6 ms·
Ooh, how I wish I could buy put options on the Hyperloop. Because unless they solve the thermal expansion problem -- and there is no feasible solution on the h
by lisper 10y ago
Ooh, how I wish I could buy put options on the Hyperloop. Because unless they solve the thermal expansion problem -- and there is no feasible solution on the horizon AFAICT -- they will fail.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoNot to mention all of the logistical problems with building and maintaining a low pressure tube. People think high speed rail is expensive? Wait until you see how expensive Hyperloop is going to be per mile. PS - And I haven't even touched on safety/evacuation problems with the concept. That quadupled the cost and size of the Eurotunnel for comparison, how can we assume it won't bloat the Hyperloop's size/cost/complexity?
- komali2 10y agoAnd so it does? However you feel about the executives and history of Hyperloop, I think it's important that companies like this exist and try things like this. You know what's expensive and was once unfeasible? Strapping thousands of tons of fuel to a rocket and launching it into space. And yet...
- masklinn 10y ago> I think it's important that companies like this exist and try things like this. They're not trying anything at this point, they've raised enough money for at most 5km worth of high-speed tracks (proper 350km/h graded tracks) and no rolling stock.
- komali2 10y agoWhat about R&D output? Even if the company goes broke, they / their research can be purchased and used in the future. They might only produce new materials that they sell the patents for upon going bankrupt. Their engineers and scientists will develop and learn, and move on to other firms if Hyperloop becomes insolvement, and take that knowledge with them.
- jklinger410 10y agoThat Musk sure is one big dummy!
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoThat's a rather offensive thing to claim. He has actually accomplished a lot and pushed two or three industries forward. Personally I don't think Musk is a "dummy" as you do, but I do feel sometimes his passion doesn't always address real world civil engineering limitations. The Hyperloop is technically very possible, thus isn't "dumb," it is just building it at scale (and addressing consumer safety, etc) that may be a challenge.
- Razengan 10y agoI think GP was being sarcastic to the GGP's comment.
- djsumdog 10y agoBut those problems can be solved. Maybe. Even if they're not, the research is important to tell us what does and doesn't work. We build massive dams to stop rivers and invest billions into complex rockets that need to carefully control explosions in order to get people and cargo into space. If one company can build a simple 10 ~ 20km tube between two major travel points in some country, it will be an invaluable proof of concept worth way more than the initial investment. Just because something is hard doesn't me we shouldn't try.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoAny problem can be solved with unlimited funds. The question isn't if it is possible, it is how much good can be done with that same money elsewhere (opportunity cost). For example, one mile of Hyperloop or five miles of conventional high speed rail? One mile of Hyperloop or two miles of Monorail? One mile of Hyperloop or investments into more efficient aircraft?
- a11r 10y agoI am assuming that you are talking about the thermal expansion of the tubes (ducts ?). A long time ago, the rails making up train tracks used to have gaps every few meters to accommodate thermal expansion (same problem). Modern rails in high speed train tracks are welded into one continuous bar that can be over a kilometer long. The trick is to stretch the rail just enough and then pin it down - kind of like a slightly stretched rubber band. That stretch can accommodate thermal expansion.
- m0skit0 10y agoNot a good analogy. One of the main Hyperloop points it is to have near vaccum inside the tubes, which will reduce air resistance and allow faster speeds, otherwise it's just a train inside a tube. This means they must be totally sealed, so no gaps allowed.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- djsumdog 10y agoIt won't be a complete vacuum though? I mean it doesn't have to be. Even removing 70% 80% of the air would greatly reduce drag. Plus don't they also need safety systems in case of issues so the tube segments can be locked and re-pressurized without damaging the train?
- SquirrelOnFire 10y agoDrag reduction is, I think as important as decreasing the shock wave generated by breaking the local speed of sound. Partial vacuum does both. Not sure how to optimize for cost and reliability of construction vs max sped
- sigmar 10y agoSo... you put in a flexible air tight seal in the tube. It will have to be modular anyway. Doesn't seem that challenging or cost prohibitive. A quick google turns up NASA projects that were looking into flexible airlock seals.
- lnanek2 10y agoWhat's unsolvable about it? Every bridge I've ever been on has had a little gap for expansion. Just make a little gap every 5km, cover the outside with rubber that stretches across the two sides, boom, you are done. The cars float on a little air pressure cushion and don't normally use their wheels, so there wouldn't even be a bump.
- lisper 10y agoThe hyperloop tube needs to maintain a vacuum and be perfectly smooth on the inside, so traditional expansion joints won't work.
- wastedhours 10y agoCould you have an outer tube with concrete and expansion joints, then a membrane on the inside that maintains smoothness but expands/contracts as the tube moves?
- lisper 10y agoWhat would the membrane be made out of? Remember, it's not enough to be smooth. You have to be: 1. Smooth (on the inside) and 2. Straight and 3. Strong (enough to bear the stress of having a multi-ton vehicle passing within a few millimeters at 700MPH) and 4. Long (300 miles at least) and 5. Airtight for that entire length, and 6. Cost-effective. It is that combination of features that no one has ben able to even begin to tell a story about how they would make it work in the face of thermal expansion.
- stcredzero 10y agoHow do gas pipelines solve the thermal expansion problem?
- masklinn 10y agoExpansion joints or loops[0], and their thermal expansion problems are significantly lower since the source is environmental changes. [0] http://i.stack.imgur.com/VhLi2.jpg http://i.stack.imgur.com/VhLi2.jpg
- wott 10y agoOh, OK. Just have to do the same with the train :-)
- lisper 10y agoBy putting bends into the pipes. https://www.quora.com/Why-do-oil-pipelines-have-so-many-seemingly-unnecessary-bends https://www.quora.com/Why-do-oil-pipelines-have-so-many-seem... But this obviously won't work for the hyperloop. It has to be straight.
- achow 10y agoShouldn't this be a solved problem by NASA? Space shuttles would have similar challenge (actually in reverse) - how to protect sealed air inside a closed cylinder from almost absolute vacuum outside in an environment where heat and cold are extreme; the cylinder being fabricated from overlapping conjoined pieces.
- thearn4 10y agoSome folks at NASA have spent some time analyzing the principles and technical challenges behind hyperloop (I know most of them for what it's worth): https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cluster=4581830088403547634&hl=en&as_sdt=0,36&sciodt=0,36 https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cluster=45818300884035476...
- achow 10y agoThanks for sharing. They seem to be convinced about the viability albeit concluding that it may need bigger diameter pipes and the speed would be little slower. No alarms on thermal expansion, structural integrity etc.
- thearn4 10y agoyeah, the analysis at that stage was focused more on the propulsion aspects of the system.
- pitaj 10y agoThey did solve this: they have expansion regions at the stations (ends of the tube) and the tube is allowed to slide freely within it's supports.
- lisper 10y agoWon't work. See http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/ http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/ for a detailed analysis.