11 ms·
US carriers halt Samsung Note 7 sales and replacements
- CountSessine 10y agoI doubt Samsung will try to find another sales channel for them in North America. Going back to the feature-phone era, one of their most important advantages over their handset competitors has been their loyalty to the big phone companies. Doing an end-run around them to sell directly to their customers seems...unseemly. So what happens to all of these Note 7's? Do they just get buried in a ditch somewhere? From reading Android Central and other sites, it seems like there are still a lot of Samsung faithful who are ready to risk having their heads blown off to own one.
- userbinator 10y agoSamsung said in a statement last month that the issue of overheating was caused by a "rare" manufacturing error that resulted in the battery's "anode-to-cathode [negative and positive electrodes]" coming into contact. Looks like the fault is in the batteries, internal shorts are both uncommon and also extremely dangerous since they will essentially dissipate all the energy in the cell as heat and can't be stopped externally. This is partially why I'm wary of devices with batteries which aren't easily removable... and to think a few years ago Samsung was making ads poking fun at Apple users for not having removable batteries.
- CamperBob2 10y agoThis is partially why I'm wary of devices with batteries which aren't easily removable... This argument is made all the time, but I don't understand it. If the batteries were removable, a large number of owners would eventually replace them with low-quality Chinese lithium batteries whose brand names contain the word "Fire" somewhere. The result will be, big surprise, more fires. The difference is that there won't be one central manufacturer who can be forced to take responsibility for them. Publicity, if any, will be too obscure for most users to notice. There is no way on Earth you will end up with fewer battery fires if the batteries are replaceable. We just won't hear about them.
- Something1234 10y agoOr PureDick. I got a crap laptop battery under that name. Puredick® New Laptop Battery for Dell Precision M6400 M6500, fits C565C G102C F678F KR854 8M039 5K145 DW554 P267P -12 Months Warranty[Li-ion 9-cell 11.1V 90Wh] https://www.amazon.com/dp/B018VAY2RW/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_2VZ-xb4C97GNE https://www.amazon.com/dp/B018VAY2RW/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_2VZ-...
- Crespyl 10y agoAt least in replacing the battery, the user is (theoretically) making an informed decision/calculated risk that is in their own hands. I suspect it's also a lot cheaper to recall/replace a handful of batteries than to recall/replace every single phone.
- simonh 10y ago>This is partially why I'm wary of devices with batteries which aren't easily removable. Why? It seems like the batteries burn out fast enough that it wouldn't be possible to safely remove one once it starts smoking. In any case doing so might save the phone - unlikely but it might - however now you have a completely naked ignited incendiary device lying on your carpet, rather than one enclosed in a protective case. That sounds to me like a worse situation to be in. And anyway now you've saved your phone at great personal risk, what are you going to do with it? Put another Note 7 battery in it and keep on using it? I'm curious what your reasoning is here.
- chipperyman573 10y agoI think he's saying that it's a lot easier to ship or give out a free replacement battery than recall an entire phone line and manage all the repairs.
- simonh 10y agoBut would that be a benefit in this situation? The new 'safe' phones supposedly had changes beyond just a new battery, so the phones would have had to go back anyway.
- r00fus 10y agoI really doubt any forums have statistically valid representation of actual users. Sockpuppets are very possible / likely [1]. [1] http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/2/16/945768/- http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/2/16/945768/-
- inimino 10y agoThey are probably still frantically figuring out how to fix the problem and will eventually have a replacement replacement. Then they can refurbish the existing ones.
- malka 10y agoIf I were a Note 7 user, I would not want a replacement, I would want a refund. Given that problem arised even with replaced Note 7, I would not take another chance with that model.
- maxpert 10y agoI don't know how fatal this will be for Samsung next time they go out and sell phones; but people have got a taste of buying from a company that doesn't have any sales or customer rep centers easily accessible where people can go and complaint. I really hope it doesn't turn out to be fatal for them but I also hope it breaks the Samsung monopoly over Android and let brands like LG, HTC shine.
- sho_hn 10y agoLG has a top competitor out right now in the V20. Removable battery, MIL-spec drop proof, second wide angle rear camera, concert-capable stereo mics with manual controls, a second screen that's actually useful (it's located in what would otherwise be dead bezel next to the front camera, and shows e.g. notifications while fullscreen, or can be used as a taskbar), usable software (read: close to vanilla Android Nougat now), fancy DAC and bundled with $150 B&O in-ears. With an aluminum main body and svelte looks. And for some reason they won't launch it in Europe and steal Samsung's sales. Madness, it's by far the most compelling phone available right now. Happy with the one I got in Korea ...
