11 ms·
100 years ago, people paid money to see a fat man in a circus sideshow.
- CoryMathews 17y agoSadly hes probably just over normal now.
- smokinn 17y agoAverage maybe but definitely not normal.
- GFischer 17y agoIf you think that's anything remotely close to average, you have to get out of your country more often. My mother really loved moving to Canada, because of that... over there she's not thought of as fat (heck, not even as overweight). I weigh 175 lbs (80 kg) and for my height (5 foot 10 / 175 cm) I'm considered on the fat side for my country (Uruguay). Whenever a fat consultant from the US comes, he is gaped at (much like the fat man on the freak show).. a TV figure from Argentina is famous precisely for being fat (Daniel "Tota" Santillán) Edit: 3 other people made the point so far too.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- chunkyslink 17y agoNot in Africa, South America, Asia or even Europe hes not.
- hackermom 17y agoIn Europe, and Scandinavia in particular, that man would sit at a point way, way beyond anything defined as normal or even plump.
- tjogin 17y agoTrue, here he would still turn heads.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pw0ncakes 17y agoNo. I'd guess him at 99.5th percentile at least in the US, but you're right that he's not that out of the ordinary, given that we now have people who exceed 1000# and can't leave their houses.
- gcb 17y agothe sum of the couple was around 900
- corruption 17y agoThey probably would have paid to see someone over 60 too.
- eru 17y agoOld people weren't that rare. Over 80 would been more of a show, I guess. (But we should find some data, before we speculate.)
- byrneseyeview 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joice_Heth http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joice_Heth P. T. Barnum traveled with this person, whom he claimed was 161 years old. She was, in fact, about 80 when she died.
- jonp 17y agoEven 80 wasn't that exceptional. In 1910 there were over 200,000 people in England & Wales aged over 80; about 1 in 170 of the population. (Calculations based on data from http://www.mortality.org/ http://www.mortality.org/)
- david_adams 17y agoThe way that life expectancy works is that it was low because so many people died of disease in their youth that it dragged the average down. But people who lived to old age still lived to what we would consider an old age today. There would just be fewer people who lived that long, but not dramatically fewer.
- astine 17y agoNot likely. Average life-expectancy at the time was about that, so there were plenty of people over 60.
- jdminhbg 17y agoSome clarifying comments on the link to the same story at marginalrevolution (http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/04/freakonomics.html#comments http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/04...): "It says in the linked page that Morgan weighed as much as 875 pounds. I think that's still a bit unusual even today." Apparently the photo is him at a younger, slimmer point.
- chaosmachine 17y agoI imagine that number was a generous estimate given by the guys selling tickets.
- jdminhbg 17y agoI don't doubt it. But the guy in the photo doesn't look to even be half that.
- ErrantX 17y agoI always find it interesting that sci-fi depictions of "evolved" humans (i.e. many years in the future) usually depict very tall, thin - even willowy - figures. That seems to fly in the face of general trend :)
- gfodor 17y agoExcept in Wall-e
- hackermom 17y agoInterestingly, WALL-E really nails the reality of western man's search for perfected convenience.
- axod 17y agoIt really should have been billed as "Not a fun kids movie" IMHO. Still surprises me that people liked that movie.
- adamhowell 17y agoIt's still the only movie my 3-yr-old daughter will sit through. The first 30 minutes is some of the best storytelling ever put to film, IMHO. So much told with so little. Other Pixar movies like Monsters, Inc. or Cars are either too scary or too talky. Wall-E is the perfect balance, and such a well told story that I never tire of it, either.
- eldenbishop 17y agoMy friends kid can only watch the beginning. When the humans show up, he starts crying. To scary.
- run4yourlives 17y agoWhat do mean? Movies that have points are not to be enjoyed? A movie cannot be entertaining and insightful?
