3 ms·
It's probably time for us to rediscover logic as a fundamental skill. But that's a prerequisite or corequisite to computational thinking.
by Jtsummers 10y ago
It's probably time for us to rediscover logic as a fundamental skill. But that's a prerequisite or corequisite to computational thinking.
- zingermc 10y agoYes! Propositional logic and conditional/indirect proof strategies should be taught before any kinds of "proofs" are taught to students (I'm looking at you, trigonometry).
- Jtsummers 10y agoRight. It's briefly introduced in geometry (or used to be) in the typical US high school curriculum, but not thoroughly and not as a distinct concept from geometry. It deserves its own sequence of material, and it should be applied to multiple areas so students can see the value of it more easily. When the only application is geometry, and they hate geometry, they won't care about the "tool" being used.
- ooqr 10y agoAristotelian logic can and should be taught at the elementary school level. Bring back the Socratic method while we're at it! And Euclid's Elements! The Greeks contributed well to education.
- internaut 10y agoUsed to be taught in the 19th century and early 20th century, along with rhetoric and the classics. I think we made a great mistake by getting rid of them.
- js8 10y agoNo, the fundamental skill is the ability to convince other people that you have the fundamental skill.
- Jtsummers 10y agoI didn't say the, I said a. What you refer to would be an aspect of rhetoric, another fundamental skill.
- js8 10y agoComing from a language that doesn't really have articles, I was wondering if I should use "the" or "a". I think I could use both, because it cannot be proven that there is only fundamental skill with that property, or that they cannot support each other. Anyway, my comment was a social commentary - it doesn't seem that pure logic is really what ultimately matters in human society, sadly. That is, if some other people are using logic wrong, you will also gain if you use it wrong in order to convince them. Although I would also say that empiricism is much more important to rationalism (logic). There are many ideas that seem very logical, yet they are very bad, because people intuitively misunderstand some aspect of reality in their model.