6 ms·
A friend of mine is working on a plan to fix this electoral college madness once and for all. It's called National Popular Vote, and it's a brilliant scheme to
by lisper 10y ago
A friend of mine is working on a plan to fix this electoral college madness once and for all. It's called National Popular Vote, and it's a brilliant scheme to have the president elected by (as the name implies) the national popular vote without a Constitutional amendment:
http://www.nationalpopularvote.com http://www.nationalpopularvote.com
The idea is to get state legislatures to pass laws that their states will cast their electoral collect votes according to the outcome of the national popular vote, but contingent on enough states passing similar legislation that the states who have passed such laws constitute a majority in the electoral college. In other words, the legislation has no effect until enough states pass it that it has the same effect as Constitutional amendment would. It's a devilishly clever hack, and the law has already passed (stealthily) in over a dozen states, including California and New York. It enjoys (as you might expect) overwhelming popular support nearly everywhere, so I think it has a good chance of actually succeeding. If you care about this sort of thing you might want to consider spreading the word, or even making a contribution.
- noobermin 10y agoWe did it with senators, we should do it with the President. Curious why you wouldn't want to amend the Constitution for this though and enshrine it there. If it needs to be passed in a majority of states, might as well fight for an amendment. Also, it is a tired meme that amendments are hard, especially when a majority of Americans agree on something.
- lisper 10y agoOne might wish to amend the Constitution, but the current political climate makes it practically impossible.
- noobermin 10y agoNot if a) a majority of Americans agree and b) you go to the states instead of through congress.
- ascagnel_ 10y agoAll amendments to the Constitution must go through Congress.
- noobermin 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_to_propose_amendments_to_the_United_States_Constitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_to_propose_amendmen...
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoNot going to happen because it's not clear that there's a way to call such a convention without giving it the power to basically do whatever it wants. See the last constitutional convention for precedent.
- mikeash 10y agoA constitutional amendment needs the approval of 2/3rds of both houses of Congress and 3/4ths of the states. There's no way NPV would get that kind of support. The Republican Party explicitly makes the preservation of the existing Electoral College system part of its official party platform, so 2/3rds of Congress is pretty much automatically not going to happen as long as that's the case.
- noobermin 10y ago>approval of 2/3rds of both houses of Congress and 3/4ths of the states You're forgetting that states can call for a convention[0]. If you need a majority of states to pass legislation, you can get a majority of states to call for a convention. [0] https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/constitution/article-v.html https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/constitution/artic...
- jessriedel 10y agoThis is even less likely to happen. A constitutional convention would be terrifying, because literally everything is up for grabs.
- noobermin 10y agoI actually am for a constitutional convention in which everything is up for grabs. Many of the recent years' controversies have been due to creative interpretation of the constitution. While I personally am happy for a few of them (gay marriage for example), many have stoked controversy. The best way to end the debate is to put it to the people to restate what their constitution means. We should not be afraid of democracy, either we trust the people of this nation to self-govern or we don't. Yes, I am not a fan of direct-democracy, but amendments to the constitution is more about deciding what is important enough to us to enshrine as part of the spirit of our law going forward. To give an example of the current desire for a convention, see the wiki article I linked elsewhere. A right wing group has had legislation calling for a convention to pass in eight states and a left wing group has managed to get it passed in five other states. Unfortunately, these groups are calling for different things, but it shows there is a brewing desire for a convention.
- swsieber 10y agoI think the thing that that individual laws allow for is a)stealth and b)agreement over time
- noobermin 10y agoIndividual laws are easier to chuck out in the middle of the night (or with moneyed interests who can organize across state lines while citizens aren't paying attention). The constitution cannot be superseded.
- wyldfire 10y ago> The constitution cannot be superseded. Ordinarily I'd agree with you but it seems like lately the Senate has shirked their duty to provide advice and consent on appointments of justices to SCOTUS. :(
- v64 10y agoWe shouldn't have done it with senators though. The original system was designed that way so as to minimize the influence of populism on the Senate.
- mikeash 10y agoDo I understand correctly that NPV would just go to whoever got the most votes, even if all were under 50%? Unfortunate if so, although I understand that it's probably a bad idea to try to make two big changes at once.
- lisper 10y agoGood question. I don't know. But I'm sure the answer is on the site somewhere.
- Jtsummers 10y ago> The National Popular Vote bill would guarantee the Presidency to the candidate who receives the most popular votes in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. http://www.nationalpopularvote.com/written-explanation http://www.nationalpopularvote.com/written-explanation Seems it only requires a plurality, not a majority of the votes.
