4 ms·
OK, so let's actually talk about those people then. The theory is that there is an unavoidable compromise between privacy and features and some people will legi
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
OK, so let's actually talk about those people then. The theory is that there is an unavoidable compromise between privacy and features and some people will legitimately choose features. That can be true, e.g. to do "people like you also viewed ..." you need the data on what people like you also viewed.
But those things are relatively rare and can be separated out. You can layer them on top of a decentralized system -- run this separate program that tells The Cloud everything you click on and in exchange you get the benefit of data from other people who make the same choice. That is still possible even if a video from your family gets downloaded P2P directly from your actual friends and no corporation automatically finds out about it and stores it in a database forever.
The problem currently is that the decision of whether to give up privacy is not tied only to the few features that legitimately require giving it up, it's also tied to participating in the same networks as the majority of people and many other features that don't inherently require privacy invasion.
Decentralization doesn't take away the choice whether to share data from the people who want to do that, it gives it back to the people who don't.
- dsacco 10y agoThe data analysis required to improve search relevance, video recommendation, A/B testing, feature improvement - basically anything, relies on crunching data on as many users as possible. For example, you cannot get to Google or Facebook's level of artificial intelligence research and performance achievements without truly vast amounts of data. This criticism of decentralization is in addition to my parallel comment in this thread about how you cannot realistically and significantly improve privacy with feature parity. The performance and reliability would also be difficult to manage without centralized servers. You're not going to be maintaining the same uptime guarantees. Finally, how are you going to motivate development in a decentralized manner? You're removing capitalist incentives to improve the product. This would have to be managed by a consortium of companies, which doesn't sound like a much better situation than we have now, or it would have to be an open protocol. If companies weren't earning a profit on developing features for further user demand, how would the products improve as well as they do now?
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> For example, you cannot get to Google or Facebook's level of artificial intelligence research and performance achievements without truly vast amounts of data. This argument is self-defeating. If any significant plurality (e.g. a third) of people opt into the "privacy for analysis" setting then you still have "truly vast amounts of data" and there is no trouble. Whereas if so few people want to make that exchange when the choice is made explicit that it can't even work properly then it doesn't matter how well it works because nearly everyone doesn't use it. > The performance and reliability would also be difficult to manage without centralized servers. You're not going to be maintaining the same uptime guarantees. Uptime is just math. You decide how much service uptime you need and based on the average device uptime that determines how much redundancy is necessary to achieve it. Consumer devices have lower uptime so you need somewhat more redundancy. And in practice not even much of that, because you want "close copies" (to improve latency/efficiency) anyway, so if you have enough copies for that then a failure doesn't reduce uptime, it just requires you to use a far copy that once. Moreover, if you have something that really does need specific uptime guarantees or is unusually likely to incur a DDoS, nothing stops you from pinning it to a P2P node hosted on the likes of AWS or CloudFlare. Then to lose uptime you have to lose the entire P2P network and CloudFlare. > Finally, how are you going to motivate development in a decentralized manner? Much the same way as we motivate development of Windows, Linux and Wikipedia.
- smallnamespace 10y agoIf you depend on P2P to avoid centralized servers, you're just moving the data security issues to devices that are much, much harder to lock down. That can make privacy much worse in a practical sense. Not to mention the difficulties of reindexing and fast retrieval over P2P. If I need to add an additional index on my centralized servers, the development cycle is much shorter than forcing every peer to reindex itself.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> If you depend on P2P to avoid centralized servers, you're just moving the data security issues to devices that are much, much harder to lock down. That can make privacy much worse in a practical sense. There is no magic security pixie dust inside a data center. If the server is vulnerable and your data is on the server then you're the same amount of screwed as if the P2P app is vulnerable and your data is on the client. Possibly more screwed because central servers have data for multiple users which give the attackers more incentive to break into them. > If I need to add an additional index on my centralized servers, the development cycle is much shorter than forcing every peer to reindex itself. And why is that?