3 ms·
> I don't believe this is completely true. How does an economic disparity happen? Colonialism, originally, then maintained due to the geopolitical interests of
by lazaroclapp 10y ago
> I don't believe this is completely true. How does an economic disparity happen?
Colonialism, originally, then maintained due to the geopolitical interests of the wealthier power.
I mean, sure "material factors or cultural, ideological, or philosophical factors" play a part in there somewhere. But the main cultural factor is that New Spain was set up as a colony of extraction for the Spanish empire, with the majority of the population as "conquered" indigenous people. The U.S. was a colony of settlement, populated by mostly Englishmen who were by far the first to obtain any sort of citizenship rights in the U.S. This gave rise to dramatically different political and legal institutions, that after independence gave quite a leg up to the U.S. vis a vis Mexico. The U.S. leveraged that leg up to: annex one third of the Mexican territory (including some of its currently richer areas, like California), intervene in Mexican politics (see. Monroe Doctrine, and Cold-War Era support for single party rule).
Sure, the crony politicians and cartels are Mexican, but the U.S. also had clientelism and Mafia just about a hundred years ago, and is not like the cartels' weapons and the government logistic support doesn't come from up north (not to mention the market for drugs...). What the U.S. didn't have to go through, in the same period: Conquest (unless you are Native American), Encomienda/Exploitation (unless you are African American), Dictatorship, Two foreign interventions, 70 years of single party rule...
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoI notice this about a lot of Latin America. I'm not a historian, but my understanding is despite being a small minority, Creole (whites born in Latin america) people still dominate the political and economic spheres. The wave of revolutions in Latin America were mostly led by them because they stood to benefit most in the new order and that continues today. From my travels, I've found that Latin America is just a little bit more colonial in nature with private citizens/corporations having more power than here in the US. For instance, the idea of a private, unregulated paramilitary/militia group being allowed to operate is an anathema. It's also slightly more misogynistic. I'm painting with a very broad brush. For instance, I find countries like Bolivia to be very progressive with regards to their drug policy and courageous for standing up to the US, asserting their rights and traditions vis a vis Coca leaf production. American drug policy is so schizophrenic as it is willing to take drastic measures to ensure compliance while also being far and away the world largest consumer of narcotics. Yes, I just finished bringing on Narcos terms of t