8 ms·
The problem with US/Mexican "relations" isn't cultural, ideological or philosophical it's mostly due to the economic disparity between the 2 nations and a city
by dogma1138 10y ago
The problem with US/Mexican "relations" isn't cultural, ideological or philosophical it's mostly due to the economic disparity between the 2 nations and a city won't change it.
There are already places where the US and Mexico effectively share a cross border municipality/urab environment.
Adding another one won't change anything it can either create a false state if only the richest of Mexicans move in or will result in the same state as many other border urban areas right now where the Mexican side provides cheap day labor and a "safer" platform for criminal activity due to the financial disparity.
- jackcosgrove 10y agoSo how do you solve a problem like that? The best solution is to make Mexico richer, which a lot of corporations are doing by moving operations there. A city like this is proposed to speed this along, with the eventual goal of dissolving the border. I think it would succeed in its goal of increasing trade and integration. The solution we've pursued thus far does indeed make Mexico richer, but it also makes parts of the US poorer. That's a big problem as we've found out this election, and one which both political parties discounted, the Republicans moreso since apparently the nationalist faction of their coalition is larger than the labor faction of the Democrats' coalition. You can justify current policy with utilitarianism (net welfare of the planet is maximized by globalizing as fast as possible) and realpolitik (we're going to globalize as fast as we possibly can without losing elections). However whenever change occurs too quickly over the will of the people, there is a reaction and we came very close to upsetting the apple cart this election. I think the opinion makers should set about trying to ameliorate the dislocations caused by globalization rather than trying to accelerate it. The latter course smacks of indifference and hubris.
- ZoF 10y agoThis is really well stated, completely agree.
- ihsw 10y ago> the Republicans moreso since apparently the nationalist faction of their coalition is larger than the labor faction of the Democrats' coalition. Trump is grabbing votes from the labor faction more than any past Republican candidate -- his stance clearly taps into the American psyche, that American exceptionalism is real and that every American company should put American workers first. Jobs, jobs, jobs! is a great platform to run on. Increasing net welfare of the planet by globalizing as fast as possible would undeniably end in failure as the resources would not at all be redistributed evenly, as can currently be seen as plain as day. Globalization is a threat to everybody as it increases instability across the board except for the very wealthy. There is value in retreating to isolationism.
- jackcosgrove 10y ago> Globalization is a threat to everybody as it increases instability across the board except for the very wealthy. Globalization benefits the wealthy and global poor, the latter the most. The losers are the middle and working classes of developed countries. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/07/people-are-angry-about-globalization-this-chart-explains-why/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/07/people-are-angry-abou... See Figure 4.
- ihsw 10y agoWhy do we let this happen? How is it the responsibility of the American people? This is a prime example of a tragedy of commons -- we are depleting the resources of America at the expense of Americans. The return on investment just isn't there. I'm not going to deny that lifting hundreds of millions of foreigners out of poverty is noble but why does the entirety of America's middle class have to be hollowed out? Those foreigners being lifted out of poverty aren't paying taxes to the US, they don't deserve the help they're getting, and the very wealthy aren't at all paying their fair share of taxes. To say that wealth will simply be created by a burgeoning middle class through replicating the Chinese model is delusional, it implies wealth will simply trickle down and we all know how silly Reaganomics is. China achieved their current status by rabidly enforcing the consumption of Chinese products and services and now they are reaping the benefits, and we have to do the same thing. China prevented their wealth from escaping through isolationist policies, it is clear that this model is the best way to secure our future. Simply lifting people out of poverty without enforcing domestic consumption is suicide by a thousand cuts.
- davidw 10y ago> The solution we've pursued thus far does indeed make Mexico richer, but it also makes parts of the US poorer. Be very careful to note that generally, yes, there are some losers from trade, but that there are more winners: it's a positive sum game. At a theoretical level this means you could take something from the winners, redistribute it to the losers and still come out ahead compared to not having trade in the first place.
