3 ms·
> provides a soft launch for anything you might want to do Similar argument gets thrown a lot when advocating a minimum wage raise, for instance, and on surfac
by prostoalex 10y ago
> provides a soft launch for anything you might want to do
Similar argument gets thrown a lot when advocating a minimum wage raise, for instance, and on surface it seems clear - a person with $11 in his pocket has more buying power than someone with $10.
The question is why hasn't that previous wage increase cause a long-term boom in economic activity? The answer is that eventually it gets priced in. Whether into the cost of housing, cost of food, cost of daycare, cost of healthcare, newer car or a cable package that now has Showtime.
The retail industry is quick to anticipate any cash influx and appropriate not only immediate cash, but future cashflows as well, which explains so many "tax refund day" sales at mattress stores and car dealerships come April.
- sheepmullet 10y ago> The answer is that eventually it gets priced in It gets priced in because work (especially min wage work) is heavily location dependent.
- prostoalex 10y agoDo you foresee large movements of population to cheaper geographies (Detroit, Mississippi, Alabama) given freedom from employment? Why are we not experiencing it with the population segments currently receiving a fixed monthly income (social security, disability, annuities)?
- morgante 10y ago> Why are we not experiencing it with the population segments currently receiving a fixed monthly income (social security, disability, annuities)? We are. Moving to a cheaper locale is an extremely common part of retirement.
- jfoutz 10y agoBecause $1 * 77 million workers * 2000 hours is only $160 billion dollars? The department of labor said "Research suggests that a minimum-wage increase could have a small stimulative effect on the economy as low-wage workers spend their additional earnings, raising demand and job growth, and providing some help on the jobs front." I don't think anybody claimed there would be a boom. BI on the other hand, might. With minimum wage you're still spending all day working. it's tough to be enthusiastic about much of anything beyond a book or a video game (or it was for me). I would guess A few people would do nothing. Most people would try a bunch of different stuff and kind of suck at it. A few people would have moderate success. And finally the occasional superstar. Pretty much the same expected outcomes as venture capital, but way way more breakevens. edit Oh, you're making the argument that because the cost of labor increases everything gets more expensive. That's true, but it's in proportion to the labor cost of the thing. Tomatoes are labor intensive, so they cost more. Pasta is mostly automated, so it doesn't go up as much. Relative pricing changes, making books and computers cheaper in terms of tomatoes.
- empath75 10y agoRaising minimum wage raises salaries all the way up the chain, as retail staff now make as much as assistant managers, then assistant managers get a raise and make almost as much as managers and so on.
- jfoutz 10y agowell, if the bottom rung gets 10%, the next one up gets 5%, then 2.5% and so on till you hit the top, where you probably get 20-50%. which sounds horrible but is a tiny fraction in an organization with tens of thousands of people. But again, that only affects prices to a degree that labor is a component. 10% across the board at Ford is .1% increase in the price of a car.
- gozur88 10y agoTomatoes are actually a good case study for wage increases. The last time we had a serious effort to curb illegal immigration we got the usual "crops rotting in the fields" rhetoric from growers, but somehow they lost the political argument. Wages went up due to the resultant labor scarcity. So growers introduced Roma tomatoes, which are not labor intensive because they can be machine harvested. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3EpFTyN26E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3EpFTyN26E
- prostoalex 10y agoThe growers still managed to squeeze in a bunch of exemptions from the minimum wage law https://www.dol.gov/whd/regs/compliance/whdfs12.htm https://www.dol.gov/whd/regs/compliance/whdfs12.htm
- lukeschlather 10y ago> The answer is that eventually it gets priced in. There's really not a lot of data supporting this statement. For the most part, minimum wage has remained pretty static between $5-15 in inflation-adjusted dollars. We do have a significant counterexample which disproves your thesis from the early 20th century - minimum wage was set at 25 cents (previously there was no minimum wage) and increased 5 cents per year until it reached 40 cents. So that's at least an 80% increase, and all of this during a big economic recovery. Obviously the WWII boom was also a factor, but the nation went from abject poverty to boom times in a scant 20 years, and I don't think you can say that the minimum wage was eroded. To the contrary, it set the standard of living that has prevailed to this day. Frankly, a market crash precipitated by a minimum wage hike has never happened, and I don't think it would happen. The worst case scenario you posit is modest inflation. That sounds like a pretty tame worst-case scenario, and well worth the risk if we can do what FDR did again, and raise the minimum standard of living for the next century.
- prostoalex 10y agoI'd have to ask you more about the details, i.e. which decades you're referring to, and how much of the recovery was simply cyclical (with Black Friday being the rock bottom), but two observations about using that time period as an example: 1) People had limited or no access to credit facilities, and therefore had little ability to accrue large household debts. One of the phenomena that bothered the economists ever since the dip in oil prices is why isn't US retail sector booming as expected - cheaper gas historically led to more shopping. I am on mobile to google this properly, but eventually they found out that a shopping boom has happened, except slowly and over a previous decade, and most people were using their newfound savings simply to deleverage their credit card debt. 2) The economy was much more localized back then. Local butcher paying the local milkman paying the local seamstress paying the local travel agent paying the local florist paying the local asphalt paver paying the local butcher. The money got recycled. Today the recycling path is more of consumer -> big-box store -> Asian manufacturer.
- WalterBright 10y ago> consumer -> big-box store -> Asian manufacturer -> American real estate -> consumer
- crdoconnor 10y ago>The question is why hasn't that previous wage increase cause a long-term boom in economic activity? It has. The money multiplier of raising the minimum wage is higher than almost any other place you could put the money. Increasing debt levels also spurs economic activity but that can only go on so long. The story of the last 30 years is that debt levels were used to spur economic activity while wages were suppressed. Once debt levels reached a peak, it all ended. In 2008. >The answer is that eventually it gets priced in. It usually leads to a decline in profitability. Dividend income comes down. Share prices come down. Prices do not usually go up: http://www.nber.org/papers/w13996 http://www.nber.org/papers/w13996 The businesses that area threatened by an increase in the minimum wage always put up a big political fight. They simply wouldn't bother if they could just pass the cost on to the consumer.