- mhb 17y agoFrom: http://men-in-full.livejournal.com/111937.html http://men-in-full.livejournal.com/111937.html referring to additional photos there: The image was taken by a photographer probably during the 1890s-1910 era. The cabinet photo measures approx. 4" x 6". It pictures a super view of a young man and woman, but both of a very large size! The back of the photo read "Chauncey Morlan, Age 25, Wt 602, Wife age 22, Wt 526". A quick "google" search revealed that they were a circus side show attraction of some type. The photographer turned out to be famous circus / sideshow / freak photographer Wendt of Boonton NJ. He was famous for his rare images of midgets, giants, fatmen, sword swallowers, jugglers and bearded ladies! Chauncy Royse Morlan and Annie Bell were married in 1892 at Huber's Museum in New York. Afterward the couple toured with the Barnum & Bailey Circus in Europe. Upon returning to the US, they continued to travel as the fattest married couple in the world "with a combined weight of 912 pounds". During the off season the Morlans returned to their home in Indianapolis, Indiana - Chauncy's home state. Annie would die at age 31, and Chauncey at age 43.
- seiha 17y agoNow that's one creepy livejournal community.
- davi 17y agoI don't think it's creepy, at least not after giving it a brief read. It's interesting, and everyone is being very polite and well spoken with one another, and talking about what they're interested in. We should do as well. (I upmodded you anyway because your comment made me go look.)
- dkimball 17y agoSo, 100 years ago, this kind of weight was sideshow-worthy (and remember the other things one would see in a circus sideshow...); today, it wouldn't turn heads on a subway. However: the US has become _more_ health-conscious in the past 100 years, not less. We must have something wrong, if concern for exercise and good nutrition goes hand-in-hand with this kind of obesity. I think this is due, at least in part, to the drastic reduction of fat consumption relative to carbohydrates; but changes in lifestyle and in modes of entertainment must have something to do with it, too. No one mindlessly eats high-carbohydrate foods while playing poker, after all... The increase in number of sedentary jobs relative to others probably has a role, too, but it must not be a very major factor on its own; otherwise, there would have been as much obesity among white-collar workers then as there is among everyone today. There are things that man was not meant to know: not the coordinates of Cthulhu's tomb in the watery depths and the nature of spells to manipulate the Great Old Ones, but the unholy and arcane arts of transistors, CRTs, and low-fat yogurt. [Edit: typo.]
- pw0ncakes 17y agoPeople here are exaggerating the fatness of the average American. Yes, obesity is an unsightly problem, but the man in that photo would still be a stand-out today-- just less of one. Instead of being someone we'd only see in a circus, he's the noticeably obese fat guy in the line at McDonalds. He's definitely not sideshow-freak material today, but he'd definitely be the fattest person on an average subway car. I'd eyeball him at 350-400 pounds. Also, one thing to keep in mind regarding the rightward tail is that, once you cross into the 400+ pound range, you're at constant risk of weight-related death, regardless of age. We can now keep people at that weight alive into their 50s and 60s at 500+ pounds. A hundred years ago, most of them would have died long before getting to the "circus-worthy" range (700+) today.
- nandemo 17y agoHe's definitely not sideshow-freak material today, but he'd definitely be the fattest person on an average subway car. I don't get your point. He might be the fattest in a subway car, but the point is that there's another like him in just about every subway car. One hundred years ago the fat guy was (say) 1 in a 100_000; nowadays it is 1 in 100.
- gcb 17y agoso, Botticelli ladies were the photoshoped playmates of the time?
- GFischer 17y agoI think I heard mentioned on art classes that fat equaled wealth, and so fat ladies might be desirable. But you have a point.
- troystribling 17y agoBut, they were not obese.
- rauljara 17y agoI had a Bangladeshi friend explain to me ~8 years ago that all the female Bangladeshi movie stars (not to be confused with Bollywood stars) were fat. For most of the population, being thin was a sign of not being able to afford much food, so fat women were the ideal. Just goes to show how subjective certain kinds of beauty are.
- stusmith1977 17y agoDitto, a couple of hundred years ago being pale was fashionable - it meant you were rich enough to not work outside. Nowadays of course, we mostly work indoors - so being tanned is fashionable.
- yangyang 17y agoStill the same in parts of asia (China, India). http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/skinwhitening-adverts-ignite-race-row-in-india-863936.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/skinwhitening-a...
- dnsworks 17y agoIt depends on where you are. I spent 6 months in Jakarta, and due to cultural arbitrage, was able to date incredibly attractive women there because I was pale and fat, and I tend to go for women with darker complexions, who are considered ugly due to the same "working outside" cultural bias.
