3 ms·
> As a result, for every great example of brutalist architecture today you can point to 10 others that really are eye-sores. Isn't that just sort of an applica
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
> As a result, for every great example of brutalist architecture today you can point to 10 others that really are eye-sores.
Isn't that just sort of an application of Sturgeon's law?
Although I suppose that given how expensive a building is to put up, there's a lot more push back against ugly things.
- herge 10y agoAnd also, old buildings are prettier on average because the old ugly buildings get torn down and replaced.
- user5994461 10y agoNot sure whether it can apply to this context. The concretes building are fairly recent. Not sure there was enough time to have a sort of "return on investment". And breaking down something of that scale is quite an undertaking.
- at-fates-hands 10y agoNot to mention most of these were made mostly of concrete and steel and built to last a lifetime. Trying to justify tearing down a perfectly fine structure just because its an eye sore becomes a much harder argument to make.
- throwanem 10y agoConcrete has a very hard time lasting more than a few decades anywhere that gets rain, and especially anywhere that gets snow.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 10y agoNot sure. There's boring or uninspiring and then there's outright ugly. Sure, a lot of buildings (most) are meh. But Brutalism managed to create an outsized number of structures that have come to be viewed as actively awful looking.
- Retra 10y agoThey probably looked very pretty in the blueprints.
- lmm 10y ago> Isn't that just sort of an application of Sturgeon's law? I think the "international style" has a much better hit ratio though. So there really was/is something uniquely bad about brutalism. (My pet theory is that it's a style designed to look good in black-and-white photographs - presumably because that's what architects tended to be judged on in those days? - at the expense of looking good in real life)