- icelancer 10y agoWow, the V20 looks amazing. I'll probably sell my iPhone 6+ and my Nexus 6P and get one. Not sure when I can get it in America, unfortunately. Any way to import it from Korea?
- sho_hn 10y agoAccording to /r/lgv20 T-Mobile and Sprint are getting it in Oct. Not sure about the import part sorry, I live in Seoul these days :)
- gogopuppygogo 10y agoSounds like a good side business for you to start :-)
- 10y ago
- piyush_soni 10y agoIt's a sad end to what was a great phone otherwise.
- camillomiller 10y agoThat's a big otherwise... it's not a great phone at all, if it's so badly engineered that it can catch fire...
- piyush_soni 10y agoMay be it's just the external battery supplier's issue, we're yet to find out. I'm talking features/performance/Software/UI wise it's a great phone. Yes, the battery department totally let it down.
- liw 10y agoIt still seems to be OK to bring Note 7s on airplanes. Not bottles of water, though, that's too dangerous.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JauntyHatAngle 10y agoYou can bring bottles of water onto airplanes...
- hueving 10y agoNot sure if you've been in an airport, but you can buy a bottle of water and bring it on an airplane.
- mschuster91 10y agoYeah, and it costs 10x as much as in a regular super market, despite being the same water. I really, really dislike flying. Not because of the flying itself, but because of being treated like a potential terrorist all the time.
- Steko 10y agoSo carry an empty bottle/tumbler/thermos and fill it up at the water fountain?
- CookieMon 10y agoWhy did Note 7's have this problem? I assume the fault is entirely in the battery (?), so did Samsung change how the batteries were manufactured this year? Does the Note 7 have power demands that mean they can't go back to tried and tested battery manufacture? (Hoping there are EE's or manufacturing people here that might have some educated guesses)
- ssalazar 10y agoI read on an earlier discussion that the issue is caused by the positive/negative battery contacts pressing together and short-circuiting as a result of mechanical distress, so the fundamental issue would be due to how the battery is situated within the device.
- raverbashing 10y agoLooks like the same thing with the Boeing 787s batteries. I'm not sure if it has to do with geometry, manufacturing defects or something like that
- userbinator 10y agoI believe Samsung doesn't make the batteries. Whoever does, however, is probably not feeling too good... It also means that this could've easily happened to another company's phones; remember the laptop fires a few years ago (Apple, Dell, IBM, Toshiba, etc. all issued recalls) that were determined to originate from defective Sony cells?
- sho_hn 10y agoSamsung Electronics doesn't make the batteries - but Samsung SDI do, along with Chinese Amperex Technology (for the third sold in China). My understanding is that both devices with SSDI and with Amperex batteries have caught on fire (IIRC there have been failures inside and outside of China), so maybe a chassis design defect subjecting the batteries to unexpected strain? Samsung SDI also manufacture iPhone batteries.
- sengork 10y agoLooks like they've halted production as well: http://ausdroid.net/2016/10/10/psa-samsung-halted-note-7-production-power-phone-off-return/ http://ausdroid.net/2016/10/10/psa-samsung-halted-note-7-pro... I am guessing that the culprit here is Samsung's shift to directly compete with iPhone 7. All other Note releases were standalone and received very little announcements.
- kayoone 10y agoScrewing up once happens, even if it shouldn't. Doing it twice will seriously shatter peoples trust in these devices and make them think twice before purchasing a new Samsung phone again. Samsung is a behemoth but this can really hurt their smartphone division.
- eksemplar 10y agoAfter 2 years my S2 became a slow unfunctional piece of dead tech. I tried resetting it through the Samsung tools, which didn't help, so I rooted it and tried different versions of basic android on it, which didn't help. At the same time I had two friends who were experiencing the same kinds of problems, who let me toy with their phones. It's completely anecdotal but three similar model phones breaking in exactly the same manner at exactly the same period in their lives was enough to put me off Samsung for good. It's been some years since and I've seen Samsung in one scandal after another. Like the time they had an entire range of flatscreen tvs break because they put the transistors too close to the cooling plates, fixing it by moving the transistors but replacing the $0.5 piece with a Samsung produced transistor which they've never sold, making repairs nearly impossible.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoTo match an anecdote with an anecdote - I've been using S4 for 3 years, and then gave it to my brother (I've upgraded to S7 with contract renewal), who's been using it for the past year too. The phone is still going strong. Feels slow-ish today, true, but still better than some of the cheaper Android phones OOTB. I blame Android's continued bloat creep[0] for that slowdown though. My brother had S3 before, and so does my SO, and they were all becoming less and less usable with time and each system update... -- [0] - Is there an official term for the phenomenon that software bloats expands to cancel out any improvements in hardware?
