5 ms·
>I don't know what to suggest other than looking for alternatives to HN. If you refuse to read the posted article, then you should choose not to participate in
by krapp 10y ago
>I don't know what to suggest other than looking for alternatives to HN.
If you refuse to read the posted article, then you should choose not to participate in threads discussing it, rather than wasting valuable thread-space with off-topic complaints about the site's business model.
- lmm 10y agoThread space is unlimited. Space on the HN front page, by contrast, is limited, and I would prefer it were not wasted on paywalled articles.
- krapp 10y agoGiven that other people here seem to be capable of discussing the actual subject at hand, the posting of paywalled articles obviously isn't wasted on the community at large. However, every irrelevant tangent about how terrible paywalls are is a waste of time.
- lmm 10y agoGiven that other people in this thread seem to be capable of disucssing the paywall, complaints about it obviously aren't wasted on the community at large.
- krapp 10y agoThe complaints are wasted, because the staff has made it clear that they aren't going to change the policy to banning all paywalled content, and complaining that they should is off topic. This thread is about Samsung discontinuing the Galaxy Note 7 Smartphone, it's not about the paywall, or whether Hacker News should allow paywalls. This community is about prioritizing signal over noise and these tangents are always, always mere noise.
- oneeyedpigeon 10y agoIt's not about refusing to read an article, it's about it being difficult, if not impossible, to read it. If sites don't want the general public to read their content, we should respect that; the content probably isn't suitable for a free, open discussion site like HN.
- krapp 10y agoIt's neither difficult nor impossible to read. Some people refuse to read any paywalled articles or attempt to work around them, and then insist that Hacker News should cater to them by not allowing those articles to be posted to begin with. And yet discussion of those articles exists despite their objections, so obviously the problem isn't that the articles aren't accessible, or can't generate discussion, but that people are offended at the existence of paywalls and want their ideals to take priority over what can and can't be discussed here.