10 ms·
Obama ends NASA space race with slow road to Mars
- gaius 17y agoDude should have committed to delivering something within his Presidency. 2030 is a long way off.
- colinplamondon 17y agoHe's the President of the United States, not 'Dude'.
- gaius 17y agoSorry, "His Majesty", "The Chosen One", "The Messiah" or whatever his adoring fans call him. "Someone will do something at some point" is just more typical dithering from this lame-duck president. In office but not in power, we say in England.
- riffic 17y ago"Mr. President" will do.
- amanfredi 17y agoI thought it was funny.
- krschultz 17y agoGo over to Digg with drivel like this. You obviously dislike his policies but even when I disliked President Bush I still was respectful. Hacker News is a place for intelligent discussion and part of that is civilized discourse. Your second sentence shows the depths of your ignorance of American politics. "this lame duck president" just passed a bill that liberals have been trying to pass for 30 years. Not exactly "in office but not in power". If you want to see what that looks like, see 2006-2008 of the Bush administration and their inability to pass ANYTHING.
- natrius 17y agoLots of people gave their lives for people to be free to call their democratically elected leader "dude". Unless you're interacting with the president in a professional context, it shouldn't matter at all what you call him (barring certain epithets and "Hitler").
- colinplamondon 17y agoObviously we shouldn't prosecute people who call the President Dude, but I do think that a level of respect is called for with all our Presidents. It's a pet peeve of mine when people call President Bush 'King George' or other epithets, even if I do disagree with his policies.
- natrius 17y agoThere's a difference between the need for more civil discourse and the need to address people by their titles. Uncivil discourse is unproductive, but I don't think "dude" is particularly uncivil. "King George" is.
- hugh3 17y agoHow about "Your Dudeness" or "El Duderino", if you're not into the whole brevity thing? Petty namecalling is stupid, but "dude" is a sign of (modest) respect. Seriously, as a foreigner I reckon that the office of the President of the United States needs to be taken down a few notches. I mean, I accept that the dude needs a private jet, but does it really have to be a 747 and called Air Force One? I accept that the dude needs a limo instead of driving himself around, but does it really need to be a custom-built limo? I accept that the guy can have a nice executive mansion, but does he really need his own seal, his own theme tune and a standing ovation every time he shows up to talk to Congress?
- jfager 17y agoBecause what we all really want from our politicians is a focus on short-term bullshit that they can run the next campaign on.
- gaius 17y agoYou want to do anything in the long term, you have to do something in the short term first.
- dackmilliken 17y agoSuch as prepare and set goals?
- yellowbkpk 17y agoIt sure would be nice to have something to get our younger people excited about science. When my parents were kids it was the Apollo mission and astronauts, when I was a kid it was computers and the Internet. My younger sister doesn't get excited about either of those things anymore: why would she? She's been able to sit in front of a computer and video-chat with people across the country and world since she was able to walk. Obama's plan seems to say "Your newborns might have the space program to be excited about ... when they're 18 years old."
- JabavuAdams 17y agoThere's a new space race going on right now. It's being done by private enterprise on budgets from $1M to $100M. Check out: Armadillo Aerospace XCOR Aerospace Masten Space Systems Unreasonable Rocket Scaled Composites SpaceX Blue Origin If you want to talk to rocketeers who are actually building hardware, today, check out the arocket mailing list. We don't need another space race to a destination. We need to build space infrastructure. It's the difference between trying to get from the east coast of the US to the west with one wagon train, versus building railways and towns. That first wagon might just make it, but it doesn't help the next wagon.
- josefresco 17y agoThis new space race might as well be a soap box derby in comparison to our military's space budget. While 100M might seem like a lot of space bucks, our Air Force has a roughly $12 billion dollar space budget which dwarfs what we spend on NASA or any of these private space ventures. I wouldn't worry about space spending, or space infrastructure when our AF is spending oodles to put weapons and craft into space.
- jcromartie 17y agoAfter seeing how some Gov't contracts play out, I can see a private space project getting much further on far less money.
- JabavuAdams 17y ago
- kingkawn 17y agocmon fellas, this is economics. maybe if you can mount a convincing hoax that Al Qaeda is trying to infiltrate Mars, we'll dump a few billion into it. Or maybe, more plausibly, if China decided to do increasingly elaborate manned-space flights, it might push us to follow suit.
- kebaman 17y agoPerhaps saving planet earth and kick starting clean alternative energy will be what excites the current or near future generation. After that, outer space exploration will still beckon. I can only hope I'm around to watch.
- DrJokepu 17y agoWhat I find quite funny about that is that for America, it will take 25 years to get to the Mars. In the meanwhile, my home town has been building a new subway line for the last 25 years and it's still far from being operational.
