4 ms·
This seems like a bit of an unfair comparison. The 'decades ago' solution was a system, built by humans, that can solve this problem (and very closely related o
by taneq 10y ago
This seems like a bit of an unfair comparison. The 'decades ago' solution was a system, built by humans, that can solve this problem (and very closely related ones), whereas this solution is a system, built by humans, that can design a system to solve the problem.
- cscurmudgeon 10y agoNo, it is not an unfair comparison. Those systems were not hand crafted. They were implemented via first-order logic theorem provers. FOL theorem proving is Turing complete and extremely expressive. This not a me vs you camp. Just a scientific statement.
- bluetwo 10y agoI agree with the point taniq makes in that those easier systems did in fact require a lot of hand crafting, even if parts were automated. I find it interesting the points at which the usefulness of these approaches plateaus. I am interested a lot in general game playing, and there is a common problem that while the general systems tend to make interesting progress, it is the systems finely crafted to the game that win competitions. What I am really, REALLY interested in is what commercial application exist for these types of technologies. Solving a puzzle slightly better than a different tool is fun, but solving a valuable business problem is where the money is at.