4 ms·
Strangely enough, I think the solution is in devices like OnHub, Google WiFi, or other third party managed routers (yes, another IOT device). Why? When attacks
by falcolas 10y ago
Strangely enough, I think the solution is in devices like OnHub, Google WiFi, or other third party managed routers (yes, another IOT device).
Why? When attacks like this are first detected, they can be shut down at the source. Known bad devices can be preemptively locked down behind a firewall. Traffic to specific IP addresses, or packets which spoof headers to cause amplification attacks could all be detected and dropped before they even reach the ISP.
Yes, there will be problems and bad diagnoses, no, I don't want one of these managing my home network; but it would be perfect for my mother, for my non-technical friends, and for the average Joe with a subverted IP camera.
- Mister_Snuggles 10y agoThis is actually a really neat idea. In another comment[0] I described how I keep my cameras away from the internet. Someone like Google could easily build something into their routers and firewall them off as they're added to the network. The firewall could allow them to talk to the appropriate cloud service, and nothing else, in order to better secure them without the user even knowing it's happening. This doesn't solve all of the IoT problems, but it does help some for the one described in the article. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12685381 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12685381
- hathawsh 10y agoI like this idea a lot. Perhaps every IoT device should publish a profile of its expected behavior to the router. For example, a wifi-enabled thermostat might tell the router that it only intends to connect to a particular range of servers, by DNS name. The router could then set up an automatic firewall rule that stays in sync with DNS changes. The user should be able to disable that firewall rule (to overcome technical issues), but most users will never have a reason to do so. We could bootstrap this idea by having the router fingerprint IoT devices and apply matching firewall policies from a database. If only we could install "apps" on routers, like we do on Android and iOS devices, someone could get started with this idea right now.
- anchpop 10y agoThe only issue is that after that point, the device can never connect anywhere else.
- ceejayoz 10y agoSo allow the device vendor a way to push a configuration change?
- jrockway 10y agoThen the attacker would push that configuration change before DDoSing someone.
- striking 10y agoYour router would notify you of the change and ask if it was intended before applying it, maybe? I realize how close to Vista's UAC this is getting.
- hathawsh 10y agoWell, I would hope that any IoT device that accepts remote configuration or software updates also checks digital signatures before applying changes. If it doesn't, then I would want the automatic firewall on the router to block all updates.
- ceejayoz 10y agoMake the configuration change come from the approved endpoints.
- bsder 10y ago> Strangely enough, I think the solution is in devices like OnHub, Google WiFi, or other third party managed routers (yes, another IOT device). Until Google decides that your Android traffic get priority over iOS traffic. Which is a more likely problem--a big company trying to control my stuff (see the Phillips LED Light kerfuffle) or my device participating in a botnet? I can mitigate the botnet by turning my device off. Giving a company control of my devices isn't so easily mitigated.