- adrianwaj 17y agoI had to call the US last night for webhost support (this host needed a call to cancel a domain from being hosted, and an email to add a new one - a paper trail), and as she had to pause between sentences for labored breath, it was then that I felt a little bit sorry for her, but at least she was employed. That was my trip to the circus.
- dpritchett 17y agoShe could have asthma or emphysema. No reason to assume breathing issues are weight related.
- josefresco 17y ago100 years ago you had to visit the traveling circus to see a fat person. Now we just turn on the television and turn to TLC or Discovery Channel to see the same thing. What exactly has changed besides the technology? Any good circus promoter or television producer will find a fatter guy than the last fat guy. I get it, we're all fatter today, but I don't believe this example proves anything.
- tjogin 17y agoYou don't need technology to see what was then considered "freakishly" obese, today. You can just go to any public place. Technology has nothing to do with it.
- Avshalom 17y agoI think the point was that people tune in in massive numbers for say Biggest Loser just to play look at the fat guy. Ditto with anything about the enormously obese on random Discovery channel shows. The money comes from advertisements instead of ticket sales but people are still making money by showing us fat people. At least one implication is that just because people were willing to pay money to see a show that included fat people in 1910 doesn't mean it was actually considered freakish any more than it is today.
- mrshoe 17y agoClassic: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ljv1knm9N4o#t=5m40s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ljv1knm9N4o#t=5m40s
- TotlolRon 17y agoIt is amazing what people are willing to pay for. (Don't focus on the circus stunt. Instead, pay attention to the business lesson :)
- jrockway 17y agoIn this day and age of cheap video games, movies, and pornography... there is not much of a market for this anymore.
- smallblacksun 17y agoAll those "500 lb mom", "the 1000 pound man" show on the discover channel (and similar), not to mention the Biggest Loser tell me otherwise.
- goodmitton 17y agoBased on that trend, we'll be expected to see 'the 2000 pound man' next.
- staticshock 17y agosociological images recently wrote about this. here's their article, which provides some interesting information omitted by the parent link: http://contexts.org/socimages/2010/02/08/the-last-sideshow-fat-man/ http://contexts.org/socimages/2010/02/08/the-last-sideshow-f... the most interesting omitted point is this: the last Fat Man actually retired as late as 2003
- mikecane 17y agoPeople of Walmart. http://www.peopleofwalmart.com/?p=12413 http://www.peopleofwalmart.com/?p=12413
- gojomo 17y agoI like Walmart, and I've noticed this phenomenon.... though much of my experience may just be noting geographic differences in obesity, as the Walmarts I visit tend to be in the less-urban areas of California, Nevada, or central Texas. I'd love to see guerrilla-installation of some sort of weight-strain gauge under the entrances/exits of major eatery chains, so as to collect and publish data on the average weight of their customers.
- mikecane 17y agoI don't live near a Walmart, but this kind of physique is no stranger in NYC. Just yesterday at a supermarket I saw a pre-teen child about 4-ft high, who was bursting just like that.
- Semiapies 17y agoStop people working behind desks and get them back out in the fields, then stop people taking advantage of national and global markets for food and put them back at the mercy of regional farm production, and you will see far fewer obese people. Mind, that's ignoring the huge pretense of the linked post that the pictured level of obesity is "normal" or "unremarkable" anywhere. Obesity is a medical definition, and most people who meet it look far thinner than that.
- 83457 17y ago"Imagine, if you will, what society would look like if 100 years from now if what passed as spectacularly obese today would not even turn heads at the mall." I don't have to imagine it -- I saw WALL-E
- frankus 17y agoThere's another article on obesity at the site that I like: http://modeledbehavior.com/2010/04/16/hoisted-from-the-comments-obesity-mystery-already-solved/ http://modeledbehavior.com/2010/04/16/hoisted-from-the-comme... Particularly this line: > In order to stay within one pound of your current weight > over a year, calories-in have to match calorie-out with > 99.7% accuracy. The calorie testing equipment that > determines what goes on food labels is not even that > accurate, so it seems implausible that people are > achieving this through conscious equation of calories-in > with calories-out.