3 ms·
The states maintain their systems because there are 2 parties that exercise a lot of influence in state politics. I've thought about trying to start a ballot i
by maxerickson 10y ago
The states maintain their systems because there are 2 parties that exercise a lot of influence in state politics.
I've thought about trying to start a ballot initiative to remove parties from the ballot process. Each candidate would have to generate sufficient support to get their name on the ballot, no other rules. Organized groups like parties would be useful under those rules, but an independent wouldn't be at a legal disadvantage compared to a member of an incumbent party (as is the case in many states today).
- Svip 10y agoI think Sir Humphrey said it best, 'no government would change a system that put it there'. While your initiative is well meant, abandoning parties is actually a step in the wrong direction. Because while parties won't appear on the ballot, the parties will make sure to include their name and their candidate in every advertisement, so only few voters are unsure whom each candidate represents. Likely washing away other parties' chances as they don't maintain the same influence. No, party-list proportional representation is a much more democracy and fairer system. Because it allows a voter to vote for a party that's not popular in their district, but so that their vote can matter on a state-wide or national-wide level. Of course, that's a major overhaul of the system, but unfortunately, I personally believe that's what necessary. However, I believe that such an overhaul could start in smaller more progressive states like Vermont or Maine. And if the system catches on, there may be public push for a similar system in neighbouring states.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe point isn't to detach the parties from the candidates, it's to make it so that party infighting is not the strongest path to the ballot. At the moment, winning a party knife fight is the thing that decides lots of local and state office elections. For the presidential election there would be more risk of pushing the election to the House of Representatives, but candidates could bargain with each other and withdraw and such. People would be able to figure it out.
- CalChris 10y agoWhile I agree that Congress and the States are not going to change the system now, that was not the case in 1780 or so. The weak Articles of Confederation were a failure and that system of government did abandon itself for a stronger more federal Constitution.
- ende 10y agoI disagree that progressives have a higher propensity for this sort of electoral reform. Progressive ideology is inherently an obsession with forming an intellectual monoculture hostile to criticism anf dissenting worldviews. This type of mindset is not conducive to increasing political diversity.
- specialist 10y ago"remove parties from the ballot process" Sounds nice. Alas, there's always winners and losers. The fight is always people vs capital. Anything that weakens the party organizations empowers the monied interests. "generate sufficient support to get their name on the ballot" In my jurisdiction, any candidate paying the modest filing fee appears on the ballot. What are the rules where you live? Of course, the Presidential race is a whole tarball onto itself. There has been interest to lower the bar even further. Such as gathering 200 signatures (to a petition) in lieu of the filing fee.
- maxerickson 10y agoThere's a signature requirement. https://ballotpedia.org/Ballot_access_requirements_for_political_candidates_in_Michigan https://ballotpedia.org/Ballot_access_requirements_for_polit... The primaries bypass that, major party candidates (selected privately by the party, the thing I propose to remove) can either file a petition (with ~1/2 the signatures required of an independent) or pay $100. Note that I'm not proposing preventing groups from organizing and participating in the gathering of signatures and endorsing of candidates, I'm proposing removing the provisions that make it easier for the incumbent groups to get on the ballot and putting them on equal footing with everyone else.