6 ms·
Why is it ideal that a candidate has been coding since before they were in college? I understand wanting people who have an interest in the job, but how many ot
by lovich 10y ago
Why is it ideal that a candidate has been coding since before they were in college? I understand wanting people who have an interest in the job, but how many other industries feel that the only good candidate is one whose been involved in it since they were a child? Sports are the only one that come readily to mind
- ern 10y agoNow that there is a push to get all kids coding in school, this criterion will have to be tightened: I wouldn't be surprised to see: "had first PR merged into a Github project before college". Of course these arbitrary criteria to filter junior programmers add no value, but are another symptom of how broken the entire business is.
- lovich 10y agoRight, it's along the lines of people declaring that the only good programmers are the ones who have outside projects regardless or whether 8-12 hours a day of programming at a job is enough to sap anyone of creativity
- eru 10y agoIf you work 8-12 creativity sapping hours, the pay better be good..
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pmiller2 10y ago> how many other industries feel that the only good candidate is one whose been involved in it since they were a child? Sports are the only one that come readily to mind Classical musicians. Of course there will be relatively few areas where early involvement is even considered in a candidate. How many 9 year old lawyers do you know?
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoSadly true. If you haven't been practicing since before puberty, you will never be a professional classical performer. But it's an exceptional and unusual field. Many professional non-classical musicians start much later, and still do okay - although it's a much more brutally selective field than software development. Edit: I see no evidence that starting late makes it impossible to be a good developer, and plenty that an early start is irrelevant. Any reasonably intelligent graduate should be able to learn to be at least averagely competent at basic code grinding. It might take a few years, but there's nothing inherently magical about the process.
- jhspaybar 10y agoI started programming around the beginning of high school and then stopped at the end of high school and became a car salesman. 8 years later I went back to school and got a CS degree and am thriving. So, I did have some early experience, but given the gap I feel like I'm more closely aligned with a late starter.
- santoriv 10y ago> Sadly true. If you haven't been practicing since before puberty, you will never be a professional classical performer. This is correct about 99.999% of the time. The exception is when extreme levels of talent and interest are simultaneously involved. Barry Tuckwell, one of the great virtuoso French hornists of the 20th century, started playing at 14 and was playing professionally within six months. Hermann Baumann, another virtuoso French horn soloist, started playing when he was 17. Anyway, I think that interest in programming before college is a likely indicator of independent interest and self-directed learning. I know a lot of folks majoring in CS or trying to get into development simply because it's a lot more lucrative than many other professions. Many(not all) of these folks don't have a genuine interest in programming which makes it unlikely that they will be effective developers.
- clifanatic 10y ago> How many 9 year old lawyers do you know? Every 9 year old.
- rlpb 10y ago> Why is it ideal that a candidate has been coding since before they were in college? Imagine if civil engineering students were taught arithmetic for the first time at college. Firms would favor applicants with an interest from a much younger age, no? The problem with software engineering is that understanding it well is as fundamental as understanding arithmetic. We teach arithmetic from the age of around six, yet we expect that starting to code only at college is somehow equivalent.
- ern 10y agoThe problem with software engineering is that understanding it well is as fundamental as understanding arithmetic Asking this may be trite but: do you have evidence to back that assertion up? Why couldn't we say that about other professions?
- rlpb 10y agoI think I might not have made myself clear enough, sorry. Let me add some context to what I meant: The problem with software engineering is that understanding [things like indirection] well is as fundamental [to software engineering] as understanding arithmetic [is fundamental to civil engineering]. I presume that this assertion, then, is uncontroversial?
- ern 10y agoIndirection may be fundamental to programming, but it is a fairly self-contained concept that in my experience can be grokked quickly. The math required for an engineering degree is based on arithmetic, algebra, trig and calculus, all of which are taught over a period of years. I may still not be understanding you, but my own experience, when I learned programming as part of an EE degree (first language was C with lots of pointer manipulation) was that concepts like indirection are a lot simpler to pick up de novo than Partial Differential Equations, Fourier Transforms and other college-level math concepts are, even with 12 year grade school background.
- Bahamut 10y agoThis is a quite unintelligent response - people can learn if they put their minds to it. Case in point, I'm a PhD dropout from a top 15 math program in the US - I did not really code at all to any serious degree. After pouring a lot of time & effort, even after starting, I became very good at what I do. I have encountered plenty of people in the profession who have become solid to very good developers, including a former grad school colleague. The people have come from all sorts of walks of life, from college dropouts to sales. Also to contrast, I have also worked with not great developers who have CS degrees. A degree does not tell me if you are passionate about what you do, or if you retained any knowledge from schooling - nor does various indicators that you have coded prior.
- yomly 10y agoWhy is it ideal that someone has been coding before college? Simply because they have that many more years experience than everyone else. You may even be able to argue that coders are amongst the only people who have a non-negligible likelihood of starting the practice before college, I could believe this is the case. I can also tell you that most the lawyers, bankers, consultants and doctors at my university will have been doing work experience + shadowing from around 14-15 years old. The even more ambitious ones will have been doing slightly more enterprising things (entering school/local/national entrepreneurial competitions), or reading around their interests, or joining/running societies. When looking at the most successful people I know around me, what becomes apparent is that they started way earlier than everyone else. Look at Zuckerberg, he wrote Synapse when he was 16. It's unlikely you'll hire a Zuckerberg, but when someone started coding is a pretty reliable heuristic for how dependable they'll be in the job. Think of it as hiring a senior analyst to do an junior analyst's role, if you will...