- isp 10y agoWirth's law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth%27s_law
- mrmondo 10y agoThis adds to Samsung's long covered up history of phones that kill SDcards, bloated batteries, uncompliant USB spec connections, under-specced voltage regulators throughout, cheap USB chargers suspected as built to fail, screen colour imperfections and second hand parts discovered in new phones discovered during new phone tear downs. They regularly spend so much more money on advertising on bus stops and trains than they ever have on r&d for any product. The parts they sell to other vendors for rebranding etc... are almost always custom, higher grade built to order parts, for example their nvme pcie drives sold to Apple are built to much higher standards and they run completely custom Apple firmware, and guess what? They don't fail or fire. Samsung are a straight out dodgy company - they're the Microsoft of hardware but with better advertising, unfortunately targeted towards people of slightly lower social status often.
- breakingcups 10y ago[citation needed]
- mrmondo 10y agoI know what you're saying, but I often comment on public transport and you're quite welcome to do your own research and dispute what I said.
- manojlds 10y agoAs someone outside the US, I first associated "US carriers" with US Aircraft Carriers. I thought this was about the navy banning Note 7 aboard the carriers, before sales and replacement brought me back to thinking this is about mobile carriers. In India we just call them mobile networks :) NLP and AI is tough, no wonder.
- kriro 10y agoThat was my initial association as well. I actually thought there was some sort of sea blockade to not let note 7s into the country. Then I thought that would be a bit too ridiculous and only then did my brain recognize the other meaning of carrier.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI immediately recognized the other meaning of the word, but I did let my imagination fly for a bit, picturing 2+ carrier groups blockading shipments of Note 7 phones...
- dotancohen 10y agoWhat phones are an alternative to the Note? I use my Note 3's stylus dozens of times a day. No other stylus comes close, as it uses Wacom technology as opposed to standard stylus' capacitance sensing. The Wacom technology needs the phone to support it. Are there any good stylii for writing text (i.e. dragging across the screen) for generic capacitance screens? All stylii that I've seen are good for selecting things (i.e. pushing against the screen) but terrible for writing.
- thrownblown 10y agoThe first generation Nvidia shield had a great stylus.
- MikusR 10y agoThe only alternative to Note 3 is Note 4. Note 5 had limited release.
- nkobeissi 10y agoI want to understand how this story makes sense, and I can't. If you put the facts together, they don't add up. First, here's the chronology. 1. Original Note 7 phones were blowing up, Samsung issued a recall. 2. Samsung released (suspiciously quickly) a new phone that used new batteries made by Amperex, which also provides batteries for the iPhone line. [A] 3. A report comes in of a post-recall, "safe" phone blowing up while not being connected to a charger and being turned off to be put in the owner's pocket. [B] 4. Another report of a "safe" phone blowing up while in the back pocket of its owner. [C] 5. Two more reports come in, both of a Note 7 blowing up overnight while their owners were asleep. [D,E] Second, here's what I don't understand: * We know the batteries are likely safe since they come from a reputed manufacturer also providing iPhones their batteries. Heck, even the initial battery manufacturer was Samsung itself, and Li-Ion batteries aren't exactly a new and unstudied technology. * Even after the new batteries were put in use, the phones are still exploding even when not connected to a charger, as explicitly stated by reports [D] and [C], and as is likely the case for [B] and [E]. How are these phones blowing up when, in all likelihood, the batteries are safe and have been replaced, and the phone isn't even under heavy use at the time of the explosion? Maybe you could blame CPU heating or a faulty charging mechanism, but the phones were not charging or under heavy load. All they were doing was discharging at an idle rate. This is literally the state least likely to cause this kind of explosion. Can anyone explain what I'm missing? Sources: [A] https://www.cnet.com/news/samsung-galaxy-note-7-explosion-battery-manufacturing-error/ https://www.cnet.com/news/samsung-galaxy-note-7-explosion-ba... [B] http://www.theverge.com/2016/10/5/13175000/samsung-galaxy-note-7-fire-replacement-plane-battery-southwest http://www.theverge.com/2016/10/5/13175000/samsung-galaxy-no... [C] http://focustaiwan.tw/news/asoc/201610080009.aspx http://focustaiwan.tw/news/asoc/201610080009.aspx [D] http://www.theverge.com/2016/10/9/13215728/samsung-galaxy-note-7-third-fire-smoke-inhalation http://www.theverge.com/2016/10/9/13215728/samsung-galaxy-no... [E] http://www.theverge.com/2016/10/9/13218730/samsung-galaxy-note-7-fire-replacement-fourth-virginia http://www.theverge.com/2016/10/9/13218730/samsung-galaxy-no...