- tgerhard 17y agoI live in the Central Florida/Space Coast area, and there is a palpable fear that soon all these aerospace jobs will be gone with nothing to fall back on in a crappy economy. This speech was meant to be encouraging to a broad constituency of a state Obama and the Democrats need for future elections. As far as science goes, the better-faster-cheaper ethos NASA had with the Mars Rovers should be revived. Robots are a terrific way to get actual science done. That said, the lessons learned from building and working on the ISS would be a good starting point for creating a vehicle to take people to Mars - a place we can eventually make habitable (http://www.users.globalnet.co.uk/~mfogg/zubrin.htm http://www.users.globalnet.co.uk/~mfogg/zubrin.htm).
- lkijuhyghjm 17y agoSo you want faster-better-cheaper using COTS technologies but also want to keep the 1000s of pork-barrel in my state Nasa jobs ?
- jerf 17y agoI don't see where tgerhard claimed that was a desirable outcome. I only see tgerhard reporting on the opinion others have from a position of knowledge. I live in Michigan, half my family works for car companies one way or another, and I was and am still against the auto bailouts. Locally healthy for me, perhaps, but in my opinion still bad policy for the country. (My point not being that I want to debate that point, but that location does not have to dictate opinion.)
- lkijuhyghjm 17y agoSorry, wasn't meant personally - but you get the point. Q; How many states DON'T have a Nasa facility?
- rbanffy 17y agoAfter 50+ years of pork barrel? I would bet on "none".
- 17y ago
- Qz 17y agoI think the asteroid landing plan is a smart one over the Mars goal. I think we're more obsessed with Mars than is due -- asteroids offer a wealth of potential resources without the immense cost of dropping into and climbing out of a planetary gravity well. Even a landing on one of Mars' fake-moons would be a better choice than Mars itself. Assuming we don't inadvertently open up the gates to hell or something like that...
- markbnine 17y agoFake moons? Phobos and Deimos? Not sure how they are fake. Yeah, gravity sucks, but I find a trip to Mars far more interesting than one to an asteroid, E.g. the geology, water resources, valles marineris, the potential for life, colonization. Why not be obsessed?
- ugh 17y agoWhat’s great about those asteroid landings is that they are relatively easy and nevertheless exciting enough. Much more exciting than the ISS or anything happening in low earth orbit. I think that’s the most important purpose of manned spaceflight. Robots will be able to tell you pretty much everything about geology, water and the potential of life on Mars.
- rbanffy 17y agoA robot cannot stand on the tallest volcano of the solar system and tell you how it felt. Robots can tell a lot, but not everything. Exploring is not only knowing what's there, but actually experiencing it in human terms. The richness of the reports from astronauts on the Moon cannot be approached by what a robot can tell you. Also, a robot can only answer the questions it was designed to answer and, thus, it embodies, in its own construction, a series of assumptions about its target environment that may be completely off. Humans are an extremely valuable resource.
- ugh 17y agoI agree. The right strategy is to put humans on Mars. The right tactic is to now focus on achievable goals.
- whyenot 17y agoI've never understood why it's so important for humans to go to mars. We live on a planet where many people still endure tremendous suffering due to starvation, disease and war. In the next 50 years we will very likely have to begin large scale geo-engineering in order to mitigate climate change and ocean acidification. Prestige "science" like sending people to the moon and mars is a luxury.
- jeebusroxors 17y agoWhere do you stop? I spent 5 bucks on lunch today. Should I have not eaten because people are hungry? What about the computer and internet you typed this on? Should we have not invested in those and spent all the money on curing disease?
- lispm 17y agothat would be great
- PostOnce 17y agoI can't believe how insensitive you are. Do you know how many kids that computer you're using could feed? Sell that computer and buy orphan food. Right now. Otherwise you're Hitler.
- colinake 17y agoNASA has shown itself incapable of meeting deadlines or staying within budget on many projects, and Obama is right to turn access to Low Earth Orbit over to commercial companies (on fixed price contracts, not the normal cost plus contracts). We've been building the same boring "get us to orbit" rocket since the 1960s. Wouldn't NASA's leadership (doing science and developing technologies that private companies cannot afford) be better spent on LEO and out? The moon, asteroids, Mars, Phobos, etc. This is a great plan. It's a Good Thing for the aerospace economy in the long run even if there's going to be some displacement in the meantime. It also opens the door for entrepreneurial companies - building rockets, engines, payload integrators, whatever - to make money in a way previously not possible. It's impossible to make money when the government is competing with you. This is a great thing for entrepreneurs, scientists, researchers, and people everywhere. There's a better chance your kid will be struck by lightning than be a NASA astronaut, but now the door has opened and we'll see private astronaut corps pop up from a few different sources. Get behind this plan, folks. It's a Good Thing and great for other entrepreneurs, even if we're not building web software. :)