13 ms·
Suspicious court cases, missing defendants, aim to get webpages taken down
- jdmichal 10y agoI know there's a few lawyers here. Assuming that these lawsuits were filed against non-existent defendants, and that the agreements from these "defendants" were actually written and submitted by the plaintiff -- What's the realistic punishment here? Would these false documents be sworn statements, and if so, would that put perjury on the table?
- h4nkoslo 10y agoPerjury would be on the table. Fraud, too, maybe, against the actual owner of the content. At a minimum any lawyer involved would probably face disbarment for fraud upon the court; the fact that they're all pro se cases makes me suspicious that a lawyer might have been involved in drafting some boilerplate language but not involved in the actual litigation, but it'd be difficult to argue that, eg, the reputation management firm's general counsel didn't know what was going on.
- DannyBee 10y agoDisbarment for any lawyers. For pro se, they can, for example, ban them from filing lawsuits unless they meet certain conditions (like independent verification, etc). All of this plus fraud (if they misrepresented what they would do) and criminal charges (because pretty much everything ever is against the law)
- gruez 10y agoAll of which makes me wonder why these SEO/"reputation management" companies even bother with this, given all the risks. Are they seriously hoping that this won't be discovered or that they won't be punished?
- M_Grey 10y agoSome people lack the ability to accurately assess the risks of their own actions, for a variety of reasons. Personality disorders, arrogance, institutional pressure, a long history of getting away with said risky behavior, can all cloud or utterly shatter the ability of someone to appreciate where the road they're on is most likely to lead.
- jacquesm 10y agoIn this case I'd suggest the reason is 'money', not some mental issue.
- M_Grey 10y agoSure, greed is a factor, but most people are greedy, while still managing to appreciate the risks of being caught.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoThey may completely appreciate the risks, however, and simply have judged it unlikely they would be caught.
- M_Grey 10y agoI mean... isn't that the primary risk?
- mi100hael 10y agoI'm sure they thought they would get away with it since there isn't a real "victim" other than someone who may or may not remember leaving a negative review or comment and probably won't even notice it's gone missing. Honestly I'm impressed that anyone connected all the dots so quickly.
- vorg 10y ago> I'm impressed that anyone connected all the dots so quickly Or it happens so often that this is the 1 in 1000 that got discovered.
- rayiner 10y agoIf more than one person was involved, and the documents were electronically filed, RICO might be on the table: http://legalnewsline.com/stories/510989090-second-circuit-rules-for-chevron-agrees-9-5-billion-judgment-against-oil-giant-was-product-of-fraud-racketeering http://legalnewsline.com/stories/510989090-second-circuit-ru....
- billiam 10y agoKinda looks like this guy, who appears to responsible for at least a decent portion of the examples in the WaPo story, is a run of the mill scammer who has already been caught: http://structuredsettlements.typepad.com/structured_settlements_4r/2015/02/richart-ruddie-sued-for-conspiracy-and-deceptive-trade-practices-in-2012.html http://structuredsettlements.typepad.com/structured_settleme... This is his LinkedIn profile. Another proud Stanford grad. https://www.linkedin.com/in/richartruddiestanford https://www.linkedin.com/in/richartruddiestanford
- mpenn 10y agoHis linkedin claims he took 1 Stanford class, and the notes he claims he wrote were clearly written by someone else (it's on Sukru Burc Eryilmaz's personal page). He went to Florida Atlantic University for his Bachelor's degree. He gets a nice headline in his education as Stanford, but he definitely did not attend for any degree.
- rurounijones 10y agoSo he is... being creative with his education profile. Given what he is involved in now, that seems on par.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rasz_pl 10y agoPrenda Law took >6 years and nobody is in prison, what makes you think this will be any different?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Prenda Law took >6 years and nobody is in prison, what makes you think this will be any different? Well, for one thing, Prenda Law controlled the entities (or they were completely fictional) that were the plaintiffs in its cases, whereas the "reputation management firms" here are apparently filing cases with their reputation management clients as named plaintiffs which the clients apparently don't know about and don't approve, and object to once they are actually made aware of them. And they use the results to influence third parties besides the defendants, and the defendants aren't generally doing something that they want to hide from attention. From the appearance of what is going on here, there are lots of reasons to think that this scam could blow up much faster on its perpetrators than Prenda Law measured from the first time someone noticed something funny going on.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> the "reputation management firms" here are apparently filing cases with their reputation management clients as named plaintiffs which the clients apparently don't know about and don't approve, and object to once they are actually made aware of them That's quite a leap from "don't want to take the fall".
- jdmichal 10y agoYou're reading a lot more into my question than what I wrote. I don't expect anything -- I honestly wanted to know what the perpetrators of the given actions I listed would be facing as potential charges. That being said, it looks like a good portion of the Prenda Law charges would probably also apply.
