5 ms·
I used IRC for over 10 years, but after using Slack for 1 it just felt outdated to me. Offline messages and simulatnous logins from multiple places are just tw
by k__ 10y ago
I used IRC for over 10 years, but after using Slack for 1 it just felt outdated to me.
Offline messages and simulatnous logins from multiple places are just two features I was missing in IRC and didn't even know till I had them, haha.
But yeah, IRC networks just worked as message broker and not as databases, so I never thought about it.
- DiabloD3 10y agoI use ZNC, so logging in from multiple places works well.
- agentdrtran 10y agoBut now you have to run a ZNC server as well - it's a lot more work for a very simple feature.
- lorenzhs 10y agoWeeChat + relay clients can do it as well, you only run weechat in a tmux/screen somwhere and connect to it with a relay client (Glowing Bear or WeeChat-Android). Works nicely, with synced state and arbitrary history scrollback
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt's not "very simple" - it's just that with Slack, someone else is running ZNC for you. Chat apps don't magically "just work" - either you run your own infrastructure, or use someone else's.
- CJefferson 10y agoEven with IRC you are still using someone else' infrastructure -- unless you run your own IRC network from scratch of course.
- nucleardog 10y agoIf you ever want to feel like you're bashing your head against a brick wall over and over, set up an IRC server with channel/nick services.
- spike021 10y agoI honestly just run a raspberry pi that has Weechat running all the time in a tmux session. So I just SSH whenever I need from wherever, pretty much (with obvious security settings configured). It works really well and is a cheap solution.
- RamenJunkie_ 10y agoZNC is great. I run it on a Pi so I don't even really have to worry about reboots or anything on another machine.
- xir78 10y agoAlso not being able to see or search chat history was a deal breaker for IRC. It's like the days before answering machines...
- eikenberry 10y agoDo you mean searching the history of when you weren't online? As every client I know of can keep a history of your sessions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- xir78 10y agoRight, when not online.
- mclellac 10y agoI'd argue that most people that use IRC use shells and a terminal multiplexer to access IRC, and this isn't an issue for them.
- superkuh 10y agoSlack isn't an IRC replacement. It's business trying to embrace, extend, and extinguish the IRC protocol so they can capture the business market that uses IRC and collect rent.
- wtbob 10y agoThat's why I use Mattermost, which Slack Without the Suck™. It's free, fast, easy to use, visually appealing, supports PostgreSQL — what more could I ask for? Well, a native Android client. But other than that, what more could I ask for?
- superkuh 10y agoCompatibility with a real protocol, IRC, instead of just a marginal bridge. Mattermost will still splinter communities.
- Karunamon 10y agoThe "real protocol" sucks on ice nowadays. No conversation history, no offline message storing, no push notifications, absolutely none of the niceties we've learned since 1990. The whole reason the Slacks and Hipchats and Discords of the world exist is that IRC is a terribly limited protocol that many people have tried to hang enhanced functionality on top of and none have succeeded. Personally, I'm in favor of letting the better product win. IRC has been objectively superseded in nearly every way that matters.
- superkuh 10y agoI don't know about you but I have all of those things simply by leaving my bog standard IRC client connected to the networks. IRC is not a limited protocol. What is happening is that people are using limited computers and networks (smart phones) that aren't capable of the same thing a 1990s computer was.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago