4 ms·
Actually, Moxie has threatened to shut LibreSignal down if they allow LibreSignal users to message normal Signal users, and refused to even discuss alternative
by kuschku 10y ago
Actually, Moxie has threatened to shut LibreSignal down if they allow LibreSignal users to message normal Signal users, and refused to even discuss alternative solutions.
He also uses the GCM library from Google, which pulls in several analytics libraries into the APK, so "Using GCM doesn't make Signal less private." is objectively false.
(And in addition to that, Moxie even refuses to allow any distribution that doesn’t come with full analytics, which is extremely user hostile.)
> Guess complaining is easier.
No, it’s easier to use XMPP than to fix a system that’s broken by design like Signal.
EDIT: Seriously? Downvotes for criticising publicly documented user-hostile behaviour from Moxie? Fuck this, the discussion culture here really got worse than even Reddit.
- StavrosK 10y agoDownvoting this comment without offering a counterpoint is very bad etiquette. Can someone provide a counterargument? Otherwise it's just pretty much censorship.
- mentat 10y agoI do not think "censorship" means what you think it means. Censorship would be moderators deleting something. Making claims without citations is fully in play to downvote.
- StavrosK 10y agoI guess you're right about the censorship part, but still, just downvoting comments without replying is not useful to anyone. The comments above that reply clarifying the situation are much more informative.
- Jarwain 10y agoCould it be because some of your information is spun/misleading? LibreSignal was abandoned according to their github, first of all. Secondly, the issue is that OWS doesn't want "others" using the servers that they own and maintain for Signal.[1] As far as I understand, they disapprove of people using the name Signal or TextSecure or Redphone for their forks, due to confusion by users who believe that the fork is actually the app released by OWS. He doesn't explicitly say whether "LibreSignal" is okay, but would prefer for a namechange to reduce confusion. Afaik, he also encourages people who don't like the GCM build in Signal to swap it out with the rewritten open source one and build with that. [1]https://github.com/LibreSignal/LibreSignal/issues/37#issuecomment-217231557 https://github.com/LibreSignal/LibreSignal/issues/37#issueco...
- kuschku 10y ago> LibreSignal was abandoned according to their github, first of all. Yes, because Moxie threatened in the discussion you linked? > Secondly, the issue is that OWS doesn't want "others" using the servers that they own and maintain for Signal The issue is that Moxie refuses to federate, or allow others the right to develop third party apps interfacing with his server (Which, btw, he can’t prohibit in the EU anyway). > Afaik, he also encourages people who don't like the GCM build in Signal to swap it out with the rewritten open source one and build with that. Yet he threatens anyone trying to distribute an alternative build with it stripped out. How the fuck is that open source development, if you threaten anyone forking it, and don’t allow any PRs that could make it more open, AND refuse to allow federation? That’s not any better than just using Facebook Messenger.
- lorenzhs 10y agoYou're cherry-picking the bits of Jarwain's response that you like to respond to, ignoring the others, yet complain about the discussion culture and being down-voted (which is not appreciated on here) in your original post. Moxie is taking issue with others using the name "Signal", as that would lead to confusion. Forking and using your own name and servers is totally okay with him. And of course you can allow others from distributing apps that use your servers in the EU. There's a difference between using modified code with OWS servers (which might be okay in the EU, IANAL), and distributing apps that interface with OWS servers despite their demand that you do not (which is certainly not okay in the EU).
- kuschku 10y agoForking and using your own servers is exactly one of the things about XMPP Moxie hated si much that he created Signal in the first place! The whole point why Moxie created it is so that everyone is on the same one, to avoid federation issues. > stributing apps that interface with OWS servers despite their demand that you do not (which is certainly not okay in the EU). I'm not a lawyer, but: EU law very specifically allows you to create software interfacing with third party software or services, even if they tell you not to do so, and you can even decompile their software to learn how to do that interfacing (compare §69d UrhG), as long as you don't have to break their ToS doing so. (Which I don't, the only ones possibly breaking the ToS would be the users, and there's also a legal argument that you can't prevent users from modifying the software they use to access your service (see the AdBlockPlus vs. BILD case, LG Hamburg)).
- moxie 10y ago> Moxie has threatened to shut LibreSignal down if they allow LibreSignal users to message normal Signal users, and refused to even discuss alternative solutions. Please cite this. To my knowledge I never threatened anything, and your comment is a response to a quote from the discussion about LibreSignal, where I suggest that they submit a PR with the functionality they desire to Signal. Is that not an alternative? > He also uses the GCM library from Google, which pulls in several analytics libraries into the APK Could you cite this as well? Here's the entire POM file for the version of the GCM library we use: <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> <project xsi:schemaLocation="http://maven.apache.org/POM/4.0.0 http://maven.apache.org/POM/4.0.0 http://maven.apache.org/xsd/maven-4.0.0.xsd" http://maven.apache.org/xsd/maven-4.0.0.xsd" xmlns="http://maven.apache.org/POM/4.0.0" http://maven.apache.org/POM/4.0.0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"> http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"> <modelVersion>4.0.0</modelVersion> <groupId>com.google.android.gms</groupId> <artifactId>play-services-gcm</artifactId> <version>8.1.0</version> <packaging>aar</packaging> <dependencies> <dependency> <groupId>com.google.android.gms</groupId> <artifactId>play-services-base</artifactId> <version>8.1.0</version> <scope>compile</scope> <type>aar</type> </dependency> </dependencies> </project> A single dependency. If you follow it, the only transitive dependency is the supportv4 library. Where are the "several" analytics libraries? > (And in addition to that, Moxie even refuses to allow any distribution that doesn’t come with full analytics, which is extremely user hostile.) What do you mean by "full analytics?" Is there something user hostile about having an aggregate count of the number of users you have on what platforms, so that you can develop and deploy software accordingly? About being able to receive crash reports when users choose to submit them so that you can fix their problems?
- topkeks 10y agokuschku BTFO
- kelnos 10y ago> If they can’t fork it while still using your servers, and you refuse to allow federation, how the FUCK is it open in any way? "Open" doesn't mean you get to use someone else's servers. It just means that the code is there and you can make use of it in your app. There are a ton of things in that code that are valuable and useful as open source beyond the line that lists the URL of their servers.