- Digory 10y agoIn addition to the other theories, this seems to be the rare, submissible case of tortious abuse of process. With wide-open punitive damages, I would think.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoA particularly interesting buried lede in the article: > And the possibility of such shenanigans bears on the Hassell v. Bird litigation that is now before the California Supreme Court: The issue there (see here and here) is whether takedown injunctions can actually be made legally binding on Internet platforms, rather than just being something that platforms choose whether to follow. The questionable nature of many such injunctions is reason to further insist that platforms not be legally bound by them. That would be a major win, if successful.
- DannyBee 10y agoCertainly you realize that buried lede is likely the reason the piece exists
- kbenson 10y agoIs the implication that this is only worth reporting about because of that case, and without the Supreme Court case this wouldn't have been reported at all? Or is it that it was only looked at in the first case because of the Supreme court case? I don't think the former is likely, this seems like news any way I look at it. As for the latter, that's possible, but I'm not sure what makes you think it's likely. Or perhaps you're trying to state something else I'm missing?
- dragonwriter 10y agoMy interpretation is that the case seeking to make these kinds of injunctions obligatory is likely what led someone to investigate what is going on with these injunctions in general, which then led to the discovery of what seemed like a strange pattern, which led to more research and hiring the PI; and therefore led to the reporting.
- kbenson 10y agoYes, that corresponds to the second interpretation I outlined above, but the article specifically states "(Readers may remember this story, which we blogged about in August; that’s the incident that got us investigating this issue.)" with regard to the Mathew Chan story (link[1]). Maybe the implication is that they only looked at that because of the Supreme Court though, and then this article exists because of the Supreme Court case by way of the original article? In any case, it was ambiguous enough to me that I figured I would ask, as I would rather learn something interesting that I missed than assume I knew what everyone involved was thinking. :) 1: http://pubcit.typepad.com/clpblog/2016/08/georgia-dentist-mitul-patel-takes-phony-litigation-scheme-to-new-extremes-as-a-way-of-suppressing-cr.html http://pubcit.typepad.com/clpblog/2016/08/georgia-dentist-mi...
- lightedman 10y agoI smell perjury, filing false instruments, fraud, and libel. This is going to be great.
- OliverJones 10y agoWhat a nightmare for the takedown-request teams at the online companies! Abuse of the court system is going to be very expensive and time-consuming for them to assess. Contempt of court or perjury prosecutions of the originators of some of these fraudulent lawsuits might serve as a deterrent. A little jail time goes a long way.
- greglindahl 10y agoThis is the 3rd nightmare for takedown teams, the first two are the DMCA and the Right to be Forgotten. Together, these are a huge barrier to entry for new search engines.
- cortesoft 10y agoThat really isn't the job of the online companies. They have neither the legal authority nor the ability to act as judicial review for these cases.
- wyager 10y agoInnocent people should not be on the hook for the fact that the system is so broken that people can sue non-existent parties. It's fine if the courts make mistakes sometimes, but if they're too incompetent to correctly use the powers given to them, those powers need to be scaled back to a level commensurate with the courts' abilities.
- Thrillington 10y agoAnd what do you propose to replace them?
- itsmemattchung 10y agoI had no idea that one could submit legal documents to Google, requesting de-indexing on specific pages. This tactic, apparently, is quite common.
- seomint 10y agoBlack Hat Lawyers? I hope they get nailed.
- jerf 10y agoAnother interesting angle to ponder is what this could do to websites hosting open comment sections on the web. Already a bit under fire for having low quality in many cases, I could see a lot of places taking down their comment sections if it's also going to open them to litigation. It doesn't take many lawsuits before the benefit the comment sections may be bringing is outweighed. I say this without judgment as to whether that would be good or bad; just musing about the second-order consequences.
- bringe 10y agoThat does seem a likely consequence. It can be argued that this stifles free discussion and argument, but with so many social sites out there, these conversations move elsewhere. However, it does decentralize the conversation more so than before.
- Senji 10y agoWe'll just move to a P2P comment system which is implemented as a browser addon and adds a comments section to any website.
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agoour justice system has been hacked. you are all cowards. rise up. revolt. you won't. you're all idiots.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 10y agoWow, I kind of expected one of the Prenda Law lawyers to be behind something like this. It makes perfect sense, you have people with money who want their past or actions to be somehow erased from discovery, and you have people who will come up with creative ways to achieve that and thus give themselves access to that money. But the really interesting thing is to watch how people react when something they used to be able to "get away with" is made impossible through technical means. Whether it is speed limiters on CPUs, copy protection on media, or poorly monitored traffic intersections.
- kaffeemitsahne 10y ago> speed limiters on CPUs What?