- bengale 10y agoFrom the articles I've seen it seems to be related to a slightly too small area for the battery, and causing it to sort of pinch.
- vamur 10y agoSo far there isn't any hard evidence (e.g HD videos) that the replacement phones really have the issue. All claims are based on hearsay and "reports". But if true then Samsung really needs changes to its management and product line. It makes too many phones - right now there they have A, C, J, E lines besides the Galaxy line, confusing and aggravating customers and likely employees as well. It can also mean that manufacturers are hitting a safety wall with lithium batteries, which is bad news for future phone battery capacities.
- joshstrange 10y agoAre you kidding? "hard evidence (e.g HD videos)" At least 2 of these have happened while people have been sleeping (One guy in KY had to be hospitalized to to inhalation of the smoke) and even if it happened during the day most people have 1 camera/video camera with them and it's their phone. Most people don't carry around a second camera to be used only to film their supposedly safe replacement bursting into flames. It sounds like the only way you'd believe this to be true is if you saw video of a phone from production, to signing off by the president of Samsung that it was safe, to shipping, to full use of the phone until such a time that it burst into flames. People with phones that have caught fire have provided proof that the serial numbers of their phones were supposed to be replacements and thus safe.
- vamur 10y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. And video evidence these days when billions have a smartphone shouldn't be much to ask for. >>At least 2 of these have happened while people have been sleeping (One guy in KY had to be hospitalized to to inhalation of the smoke) and even if it happened during the day most people have 1 camera/video camera with them and it's their phone. And how do you know these people weren't violating manufacturer safety guidelines? Or that the reports are true and not rumors? Or that it is not an isolated accident? >>Most people don't carry around a second camera to be used only to film their supposedly safe replacement bursting into flames. These days if something extraordinary happens - such as a phone blowing up in the middle of the day - it is usually filmed. When it is not, then that raises questions. >> It sounds like the only way you'd believe this to be true is if you saw video of a phone from production, to signing off by the president of Samsung that it was safe, to shipping, to full use of the phone until such a time that it burst into flames. Chinese suppliers on Aliexpress today require unpacking videos before claiming defective merchandise. So it isn't much to ask for some evidence before a witch-hunt.
- fumar 10y agoI have Note 7, my first non-nexus device going back to the G1, and its a brilliant piece of technology. The screen is flawless, its blazing fast, and the stylus is great for notes on OneNote. I am pretty bummed out Samsung couldn't get their manufacturers to deliver on 100% quality and control. I can't think of what other device to get. The Pixel XL looks fine, but it lacks wireless charging, a 5.7" screen, and a stylus. For the record, Touchwiz is a bit too much, so I changed my launcher and made a few changes to the UI to align more with stock android. But other than that, I couldn't be happier with the ticking time bomb of a phone.
- victorhooi 10y agoI was initially annoyed by the removal of wireless charging from the Nexus 5X (I previously had a Nexus 5). However, to be honest, wireless charging was always 1. flakey (placement had to be just right - often I'd check in the morning and it hadn't charged) and 2. super slow. I'd much rather trade it off for super-fast charging (Pixel is meant to do 7 hours of battery life in 15 minutes), and the reversible (and standardised!) USB-C cable. I've always preferred smaller phones, so the 5" and 5.5" screens are fine for me (although I'm obviously going for the standard Pixel at 5") - and stylus to me doesn't make sense on a smaller phone screen anyhow - I have a tablet for that. Agree with you that Touchwiz is too much - I've always hated it and found it gimmicky and tacky - and it tends to bog down the phone over time, like a bad Windows install.