4 ms·
I use CURRENT on a Thinkpad X230. It works ok. Main gotchas: * No SSL CA certificates out of the box. FreeBSD security team has taken the curious
by loeg 10y ago
I use CURRENT on a Thinkpad X230. It works ok.
Main gotchas:
* No SSL CA certificates out of the box. FreeBSD security team has taken the
curious posture of claiming that shipping no CAs is better than just
shipping e.g. Mozilla's CA bundle.[0]
* rc.d is like Linux init from 5 years ago. Dynamic network configuration is
not handled well.
* Intel GPU driver support for anything above Haswell is still waiting to be
merged. But work is ongoing.[1]
* No Xorg or session management out of the box. You get dropped to a terminal
console. Good luck starting a session.
* Some packages conflict with each other needlessly. For example, you cannot
install gitk and git-svn at the same time.
* Finally, the installer has some limited choices. You can't enable full disk
encryption for UFS with the installer (last time I checked, anyway).
Other than all that, it works well.
[0]: https://bugs.freebsd.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=189811 https://bugs.freebsd.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=189811
[1]: https://github.com/FreeBSDDesktop/freebsd-base-graphics/wiki https://github.com/FreeBSDDesktop/freebsd-base-graphics/wiki
- dTal 10y agoHmph. I remember when "session management" was echo startx >> .loginrc I sure miss being able to understand and control my machine...
- voltagex_ 10y agoI reached the point of not understanding my machine when mounting a disk on Linux required udisks2/dbus and parts of Gnome. FreeBSD can be pretty spartan, but I do feel like I'm more in control.
- groovy2shoes 10y agoIs this a thing? I'm running Slackware and mounting a disk is still done with good ol' `mount`, same as it ever was.
- voltagex_ 10y agoI was probably being a bit snarky. I have run into cases where getting a drive to show up in the GUI (so, mounting as a user) needed something via dbus.
- groovy2shoes 10y agoAh. Well, I sympathize. When I first started using Linux, one thing I liked about it was the simplicity. Seems that simplicity has been getting eroded slowly but surely since I first started with it, but it has accelerated quite a bit in recent years. Slackware feels like one of the last holdouts, along with the likes of CRUX and Gentoo, but I fear that soon I will be forced to switch to some BSD -- which I wouldn't mind if my laptop hardware were better supported (I've been running various BSDs on servers for years, but Linux just seems to work better on my laptop; that said, I downloaded the 11.0-RELEASE ISOs a few days ago and I'll give it a shot on the lappy).
- vacri 10y agoI've been in the linux world for less than a decade, and I miss 'mount' being useful. It's full of spam now - so I've started using 'lsblk' instead... $ mount | wc -l 32 $ lsblk NAME MAJ:MIN RM SIZE RO TYPE MOUNTPOINT sda 8:0 0 698.7G 0 disk ├─sda1 8:1 0 512M 0 part /boot/efi ├─sda2 8:2 0 690.3G 0 part / └─sda3 8:3 0 7.9G 0 part [SWAP] # this was a mistake... sr0 11:0 1 1024M 0 rom
- twr 10y ago> # this was a mistake... That's not an unfixable mistake: sda3 is at the end of the partition table, so if it's deleted, sda2 can be safely resized offline. For example, parted /dev/sda rm 3 parted /dev/sda "resizepart 2 -0" resize2fs /dev/sda2 # for ext2/3/4 And then you can create a swap file or volume on sda2, so long as it isn't on btrfs.
- groovy2shoes 10y agoCool! I didn't know about `lsblk`. Thanks!
- gonzo 10y agoI use HEAD on a Intel Skull Canyon (Sky Canyon i7) NUC. Intel GPU driver just works on a 4K screen. I run ZFS on a pair or mirrored M.2 (NGFF) SSDs. Disk encryption is straight-forward here. pfSense 2.4 will have ZFS as well. I have a mostly retired x230 as well. 'Only' 16GB ram.
- tete 10y agoThat the BSDs init still works and currently makes many people switch from Linux actually makes it look different. Also small note on FreeBSDs rc vs Linux old init is that it for example always had support for dependencies. I'm saying that because BSD's especially FreeBSD's simple, pretty and working rc system have always been a thing that I missed when using Linux. Or in other words I disliked that run level system that makes managing dependencies really hard. I always hoped OpenRC would become the most common init system on Linux and actually still do, because I think it is the best option, when compared with sysv init and systemd. Also about the CAs: Everything that wants it has a dependency. About package conflicts: Choose between official packages or your own with Poudriere Out of the box the system is like Arch Linux, Debian or Ubuntu Server. It's the FreeBSD base system. You can install packages to make it into a router, a server, a thing hosting your private cloud using jails, a jail itself, etc. And the plus side. You don't have to get rid of all the stuff when you want your nice little i3 environment. And if you want KDE, just install it and kdm using pkg install and do sysrc kdm_enable=yes. Or go for TueOS (former pc-bsd). Or if you just want some FreeBSD tools go on MacOS and enter grep --version. With the other things I agree. FreeBSD isn't really your multimedia desktop environment. It is maybe for people that like it liked Gentoo or Arch Linux, but you should really check on your laptop's hardware before. Most driver development really happens in the server or usual suspects (Lenovo, Raspberry, ...) area. Sorry, didn't mean to even strongly disagree, but wanting to share my own experiences. Not everyone comes with the same views and I'm personally someone who is switching back from Arch Linux, because of the developments in the last few years in the Linux world. It just in my personal experience felt so much more easy to do stuff and have the system I want. Having used Arch for around a decade with only a relatively short break doesn't make that easy, but I liked it's initial idea about keeping things simple and that's what I miss on many ends. The main reason for not using FreeBSD on laptops really was the lack of some drivers for me. So that's maybe the biggest gotcha. Oh and for new people maybe that it is not just another Linux distribution so many things work differently. Biggest is probably the separation between base system and ports/packages.
- crest 10y agoJust run `pkg install -y xdm` and enable it in /etc/ttys to have init (re-)start xdm on the ttyv of your choice.
- JdeBP 10y ago> No Xorg or session management out of the box. TrueOS Desktop is your friend. PC-BSD, now called TrueOS, has for years now been the place to go if one cannot hack getting X up and running onesself, as one has to do with FreeBSD. PC-BSD/TrueOS Desktop has X and GUI login pre-configured out of the box. > rc.d is like Linux init from 5 years ago. Linux init from 5 years ago was upstart in quite a few places. (Debian is not the entire world.) init is not rc. upstart is nothing at all like Mewburn rc. And Mewburn rc has significant differences to van Smoorenburg rc, from not having any notion of runlevels (which the BSD world never adopted from the AT&T System 5 world) to a different division of work between the individual scripts and the common script libraries. Dynamic network configuration is handled through devd rules. > You can't enable full disk encryption for UFS with the installer ... although the FreeBSD/PC-BSD/TrueOS world is rapidly heading to all-ZFS as the norm. The PC-BSD 10.2 installer creates an all-ZFS system.
- type0 10y agoHow about GhostBSD? Anyone familiar with it?