change from the original design, but not as drastic as you suggest.