4 ms·
The courts, justice system, and police are horrible by the standards of information access in the 21st century. If you are a victim in an incident, do you know
by stcredzero 10y ago
The courts, justice system, and police are horrible by the standards of information access in the 21st century. If you are a victim in an incident, do you know how long it takes to get a copy of the police report? 10 business days. So it's entirely possible that someone who has a hearing for a restraining order, who may not realize that it may be in their interest to have a copy, to be caught flat-footed. And the personal experience of getting it may well be pretty bad as well. The clerk seems to talk to you like you're some scum -- as if you were the perpetrator. (And yes, I was polite, and yes, she knew I was the victim.) The reason for the delay -- they have to redact the private information of the assailant. How in the world does that take them 10 days? On top of all that, they insist that you bring correct change. Also, you will note that there is the typical bureaucratic nonchalance bordering on hostility in the lack of customer service. No attempt at greeting or showing you are noticed or matter in any way. No air of politeness, but even an undertone of contempt -- and that's being perhaps way too charitable. My overwhelming suspicion -- as someone who went to an Ivy League school -- is that I was being treated as "yet another brown person," and that if one of my classmates with a different appearance was present, they would have been treated differently. (Though they still would have had to wait 10 days to get a redacted copy of a sheaf of papers.)
And that's just one example. Such horribleness is all over those systems. I had a hearing get moved 40 miles away -- apparently en-masse because of a computer system change -- with no notification to myself or my lawyer. I didn't even find out about that until we showed up. Sure, the US system is fantastic compared to other places in the world and justice during the middle ages. However, there's still a lot to it that's horrible.
EDIT: The takeaway from this article, my experience, and from many accounts of the justice system in the US, is that it is good on the large contexts of the world and history. However, it's still capable of cruel and arbitrary effects that run drastically counter to reality. Many of these effects come as myriad little "bites" or as if one is fighting a current. And the direction of these effects is strongly influenced by perceived socioeconomic status and race. This is still not up to the point of "good governance."
- Fiahil 10y ago> My overwhelming suspicion -- as someone who went to an Ivy League school -- is that I was being treated as "yet another brown person," Isn't that the way it's supposed to be? It's an old concept: In the eyes of the law, people don't get special treatment depending on their social status.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoDid you miss the part where they were treated worse because of their skin color?
- blackbagboys 10y agoYes, because that part wasn't there, just the parent's unsubstantiated suspicion that racism was the likeliest explanation for an unpleasant experience in dealing with low-level government bureaucrats.
- stcredzero 10y agoBe more careful in your reading. There is a certain way that people talk to someone they view as considerably inferior. The fact that people working in a place so quickly shift into that mode, even when it's at odds with the facts of the particular situation, is a very strong indicator that some sort of prejudice is at play. Whether or not it's racism, it's certainly not compatible with good governance.
- PhasmaFelis 10y ago> Yes, because that part wasn't there Neither was the part where they expected "special treatment depending on their social status." You don't get to dismiss the author's suspicions as imaginary while elevating your own to fact.
- stcredzero 10y agoMy point in including that piece of knowledge, is that I know what it's like when people have all sorts of different ideas about your socioeconomic background. I've been an Ivy brat. I've also been a homeless person. At the time of the events described, I am a well paid societal-normative upper middle class software engineer. I have first hand experience of when people are addressing me as a person of privilege, just another person, or an inferior scumbag. There is a tendency when I'm in the world of the justice/police system, for privileged people to automatically talk to me more like I'm a scumbag than I'm a normative person, but then I'll see the same someone take a different attitude when talking to someone privileged and "white." So no, I'm not expressing disappointment that I'm not spoken to as a privileged person. I'm just wishing I was spoken to equally as a person.
- Spooky23 10y agoI guess it depends where you live. When I needed a police report for a traffic accident and when my house was burglarized, I dropped by the station and had it in less than 20 minutes. When you have problems with the "retail" side of government at any level, call your local councilman, alderman, or whatever. If they suck, call the police chief.