9 ms·
If you can't afford a car, then in general you're pretty screwed in American suburbs. If buses even go where you want, you're now talking hours spent trying to
by azinman2 10y ago
If you can't afford a car, then in general you're pretty screwed in American suburbs. If buses even go where you want, you're now talking hours spent trying to do basic things like grocery shopping, let alone attempting to find and work a job (of which there are also less).
Further, don't underestimate the power of white flight. It's happened many a time before.
- rayiner 10y agoOnly 20% of people in public housing in DC have wage income. And many live in food deserts anyway.
- azinman2 10y agoSo then let's continue to make it even harder to live? I don't understand your point. I've seen first hand in Boston how hard it is for someone in public housing to get a job. Can't imagine some random suburb.
- ashark 10y ago> Further, don't underestimate the power of white flight. It's happened many a time before. I think it would be pretty surprising if this hyper-integration plan didn't result in a sudden and substantial drop in the quality of education in the nicer schools (more classroom disruption which is, anecdotally from the several teachers I know, a huge problem in lower-income schools, more teacher time spent catching the new students up, et c.) and I 100% guarantee that any parents, of any color, who could afford to leave those districts to unaffected ones or switch to private schools would do so ASAP. So yeah, white (and/or not-poor) flight, instantly. And probably some fairly intense protest action by any who couldn't afford to get their kids out.
- duaneb 10y agoSo shame them for being classist and racist. Public education is a public investment.
- Kalium 10y agoYou're welcome to shame people moving their kids to better schools as classist and racist. It might work! With that said, I have some doubts that such a policy would accomplish what you might hope for. Most people, even those who wish people wouldn't, understand and sympathize with parents trying to get the best possible education for their kids.
- rayiner 10y ago"Better schools?" They'd be the same schools, just with some additional lower income kids.
- Kalium 10y agoI am operating in the context of a *parent comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12694649 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12694649 I'm open to the possibility that the measured quality of a school does not change if you make significant changes to its constituent populations, but it seems like a large enough question to not be assumed in passing.
- rayiner 10y agoSure going from 1% low income to 10% low income will have the short term effect of changing the overall average test scores. But how will it change the quality of education for the existing students? It'll be the same teachers, same curriculum, same facilities, etc.
- Kalium 10y agoThe educational experience of students is not dictated wholly by teachers, curriculum, and facilities.
- tptacek 10y agoYou are coming dangerously close to implying that children in poorly performing school districts are intrinsically unschoolable. That can't be what you mean to imply, so I think maybe step back and examine how you've ended up in an incoherent position.
- josho 10y agoHave a listen to The Problem We All Live With[1] a podcast episode from This American Life. It speaks to this specifically and comes to very different conclusions. Ie. integration works. [1] http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/562/the-problem-we-all-live-with http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/562/t...
- tptacek 10y agoI live in a city-adjacent suburb in Chicago, Oak Park, directly butting up against Austin, the largest high-crime overwhelmingly black neighborhood in the city of Chicago. Oak Park is tiny and known for its school system. The western side Austin Ave, which divides Chicago from Oak Park, hosts an unbroken row of multi-family dwellings, many of them large apartment buildings. The occupants of those buildings are people who would otherwise live in Austin, but move to Oak Park to get their kids into Oak Park schools. This has been going on for decades in Oak Park, and we continue to have excellent schools, and continue to be a high-status magnet for professionals who want to live somewhere connected to the CTA trains but not part of CPS schools. It doesn't happen in Kennilworth or Wilmette, because those suburbs aren't directly adjacent to troubled neighborhoods in Chicago. But there is absolutely no reason to believe that the carrying capacity for lower-income students of those suburbs --- the majority of Chicago suburbs, which like Wilmette and unlike Oak Park, aren't city-adjacent --- is any less than that of Oak Park. So, no, I don't think your hypothesis about inner-city kids disrupting suburban schools is accurate, nor do I think "instant white flight" is going to happen. "White flight" was an irrational, racist reaction to housing integration. It's not a law of nature; it was/is a growing pain of the US getting over centuries of segregation.
- wyager 10y agoMultiple Houston suburban neighborhoods have been ruined by "integrative" public housing developments. The situation you're describing sounds rather different (more organic, in particular). We also can't expect uniform results across the board. > "White flight" was an irrational What's irrational about it? The suburbs created as a result of "white flight" are objectively vastly safer than the places the now middle-class suburbanites were fleeing from.
- tptacek 10y agoThe dominant economic power reacted to de jure segregation by creating a regime of de facto financially-enforced segregation. It's awfully nervy of you to blame the victims of that effort for its effects.
- wyager 10y ago> It's happened many a time before. And who can blame them? If you started putting a bunch of high-risk no-income people in section 8 housing in a formerly nice neighborhood, any rational person who could afford it would move away.
- thinkmoore 10y ago"High risk, no-income." Really? Section 8 supports the working poor. You need to check your prejudices against reality.
- wyager 10y agoI guess most of them work from home then? I see you go to Harvard, so you have the privilege of being insulated from the realities of publicly supported destitute poverty. I suspect you've never seen massive fights in a section 8 complex, or people setting trash cans on fire, or people smashing windows, or stealing appliances from their own buildings.
- azinman2 10y agoDown the street from Harvard is section 8 housing that I'm sure the GP isn't even aware of, because it looks just like any other building near by. No trash can fires or the like. I used to be a big brother to a kid in that building, so I've been inside many times. None of those things you described were happening.
- duaneb 10y agoIf only the working poor were "high-risk no-income". That would indicate some free time to get into trouble! That would mean they could simply find a job instead of stretching their current ones. This is a classist dogwhistle labeling the poor as lazy, violent people.
- wyager 10y agoI have lived near section 8 housing in Texas. They are not, generally speaking, working. It's also not the kind of place you want to be near at night. "The poor" is not the same as "people who live in public housing". There are a lot of dirt-poor rural areas that are very safe (and generally more employable).