- david-given 10y agoFrom the old mainframe days, when you bought machines by, basically subscription --- you paid for a support contract and the hardware was usually provided as part of that. Different grades of support contract gave you different classes of machine, but frequently all the hardware was the same, just with bits disabled. If you upgraded your contract, they'd send a tech round who would flip some switches inside and, say, double your clock speed, or enable some more CPUs, etc.
- DiabloD3 10y agoAka the IBM model.
- tlb 10y agoGood work by the WaPo for getting to the bottom of this. This shows an important reason why court proceedings should be openly accessible at scale. Lawyers can spread legal DOS attacks out across jurisdictions, where individual judges would have a hard time discovering the pattern. Allowing citizens to do large scale pattern matching will uncover such things.
- rayiner 10y agoThat's a desirable goal, but hard to achieve. In the US, courts aren't just an administrative unit of government, like the DMV. They're an independent branch of government, organized as a distributed system. Individual courts have their own jurisdiction and are largely self-managed. As a result, there isn't really anyone who can tell even all the federal courts, much less the state ones, to all plug into a central electronic filing system. Indeed, even though the federal courts all use the PACER software, each court actually maintains it's own system.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> As a result, there isn't really anyone who can tell even all the federal courts, much less the state ones, to all plug into a central electronic filing system. Congress can, in fact, do that for federal courts; as for state courts, its true that there is no one body that can, but Congress has been very successful in the past at getting fairly good national compliance with programs that are outside of its ability to mandate by setting rules and providing implementation and maintenance funds to states who choose to follow the rules; there's no reason why this couldn't work with court record systems.
- rayiner 10y agoI didn't say it was impossible, just hard to achieve. I think getting an act of Congress (in an area where Congress historically has been loathe to legislate) qualifies.
- dragonwriter 10y ago
- pasbesoin 10y agoI hope we will start criminalizing such abuses of the legal system. And not just the plaintiffs, but their lawyers. Lest this nation "founded on law" become, by extension, a nation (further) founded on corruption. Civil cases deserve and need to remain civil. But blatant and deliberate and self-serving abuse of the system -- here perhaps including perjury and a form of libel -- should, in extremis, cost people their freedom, their licenses, and their membership in civil society. I'm mindful of the need for room for civil protest and other forms of law breaking. The law does need to be challenged and refined -- constantly. I'm not sure how to draw the line between e.g. those two (as well as in other distinctions). But, something needs to be done, or our legal system is going to be reduced to simply another arena for power plays, devoid of other integrity. P.S. I'm mindful that extreme abuses already are criminal. But enough abuse goes unchecked, that either the line needs to move, or enforcement needs to be more active and thorough. The legal profession needs to better consider that it is not exceptional, it is like any other institution: If you don't keep your own house in order, you will fall.
- tehwalrus 10y agoIsn't this plainly criminal, as in Perjury, on behalf of the people filing suits?
- jxramos 10y agoCould be an interesting opportunity to archive these "banned" websites and create a new site off of these cases. Pretty crazy abuse of power. Makes me think about the further shift away from print media, before libel and defamation were primarily ran via printed newspaper and what not. Now the focus shifts online.
- wmeredith 10y agoThis is next level blackhat SEO. With perjury and disbarment at stake.
- prdonahue 10y agoWould be interested to see if any of these lawyers have connections to Reputation Defender[1] or any of the similar companies in this space? 1 - https://www.reputationdefender.com/ https://www.reputationdefender.com/
- Sanddancer 10y agoIt seems like it. The woman who the Post is mentioning, Kathy Glatter, has a rather white-washed google presence, marred only by the article on her behavior, which quite likely is rather linked at the moment. http://www.davisenterprise.com/local-news/north-davis-parent-responsible-for-gate-petition-forgeries/ http://www.davisenterprise.com/local-news/north-davis-parent...
- WhitneyLand 10y agoMeet the con man behind most of this, Richart Ruddie. Notice how he includes Stanford in his username, and also lists it on his profile, when it looks like he just watched E145 on youtube. https://linkedin.com/in/richartruddiestanford https://linkedin.com/in/richartruddiestanford Also some of the previous trouble he's been in: http://structuredsettlements.typepad.com/structured_settlements_4r/2015/02/richart-ruddie-sued-for-conspiracy-and-deceptive-trade-practices-in-2012.html http://structuredsettlements.typepad.com/structured_settleme...
- wNk6A23YB 10y agoThis is a great reminder that people who consider themselves entrepreneurs shouldn't be trusted. A person who starts a bakery is a baker. A person who makes money by skirting health and labor department regulations by paying people under the table to make bread in unsanitary conditions is an entrepreneur.
- gnarbarian 10y agoLegal hax
- tofupup 10y agoneat