- mcherm 10y agoThe goal (national popular vote) is laudable, but I think that particular approach is flawed. A system where the votes are counted nationally and the ticket (president + vice president) winning the most votes is elected would be a system that I could strongly support. But a system where each state votes its electoral college votes in a ratio based on the state's popular vote, which did not change the other rules (like "if no one gets a majority then we ignore the voters entirely and hold a vote in the House of Representatives instead") would work poorly. The next-biggest weakness, I believe, would be that the ratio of voters in each state is fairly well known. There are roughly 200,000 voters per House Representative, so one must persuade a substantial portion of that number to "flip" any one vote. This means that, effectively, there would only be one vote "up for grabs" in each state (maybe 2 in the really big states), with the other votes essentially "fixed". This gives hugely disproportional power to the small states (imagine if each state had only a single vote). EDIT: Please disregard!!! I misread the original proposal, which is a LOT smarter than I thought. The proposal is to give the state's votes to the winner of the national popular vote, thus effecting the proposal I originally preferred.
- tunesmith 10y agoI think something like this is necessary but not sufficient. All it does it invalidate the Electoral College, but it doesn't solve other problems - spoiler effects still exist, close elections will be even harder to deal with since nationwide recounts are harder than statewide recounts, etc. I think a lot of people get sucked in to thinking about voting methods when it is actually a distraction when you consider that we don't have a consensus of how to even define democracy. For instance, ask yourself these two questions: 1) If, in a multi-candidate election, one candidate would defeat all others head-to-head, should that candidate be the winner? (I personally say yes, but many say "not necessarily") 2) If, in a two-candidate election, candidate A wins 51-49, but the supporters of candidate B are significantly more passionate than candidate A, should B win? (I personally say no, but many say yes - usually implicit in arguments for more "utility" or "overall voter happiness") Because of my beliefs, I would be in favor of something like the National Popular Vote compact, but with a Condorcet element - where each state's EVs are awarded to the national Condorcet winner if it exists. States would transition to ranked ballots on their own timetable, and the national vote would take ranked ballots into account as reported. (An unranked ballot is Condorcet-compatible as it expressed a preference for one candidate above all others, with no preference between the others.) If Smith/Schwartz sets happen, the election goes to the House as it does now.
- macintux 10y agoI'm strongly opposed. The electoral college is designed to protect the country from manifestly unqualified presidents. Furthermore, the electoral college is all that stands between us and Florida 2000 on a national scale. Recounting one state was painful enough. Recounting all 50? Nightmare.
- lisper 10y agoIt's arguable whether the electoral college works as intended. But it would still exist under NPV, so whatever protections it provides us now, it would continue to provide, so this is not reasonable grounds for opposing the NPV proposal.
- tunesmith 10y agoA nationwide recount (or multiple statewide recounts) is bigger and more complicated than a single statewide recount. How is that not reasonable grounds for opposing NPV? It is worth considering that if the size of the House had been permitted to grow as originally intended, then the difference between the NPV and the EC basically disappears. For instance, I believe that Gore would have won in 2000 had the House been double or triple in size (I forget exactly where, but somewhere around there). So that's a point in favor of the popular vote.
- mikeash 10y agoGrowing the House might have solved 2000 but it doesn't solve the overall problem, which is that a few states are hugely elevated in importance because they're the only ones that might realistically go either way. Swinging 5% of voters in Ohio is vastly more valuable than swinging 5% of voters in California, even though California has 3x more people. A larger House wouldn't change that.
- lisper 10y agoIt's actually a theorem that it is not possible to devise an apportionment scheme that does not have perverse outcomes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apportionment_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apportionment_paradox http://study.com/academy/lesson/balanski-youngs-impossibility-theorem-political-apportionment.html http://study.com/academy/lesson/balanski-youngs-impossibilit...
- zeveb 10y agoI strongly believe that a national popular vote is exactly the wrong direction for the country; it'd be far better to eliminate the popular vote entirely and have the state governments allocate their electoral votes. I think the madness is that we vote for the president at all. We are a federal republic, not a unitary state; the President presides over the United States, not the people of the several states, and should thus be selected by the states. As you might imagine, I'd like to repeal the 17th Amendment as well: the people are represented by our … Representatives; we don't need to also have super-representative Senators; right now, the states have no voices in the federal government, which just seems wrong. I'd be open to a system in which the state legislature allocates two electoral votes and a popular election allocated the state's remaining electoral votes, mirroring the federal system of representatives and senators.