- kiliantics 10y agoMexico does not get richer when corporations move their operations there. How does anyone belief this codswallop? Say I own a factory and it makes 100 million dollars gross per year and I have to pay my American workers 40 million dollars and the other running costs are 40 million. Now I've made 20 million in profit. Now I move operations to Mexico and I pay my cheaper workers 10 million dollars. Maybe I lower my product prices a little but I can still make it away with massively larger profits, which is why I moved operations there in the first place! Where is the money going into Mexico in any of this? Sure, the government taxes you but odds are that tax is less than in the US, since you wouldn't otherwise set up there (take a look at Ireland for a good example of this). You probably did some greasing up of politicians to get a good deal and much of that tax money is not reaching the people of Mexico in the form of decent services, as is the case in most government expenditure (US military budget anyone?) Now you say, well I'm hiring Mexican employees who are being paid and can now put that money back into the Mexican economy. This all sounds good in theory but you are paying them the bear minimum that you can (the whole reason you moved over there in the first place, remember) which ionly has to be marginally better, if at all, than the money they were making before you showed up. It's been shown that NAFTA killed local industry in a lot of Mexico because American companies could sell their products more cheaply to the Mexican market, thereby killing the local competition. This forced people to abandon their businesses and work for American companies for pitiful wages. Nothing about this neoliberal form of globalisation is helping to alleviate economic disparity in the world. We have seen inequality increase and real wages stagnate in the time since this whole project started.
- schoen 10y ago> This all sounds good in theory but you are paying them the bear minimum that you can (the whole reason you moved over there in the first place, remember) which ionly has to be marginally better, if at all, than the money they were making before you showed up. But haven't you increased the aggregate demand for labor in Mexico, since people who came to work in your factory are no longer doing other jobs? So either total employment could increase as other people start to do those jobs, or wages could rise more than marginally. (If Google comes to town somewhere and hires away the whole IT department from a local hospital -- even for a 1% pay rise -- presumably the hospital will now be looking to hire some new IT staff.)
- aaron-lebo 10y ago> The problem with US/Mexican "relations" isn't cultural, ideological or philosophical it's mostly due to the economic disparity between the 2 nations and a city won't change it. I don't believe this is completely true. How does an economic disparity happen? Through material factors or cultural, ideological, or philosophical factors. Mexico for various reasons has had an incredibly difficult time having a stable political system. Santa Anna came back from exile and screwed his people over how many times? How many times did power violently sway back and forth between the liberals and conservatives in the early part of the 20th century? Why is Mexico now effectively a narco state ruled by the cartels and crony politicians? I'll give you a hint: it's not because of resources or good land or good people: all of which it has in plenty. Mexico should be booming due to NAFTA. So much of this development we now see in East Asia could have very easily gone right across the border if it had a working political system. No, there's clearly bigger issues. Building a new city on the border isn't going to fix that. We already have Juarez.
- ubernostrum 10y agoWell, land does have a lot to do with it, historically. Or rather, the people who controlled the land vs. the people who didn't control the land is the source of a lot of the historical instability in Mexico, which really ought to be a warning to people who argue that inequality and dispossession are perfectly fine and expected consequences of a good system.
- dmix 10y ago> which really ought to be a warning to people who argue that inequality and dispossession are perfectly fine and expected consequences of a good system. A "good system" doesn't just mean rewarding the top contributors with more but also implies the existence a strong and fair legal system where human, business, and property rights are respected and criminal law is enforced. That is almost always a necessary prerequisite for capitalism to function (even Adam Smith wrote about this quite a bit in the 1700s) but capitalism usually gets faulted regardless - even when market economies are pigeonholed on top of a) purposefully neglectful authoritarian states or b) places with under-developed legal systems. There have been plenty of cases in Mexico where rightful owners of land were 'dispossessed' and this didn't happen as a result of a functioning free-market system (which is what I believe you were taking a swipe at). Whether the land rights were fairly distributed or respected post-colonization is also not a cause/effect result of a market economy but a result of the functions of the state/legal system. It certainly won't help either when responsibility is post-defacto shifted onto markets where the powerless poor will have even less authority than in courts or government. Stealing a bunch of stuff then shifting previously centralized authority/responsibility over to markets is a sadly common tactic in underdeveloped regions, not surprising there was such hostility towards capitalism in South/Central America in the past 60 yrs where it was rushed in without addressing underlying systemic issues (see also: Russia and parts of eastern europe in 80/90s).
