4 ms·
I saw this article on HN this morning at zero comments, and I really expected to drive in to work and get there with 50+ comments going "Yeah! That's right!" I
by jerf 10y ago
I saw this article on HN this morning at zero comments, and I really expected to drive in to work and get there with 50+ comments going "Yeah! That's right!" I had this comment all planned out about how impressive it was to get HN to suddenly line up behind the neocon foreign policy establishment by just saying "Boo Trump!" in the right way.
But it seems I've underestimated HN a bit; my compliments and apologies.
I'll salvage the part where I point out this is basically an appeal to authority appealing to authority, and I don't necessarily trust either of the authorities. I do believe that there are some serious negotiations that take place and that there are things hidden from the public that are more serious than they may initially seem (both in the sense of being important and being treated more seriously than anything that makes the news), but when I look out into the world I still see an awful lot of official foreign policy maneuvers that do not seem to be the result of sober adult calculations for the best of humanity but still very much seem to be games of brinkmanship where the players stand to gain and the public and the world... and not to put to fine a point on it, but me and the ones I love, and you and the ones you love... are the ones that will pay if they lose.
I haven't got much rational reason to trust the current foreign policy community and I've got no rational reason to accept Elizier as an authority on the matter. That is not to say either of those things is false... it is to say that I have no reason to accept them as true, and in the case of the foreign policy community, some rational reasons to distrust them. If I am wrong, because it turns out those are both reliable authorities, then the only rational conclusion is that both of these authorities should have tried much harder a long time ago to give me rational reasons to trust them more. Such things happen.