3 ms·
My point is that the car (really the programmers) should avoid choosing at all. The difference between "the car is programmed to kill pedestrians" and "pedestri
by wmf 10y ago
My point is that the car (really the programmers) should avoid choosing at all. The difference between "the car is programmed to kill pedestrians" and "pedestrians are statistically more likely to be killed in accidents" is intent, which has a lot of ethical and legal weight.
Also, if your code has a decide_who_to_kill() function, Dieselgate starts to look like a faux pas in comparison.
- smallnamespace 10y agoYes, yet by 'not making a choice', you still chose a definite probability distribution of outcomes. That distribution will need to be justified. If some people die and others don't, people will ask 'Why did this person die and not that other one?' I highly doubt that 'We flipped a coin' is going to be an acceptable answer.
- ehnto 10y agoWhat would you propose the software do in a scenario where it does have to decide? Throw a fatal exception, appropriately, and stop operating? I do agree with you, but I'm not certain you can avoid making a decision when your software will inevitably be provided a scenario where it has to do something, but no option is good. All of that said I would be surprised if we expect our cars to swerve and dart around the road to avoid obstacles, I figured it was going to be down to slaming on the brakes in a fraction of a second in most cases. As human drivers, swerving makes things significantly more dangerous in most cases.
- lobotryas 10y agoI would never want someone to explain to my family that the reason my self-driving car plunged over a cliff is because STATISTICALLY I had a better chance of surviving the fall than a child had a chance to survive being run over. In other words, are you or anyone else reading this ready to die RIGHT NOW if it somehow saved the life of other humans? Probably not. I applaud MB for what they are doing. If i an to buy a self-driving car then I would only take one that protects my life and the lives of my occupants (my children, family, friends) above the lives of all other people.