- yummyfajitas 10y agoNo, the problem is simply political. Mexicans and their American descendents vote D. D's want more Mexicans, R's don't want that. There's nothing whatsoever wrong with a shared economic area and huge economic disparity. Consider Bombay, Bangalore or Pune - all lovely places which bring high skill/high income folks together with low skill/low income folks looking to move up in the world. The result is beautiful modern neighborhoods like Koramangala, Bandra or Koregaon park, up and coming areas (described by westerners as "slums") like Dharavi or Baiganwadi, and free trade that benefits everyone. You have rich Parsis/Gujus moving in and working at banks, smart Tamils working in software, poor Biharis driving their Ubers, and everyone benefits. Do you think Bombay should close her borders to Bihar, or even inland Maharashtra? The only big issues are political externalities - i.e., Mexicans might vote for politicians that make the US more like Mexico. That's an issue even in the US (California refugees voting for CA-like policies in their new states), and is best solved with disenfranchisement/reduced democracy rather than trade barriers.
- hx87 10y ago> California refugees voting for CA-like policies in their new states That depends on which CA refugees you're talking about--the ones who fled when it was undergoing a red -> blue transition, or the ones that were priced out? The former are political refugees and tend to vote for very anti-(current)-CA policies, whereas the latter aren't exactly analogous to Mexican immigrants in the US--they love everything about CA except the price and are trying to create low-cost CAs in exile, whereas Mexicans are escaping more structural problems and are in no hurry to recreate the conditions that made them left.
- aaron-lebo 10y ago> Mexicans and their American descendents vote D. D's want more Mexicans, R's don't want that. GWB got over 40% of the Hispanic vote in 2004. Mexicans tend to be very conservative. That's the truth in California as much as it is in the South. These conservative roots match the Republicans more so than the Democrats, but it's the immigration stance that has tilted Hispanics towards the Democrats, but only recently, and even that is probably a temporary thing. The notion that the Democrats have Hispanic (and especially Mexican) voters locked up isn't a reality. > The only big issues are political externalities - i.e., Mexicans might vote for politicians that make the US more like Mexico. That's an issue even in the US (California refugees voting for CA-like policies in their new states), and is best solved with disenfranchisement/reduced democracy rather than trade barriers. To be clear, regardless of your political stance or your views on immigration, not giving illegal immigrants the right to vote is not the same as disenfranchisement or reduced democracy. For legal migrants, am not aware of anything showing actual attempts at disenfranchisement.
- stcredzero 10y agoeffectively share a cross border municipality/urab environment For a moment, I thought this was a new slang word I hadn't run across yet.
- dogma1138 10y agoNo, it's not that common in the US there are a few spots like Juarez tho. In Europe this is known as Eurodistricts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurodistrict https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurodistrict, there are also similar things in Asia but again slightly rarer.
- cpeterso 10y ago"Weird fiction" author China Miéville wrote an interesting detective novel, "The City & the City", about two cities that occupy the same geographical space and the implications that has for daily life and government operations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_City_%26_the_City https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_City_%26_the_City
- cloudjacker 10y agoI think it would be a nice change of pace to have a wealthy border city. US perceptions of Mexico are - as you mentioned - inaccurately skewed towards a disenfranchised class of Mexicans, notably absent of the privileged class that is completely content with Mexico.