5 ms·
This is why I think I'm in favor of basic income. With robots doing all our labor, "a job" is not how we can support basic needs like food and shelter. (Money
by jrockway 10y ago
This is why I think I'm in favor of basic income. With robots doing all our labor, "a job" is not how we can support basic needs like food and shelter. (Money still changes hands with robots doing all the work, so we can tax that and use it to fund basic income for everyone.)
This assumes that people want a job because they want the income, not because they want to do something rewarding all day. Not sure how to solve that problem.
- elcct 10y agoBasic income will become new zero. People are creative and for sure will find themselves ways to earn bread.
- duaneb 10y agoZero is a number, not just "small". If you can't buy anything with BI it's worse than worthless.
- bduerst 10y ago>If you can't buy anything with BI it's worse than worthless. That's their point. There are goods and service that have income-elastic pricing. A chief example of this is housing. As income increases, so do housing prices, which is why welfare programs are typically tied to specific goods and services (food stamps, medicare, etc.)
- jfoutz 10y agoThe Milton Friedman model gave you a tax deduction twice as much as the BI check. So, if you're getting $500 a month in BI, but you decide to work a little, up to $1000 dollars in taxes is deductible. The idea is, you always make more money by working. So maybe you sell a painting for $500, 20% taxes would be $100. At the end of the month, you wind up with $450 from BI and $500 from the painting (because you can deduct all the taxes at a 2 for 1 rate). So maybe you're a fancy doctor that makes $10000 a month. to keep things simple taxes would still be 20%, $2000. You get to deduct $1000, from those taxes, because you didn't take any BI benefits. One of the things i think is great about it, it provides a soft launch for anything you might want to do. (I think you know this, but some people sort of miss the "it's better to work" part of BI)
- balls187 10y ago> So maybe you're a fancy doctor that makes $10000 a month. An annual salary of $120,000 is $10,000 a month. No need to be a fancy doctor to pull that salary.
- prostoalex 10y ago> provides a soft launch for anything you might want to do Similar argument gets thrown a lot when advocating a minimum wage raise, for instance, and on surface it seems clear - a person with $11 in his pocket has more buying power than someone with $10. The question is why hasn't that previous wage increase cause a long-term boom in economic activity? The answer is that eventually it gets priced in. Whether into the cost of housing, cost of food, cost of daycare, cost of healthcare, newer car or a cable package that now has Showtime. The retail industry is quick to anticipate any cash influx and appropriate not only immediate cash, but future cashflows as well, which explains so many "tax refund day" sales at mattress stores and car dealerships come April.
- sheepmullet 10y ago> The answer is that eventually it gets priced in It gets priced in because work (especially min wage work) is heavily location dependent.
- prostoalex 10y agoDo you foresee large movements of population to cheaper geographies (Detroit, Mississippi, Alabama) given freedom from employment? Why are we not experiencing it with the population segments currently receiving a fixed monthly income (social security, disability, annuities)?
- morgante 10y ago> Why are we not experiencing it with the population segments currently receiving a fixed monthly income (social security, disability, annuities)? We are. Moving to a cheaper locale is an extremely common part of retirement.
- prostoalex 10y agoHow much of that income would immediately go towards health/dental insurance premiums (or Obamacare penalty for those refusing to join the club)? Healthcare is one of those things that seem to get more expensive as robotics and high-tech labs are introduced into it.
- halugalugh 10y agoBasic income really seems like the path to take when you're a narcissist who wants to appear as though you're guiltily taking the high road. It implies a smugness that you both caused and can solve other peoples' problems. tldr gfy
- visarga 10y ago> Not sure how to solve that problem. TL;DR - Instead of UBI, how about self reliance? Instead of UBI, wouldn't be better to empower people and communities of people directly by providing financial help and technology, including automation. Each community, city or country needs to be self reliant and not need much external financial help. If a city has enough land to cultivate its food, it can build a vertically integrated economy, with everything necessary for its citizens to live by. People would be directly involved in providing for themselves, using automation as well. They would not feel robbed of their agency and self determinacy. Practical measures to achieve that would be: to invest in energy tech such as solar, make sure automation and 3d-printing are open source and easy to employ, heavily tax imports in order to encourage reliance on local production, tax automation and AI, provide financial help for local projects, provide healthcare and education for free. With all those in place, the need for UBI would be much reduced. If people were left with no jobs and insufficient social protection they would not simply roll out and die. They would associate to find alternative means such as self sustaining farm communities, some of them would provide professional services to others, creating a human-based parallel currency. Such communities could invest what they had before into the common pool and have their own capital. With capital they can have the ability to use automation as well. What is essential is that the entry barrier to AI and automation be made low, in order to empower everyone.
- Grishnakh 10y agoThis doesn't really make sense. If you give a city full of people the money and technology they need to be self-reliant, then how do you make sure a few assholes (the managers) don't take everything for themselves and leave others homeless? If you have automation doing all the actual work, how are people in this city supposed to earn money to survive? After all, who's going to own the financial help and technology that's being provided to the city? The government of course, but then how do you distribute that? Well either you make people work for money, or you give everyone a UBI. Finally, there's no practical way any city can be self-reliant anyway. Humans have relied on trade for millennia now. Cities in the frozen north aren't going to easily be able to grow all their own food, cities in other places won't be the best place to run factories, our entire global economy is run on the idea of specialization of labor, and it's been this way since before Roman times. People specialize in certain things, they form groups (companies) that excel at doing certain things, and then they trade with each other. That's how an economy works. Hindering that isn't going to help anyone, at least until we invent replicators (and no, 3D printers are not like replicators). A low barrier to automation doesn't work because someone has to own the automation, and whoever owns it first has the first-mover advantage and puts everyone else out of business.