3 ms·
The remote control for my television was an improvement because I didn't have to get up from my chair to change channels and when I got cable, there were a lot
by brudgers 10y ago
The remote control for my television was an improvement because I didn't have to get up from my chair to change channels and when I got cable, there were a lot more channels to hunt. But most things don't need to be tuned because they don't create high bandwidth continuous variable information streams.
My smartphone and television are valuable because they're part of the network. My refrigerator is valuable because it meaningfully reduces my odds of death by food poisoning. The general appeal of configuring things like refrigerators and tea kettles is probably lower than programming the VCR ever was.
I'm skeptical that open protocols will change things much. Mostly because tea kettles are stand alone devices; the benefits of networking them are corner cases; and making them smart adds a lot of incidental complexity and that complexity manifests itself quickly because networks are unreliable.
- Bartweiss 10y agoMy preferred 'program' for my refrigerator is "get cold and stay that way". Turns out I can write that with a ten cent analog knob the day I buy it! I can imagine a world where it's worth programming my refrigerator, but the only possible justification would be that it integrates easily with a fitness band, to-do list, and preferably something else I care about. Ideally, I'd give them all some basic rules from a safe and convenient UI on my computer. I've seen arguments for networking a kettle - usually "hot when you get home" - but I've never believed any of them. The thing takes 30 seconds to boil already, and I have no need to integrate it into my health or planning regimens.
- brudgers 10y agoWhen I imagine the world were I integrate my refrigerator with my shopping list it winds up not containing me. I mean I'd rather integrate my shopping list directly with my grocery store because integrating with my fridge smells like two integrations: there's also the fridge to the grocery store. Adding a fitness band is an n+1 operation in an O(n^2) integration process. And if I consider integrating at the feature level rather than the device level (which is where integration matters) the combinatorials are at the point where the responses can't be canned and the training sets don't exist to tune the integrations to my goals automatically.