4 ms·
> I was going to cite you some research but the article does a pretty good job in going into detail why it's not just time. No, it doesn't. It cites a single,
by bsder 10y ago
> I was going to cite you some research but the article does a pretty good job in going into detail why it's not just time.
No, it doesn't. It cites a single, very small, non-replicated study about, specifically, perfect pitch on an equal tempered scale (we'll get back to this in a minute). We know that detailed sound discrimination is one of the very specific things that closes off with neuroplasticity. We also know that it closes off REALLY early--much earlier than adolescence.
I would also suggest that you need to treat neuro studies with HUGE heaping servings of skepticism. Neuro is one of the worst offenders in the non-replicability crisis. In addition, the fMRI software bugs have invalidated a lot of neuro research.
Finally, with respect to testing "perfect pitch", AN EQUAL TEMPERED SCALE IS FAR FROM PERFECT. "Western" music converged on a 12-note, equal tempered scale where each note is slightly "wrong". Why would discriminating such an artificial construct have ANY relation to a biological system? Many cultures have very different musical scales, perhaps one of those scales is "easier to learn" as an adult.
And I won't even get into whether "perfect pitch" is actually a help or hindrance to a musician.
> I seriously hope if you have kids or plan to have kids, you do not assume they can catch up later on and that you give them to proper learning environment when they are young.
WTF? How did you make the leap from "the problem with adult learning is that adults don't have time" to "children should be deprived of a learning environment"? There seems to be a step missing.
Please read what people ACTUALLY wrote and not what you THINK they wrote.