3 ms·
There is a classical mechanics missing in the grad school section. One of the primary books used is by Goldstein. I also recommend Classical Dynamics of Partic
by godelski 10y ago
There is a classical mechanics missing in the grad school section. One of the primary books used is by Goldstein.
I also recommend Classical Dynamics of Particles and Systems by Marion and Thornton.
As was mentioned in another post Linear Algebra is a must, and I think David Lay's book is a great one to start with.
As the author mentions, to learn physics you MUST DO PROBLEMS.
On another note I can't seem to find anyone that has mnemonic techniques for learning equations. So if anyone comes across a good method I'd like to hear it. And I'm not just talking about something like "low d high minus high d low, square the bottom and away we go". But to more complex equations, like memorize "memorize Einstein's field equation." A method that could potentially work for any arbitrary equation.
- antognini 10y agoI think the only way to consistently memorize an equation is to deeply understand it. Not just how to apply it, but essentially how to derive it. What motivates it. Why it must take the form that it does. With fundamental physical equations you have to be a little hand-wavy, because they are, well, fundamental, so they can't be derived from anything else. But you can motivate the form of the Schrodinger equation from the classical wave equation. (I should note that Feynman disagrees with this claim, but you can find a nice motivation for the form in Penrose's Road to Reality.) Regardless, going through these motions will serve to embed the form of the equation in your mind. It also helps to write the form of the equation in a number of different ways. Some may be easier to remember than others. Maxwell's equations, for instance, are pretty easy to remember if you write them in terms of the EM stress-energy tensor.
- godelski 10y agoThis is always how I have memorized them, really through repetition (back to doing problems). The thing is that except for the basic ones and ones I use excessively, I forget; I think this is common. In comparison I can remember mnemonic lists of random items created years ago. I can't help but think there is a way to store math information similarly. Because that would suggest that it is a problem with the storage of the information. I've always looked for more effective ways to study. And to counter your suggestion you can definitely fully understand the principles of an equation without being able to remember the equation itself. A simple example of this would be the Laplacian in spherical coordinates. It is easy to understand what is being done and the Cartesian form is trivial (most people have this memorized even) and the spherical can be derived from it simply. Problem is this takes way too much time. I don't think an example like this you could argue that there isn't an understanding of what is going on, just a familiarity issue. And thus how the information was stored. I'd argue that most of those that know this off the top of their head do so from repetition and not because of a better understanding than their Cartesian only counterparts.
- sn9 10y agoMark Eichenlaub's Quora answer to this question [0] should give you much to think about. [0] https://www.quora.com/Do-grad-school-students-remember-everything-they-were-taught-in-college-all-the-time https://www.quora.com/Do-grad-school-students-remember-every...
- selimthegrim 10y agoSurely you mean the Faraday tensor?
- antognini 10y agoYes, you're right, my mistake!
- llamaz 10y agoOften if you understand the equations you can "half re-derive" them from the given information. That is, you can start to work them out from first principles to jog your memory, then write the rest from memory. Other times, e.g. in probability theory, there are just a lot of equations, so even if you do a lot of practice problems, you will not have memorised all the equations. In these cases, usually a formula sheet is permitted on the final exam. Otherwise, you have to study math the same way you do biology - summarising and constant revision.
- godelski 10y agoI'm out of school. But I can't help but think there is a better way. I always get the answer "When you understand it enough you'll have it memorized." I hate this answer because it is easily provable as false. Like my example in the other comment, the Laplacian is an easy concept, but remember it in spherical coordinates isn't trivial like it is in Cartesian. If I can memorize a list of 20 random items for years with minimal repetition I don't see why I can't do this with equations. It isn't about memorizing everything, it is about memorizing what is useful so I don't have to look it up on google every few weeks when I need it. As for testing, when I was in school most classes didn't allow me to have a formula sheet. And anyone that does the physics GRE knows how much has to be remembered. But to me it is more about quick and easy access. Motivation isn't about some test.