4 ms·
Truth is almost never comfortable. And, generally, ignorance is bliss (which is true, however uncomfortable that may be).
by Koshkin 10y ago
Truth is almost never comfortable. And, generally, ignorance is bliss (which is true, however uncomfortable that may be).
- duaneb 10y agoThis is a very strange attitude about truth. What does it have to do with one's comfort level? Not everyone is emotionally invested in understanding the universe. I personally rather enjoy it when the universe surprises me, although again, surprises can be good or bad.
- Koshkin 10y agoAccording to Hitchhiker's Guide, a truth about the universe is that the universe is an extremely big place - so huge, in fact, that our planet and all of us look utterly insignificant in the grand scheme of things. Which, I think, is true, but there is no way I could take comfort in that thought.
- duaneb 10y agoI think the reverse—that humans are somehow meaningful—is far more terrifying.
- notduncansmith 10y agoYou're talking about whether the truth "is comfortable" or not; the truth, fact, the history of the motion of particles through space and time, simply is. The notion of "comfortable" is a filter that exists in the mind, through which you can choose to perceive the truth.
- Koshkin 10y agoThis looks reductionist and therefore most likely is false. Feeling uncomfortable has some objectivity to it, and no amount of "transcendence" can change that which is objective. I was talking about less fundamental truths, such as the realization that one's parents are idiots, life is being wasted, every minute a person is getting murdered somewhere in a most horrifying way, girlfriend is getting ugly, etc. Try to get comfortable with that...
- vorotato 10y agoI think that's the very thing people attempt to achieve when they try to achieve transcendence. Some people enjoy physical pain, so surely it's at least conceivable that one could be comfortable with it.
- notduncansmith 10y agoWell, the feeling of mental discomfort definitely is a physical phenomenon at the neuron level. However, because we have the ability to reflect on our feelings as we feel them, we have the ability to consider them as one signal out of many. The feeling of happiness or sadness or discomfort or fear is a single signal; others include situational awareness, memories, goals, etc (not describing a strict ontology here). My impression of "transcendence" is the ability to consciously take these signals as input, rather than subconsciously by following feelings. The prerequisite to this is a deep understanding of oneself, the different signals one can perceive, and what real-world phenomena correspond to those signals (vs what the signals themselves say). There's also a lot of anecdotal evidence that various psychedelics aid in this process, with one theory being that because they often delay or otherwise distort the link between your perception and reality, you have to think logically about how to compensate for the difference between your perception and what you consciously know to be reality. Throw the especially pensive nature induced by some variants of marijuana or LSD into the mix, and you've got a recipe for enlightenment. By the way, if that sounds plausible, consider that the euphoria associated with consuming those substances may be an evolutionary adaptation. Seeing really is believing; humans have a hard time properly attributing weight to factors they can't directly perceive (even our own suffering isn't enough to motivate us if it's far enough in the future to be abstract to our current selves). As a result, most people don't acquire the ability to consciously perceive their input signals (and compensate for them) until the difference between perception and reality is made literally visible, e.g. by psychedelics.
- solipsism 10y agoYou should end your first sentence with "to me." I find the truth (I'm an atheist nihilist) extremely comforting.
- taneq 10y agoReally? I'd like to hear more about your worldview.
- erik14th 10y agoTruth is almost never comfortable because we come from a world of ideals. If you expect perfect, anything you get is shitty. If you accept you're a conscious imperfect animal, being able to communicate with other conscious beings is in itself a pretty nice deal. You can't change the truth, so it cannot be put as the problem, the problem is the expectations we are given while growing up just to discover most of it is bullshit. You could also try to put the ideal in it's place, as an horizon, something you walk towards in order to progress, but it'd be foolish to expect to get there, let alone demand to be there already.
- rubberstamp 10y agoso should everyone lie to you to make you comfortable? I don't care if truth makes me uncomfortable. It was something I realized as part of growing up. I'd rather be uncomfortable than being told lies and foolishly believing them. At first I thought truth hurts, but it not truth that hurts. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12690423 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12690423
- Koshkin 10y ago> lie to you to make you comfortable People do that all the time, and for a very good reason. Life in a society where everyone only speaks truth would be impossible (which is why, for instance, atheism is not very popular).
- rubberstamp 10y agothat is impossible today only because people now a days don't have wisdom. Only a small minority has the ability to see through the bullshit unimportant noise we are constantly bombarded with. In CS terms, only true data has value and is therefore knowledge. Other data is just noise and is of no value.
- Koshkin 10y agoThat seems to be a very narrow view of what is valuable. Works of fiction have value. Even fairy tales do. (You may argue that even those contain elements of "true data", but still...)
- rubberstamp 10y agoWe both may be trying to make the exact same point. Sorry if the CS analogue caused more confusion. Not all knowledge is considered to have true monetary value. Many kind of business practices is not necessarily knowledge or truth. Some practices are even out right manipulation and ethically illegal. To me valuable is human culture, its history, how we could advance science and tech without its misuse to grab more power etc. As I read more and more, thought about various things that I read, observe things happening around me, read history and think the need of violence and such stuff, it got me various perspectives. I would hate anything but the truth. One's opinion about something is not necessarily truth and we get mostly uncomfortable about someone else's opinion. But dont we not want the true fact even if it is uncomfortable?
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>And, generally, ignorance is bliss (which is true, however uncomfortable that may be). Nah. Ignorance now usually means a whole lot of pain later.