4 ms·
Hmm, the general direction of this argument is uncomfortably close to, "gays get the HIV epidemic they deserve" (even for some of the same reasons this article
by _delirium 17y ago
Hmm, the general direction of this argument is uncomfortably close to, "gays get the HIV epidemic they deserve" (even for some of the same reasons this article cites).
In both cases we could probably have more rational discussions without that "deserve" word, which involves moral connotations. How about discussing: what kinds of sexual-relationship graphs are more or less conducive to the spreads of which kinds of disease?
I would guess there are actually a lot of factors, and more than unprotected promiscuity. Clearly unprotected promiscuity seems involved: the article's discussion of some recent African experience points that out, and so does the 80s gay bathhouse culture. But there are plenty of promiscuous cultures that appear not to have high HIV prevalence, e.g. college-student bar-pickup and frat culture has very low HIV infection rates, even for people with 30+ partners and regular unprotected sex.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- praptak 17y ago"college-student bar-pickup and frat culture has very low HIV infection rates, even for people with 30+ partners and regular unprotected sex" Citation needed. I seriously doubt a major group of people can keep low infection rates with 30+ partners and regular unprotected sex. The only rational explanation would be regular HIV tests plus stopping on positive result - seems implausible.
- Retric 17y agoFor disease transmission it's less important how much people connect inside small groups but how much those groups connect to other groups. The issue is when someone get's infected with something vary quickly the whole group becomes infected.
- araneae 17y agoRight. For instance, models have shown that IV drug users are an extremely important group because they connect the heterosexual and gay pools of susceptible.
- jcnnghm 17y agoIn the US, AIDS is almost entirely confined to people that are either gay, or needle drug users.
- spamizbad 17y agoIf by "almost entirely confined" you mean approximately 70-75%[1]. This shouldn't be surprising: US culture pushes homosexuality underground, and is mostly uninterested in treating IV drug users outside of a few liberal enclaves. [1] http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5739a2.htm http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5739a2.htm
- jcnnghm 17y agoMaybe you're looking somewhere I'm not, but the 0.8% figure under the 'Other' Category would seem to support what I'm saying, since it excludes people knowing sleeping with people that are known to have AIDS, Needle Drug users, and gay males.
- spamizbad 17y agoI really can't believe I'm having this argument in 2010. You stated that it was confined to Gays and IV drug users. It's not. The statistics show heterosexuals contracting it. Whether they get it because they're sleeping with an IV drug user, someone who is homosexual, or another heterosexual who is classified as "high risk" doesn't matter: they're straight and they have HIV, therefor it's not "contained" to gays and IV users.
- _delirium 17y agoI agree he phrased it too strongly, but you could accurately say that it's effectively confined to MSM, IV users, and those two groups' immediate sexual partners. That sort of analysis is pretty common in epidemiology, describing a particular outbreak as "confined to group A and immediate contacts of group A". For example, when looking at diseases associated with health-care workers, people in direct prolonged contact with them but who aren't themselves health-care workers, like family members, are often counted as basically honorary health-care workers (or at least treated as a group separate from the general public).
- joeyo 17y agoHere are the data for 2007: http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/topics/surveillance/basic.htm#hivaidsexposure http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/topics/surveillance/basic.htm#hivaids... Estimated # of HIV/AIDS Cases, in 2007 Category | Adult & Adolescent Male | Adult & Adolescent Female | Total ----------------------------+-------------------------+---------------------------+------- Male-to-male sexual contact | 22,472 | - | 22,472 Injection drug use | 3,133 | 1,806 | 4,939 Male-to-male sexual contact | | | and injection drug use | 1,260 | - | 1,260 High-risk heterosexual | | | contact* | 4,551 | 9,076 | 13,627 Other** | 102 | 96 | 198 * Heterosexual contact with a person known to have, or to be at high risk for, HIV infection. **Includes hemophilia, blood transfusion, perinatal exposure, and risk not reported or not identified.
- mseebach 17y agoThe argument of the article is that when the head of the government acts blatantly irresponsible and appears to be proud of it, it's no small wonder responsible behavior is rare. Gays spearheaded the campaign for safe sex because they were highly exposed to the risk (anal sex has a much higher risk of transmitting HIV). If leaders in the gay community, well aware of the risk, went around boasting of having unprotected sex, their advice would be laughed at, and yes, it'd be fair to say they'd earned it. But they don't - gay leaders are exceedingly responsible in this area. As opposed (apparently) to the leaders of South Africa and Swaziland. Screw "the general direction" and "uncomfortably". HIV is really, actually, for real dangerous. When you act irresponsibly, against better knowledge, as a leader, yes, you deserved it when your people suffers.
- rauljara 17y agoThe people don't deserve it, however. And the article isn't about the leader deserving anything, it is about the culture deserving what it gets, and using the leader as an excuse to talk about it. And maybe it is a good excuse to talk about dangerous behavior and the consequences thereof, but talking about people "deserving" an epidemic like AIDS is pretty insensitive and counter productive. Whatever good message you had (behavior needs to change) is going to be drowned out by that stupid generalization (no, a third wife who got AIDS from her philandering husband did not deserve it, and vice versa).
- mseebach 17y agoThere's a personal "deserves" and a systemic "deserves". I think the purpose of the article was indeed to provoke and to get the point across that HIV in these areas aren't just about getting condoms and information in the hands of people, it's systemic. Combine that with white guilt (white Christian Europeans don't really get to tell Africans how to lead their lives), that's a recipe for, if not disaster, then really inefficient programs.
- rbanffy 17y agoIf culture doesn't change, the population will be pushed into extinction. Or will evolve to become immune to HIV. It has less to do with promiscuity than with unprotected sex. If the promiscuous population engages only in safe sex, then it's very unlikely HIV and other STDs will spread. No individuals deserve blame for collective actions, but the collectivity may deserve what comes from collective behaviour.
- araneae 17y agoIt's not just close, it's the same. Gay men do have the types of sexual relationships that are more likely to lead to STD transmission than their heterosexual counterparts in the U.S. I actually often wonder why heterosexual men get condemned for promiscuity more than homosexual men. (Probably because there are no women to yell at them for it.) Anyway, this 2006 papers looks at the effect of different network patterns in sexual relationships and STD transmission. Basically, the amount of overlap you have between sexual partners is key. The less, the better. http://www.scribd.com/full/29969122?access_key=key-19cz4fztdgmy90tcfecm http://www.scribd.com/full/29969122?access_key=key-19cz4fztd...