3 ms·
Every time. Every time I read some post by someone about how they were treated unfairly by some company or another, upon further inspection they are not tellin
by ars 10y ago
Every time.
Every time I read some post by someone about how they were treated unfairly by some company or another, upon further inspection they are not telling the whole truth. (Usually not outright lies, just not the complete story.)
Every time.
Oh well. I like myself better when I believe people, so I'll continue to do that anyway despite logic saying not to.
- rizzom5000 10y agoI was thinking something similar when the story originally came out. There simply wasn't any evidence of any wrongdoing by anyone, but the mob was ready to pull out the pitchforks: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12646919 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12646919 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12680131 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12680131
- mitchty 10y agoIt fits a certain narrative that certain groups want to promote about apple. The story just became a vehicle to vent about preexisting gripes about them. Note how you see statements like walled garden etc, when this can also be couched as removing developers that game the system.
- kbenson 10y agoI don't know. I still think those crazy Verizon cancellation/customer support calls that were circulating a few years ago probably weren't hiding too much.
- fizzbatter 10y ago> I like myself better when I believe people, so I'll continue to do that anyway despite logic saying not to. Well put. For what it's worth though, i tend to view cases like this with skepticism. I mainly think of it as, why believe PersonA over PersonB - it's a technical decision at that point, not a personal judgement. It's a little more difficult when it's John Doe vs Apple, ie a human vs a corporation, but ultimately i still don't picking sides without hard evidence. He said she saids rarely add up, regardless of guilt.
- blub 10y agoSo basically you seem to judge situations poorly, but seem to insinuate that customer complaints are often not justified. That may be, and that's why it's a good idea to wait for proof. People saying "I told you so" or "Every time" are missing the point and not helping.
- nbm 10y agoThere's a weird power imbalance in these situations. The person reporting the problem is able to tell whatever story they want since they generally don't have a reputation to maintain (and will, if anything, likely improve their reputation), and the company has to be very careful - it's often better to not release any detail to avoid potentially worse fallout from releasing potentially private information (yes, the privacy of the person making the complaint). This is especially bad when your company is on the receiving end, and you know the truth. For example, a previous company had someone making claims that some purchase was made on their credit card without their knowledge - but there was account email confirmation at account creation time, account email conversation with community support, actual logical proof from the post itself of something that required said purchase, and so forth. In another case, an account is closed due to some clearly provable illegal behaviour, but it was blamed on not paying to renewing something optional. So since then I'm perfectly capable of neither believing nor disbelieving claims made by people, even when it happens to agree with what I was thinking already. It doesn't make me feel better or worse than believing them, I just assume I don't have the information necessary to make any real judgement about it. Life lesson, I guess, and useful to not get sucked into things like political theatre.