4 ms·
I hate these kinds of assumptions ... "There’s a reason adults don’t pick up Japanese or learn how to kite surf. It’s ridiculously hard. In stark contrast, you
by bsder 10y ago
I hate these kinds of assumptions ...
"There’s a reason adults don’t pick up Japanese or learn how to kite surf. It’s ridiculously hard. In stark contrast, young people can learn the most difficult things relatively easily. Polynomials, Chinese, skateboarding — no problem!"
Um, ask some teachers about how easy that is sometime. I'm sure you'd get an earful.
The biggest difference between adults and children is not neuroplasticity--the biggest difference is TIME.
Children can spend 4+ hours a day learning a language, playing guitar, drawing, etc. In one year, that's roughly 1,000 hours.
I would challenge you to find an adult who can commit 1,000 hours in a year into learning something completely new.
In addition, children have a much better reinforcement loop. A child who can say even a couple of words in a foreign language will get wonderful praise; an adult won't receive praise until he can practically get a PhD in the language. Musical instruments are similar--a child can bang out stuff and everybody thinks it's wonderful--one wrong note as an adult and everybody is a critic.
I suspect there is some neuroplasticity involved in language--certain sounds seem to be indistinguishable to non-native speakers after a certain age. However, I suspect that the neuroplasticity is dwarfed by simple time.
I see little value in futzing with drugging the brain until we normalize things like time.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoExactly this. As an adult, it's close to impossible for me to find an uninterrupted block of 4+ hours without risking problems at work or with some errands. And I'm not even married, and don't have children yet!. A related thing is that kids don't worry. As a child, I could easily blow half a day - or half a week - playing with some new idea, because I knew I'll have more of free time next day, and the day after that, etc. As an adult, time is so precious that I often don't do something because I know I won't have enough time to finish it. Sure, a lot of problems here could be solved if one was better at micromanaging[0] their own time. And maybe more assertive than I am; getting time to learn involves saying "fuck you" to a lot of people who desperately want your attention. But still, I think the primary reason adults learn much less than children is that they don't have time - and energy - after spending more than half of their waking day at work[1]. -- [0] - In the StarCraft sense. Using time well too often feels like fighting 2 vs 1, where your enemies have already taken half 3/4 of the map, your economy is barely functional, and the only chance of winning you have is to outmicro them. [1] - Often closer to 2/3 if you factor in commute and meals.
- negamax 10y agoI was surprised by this statement. As someone surrounded by really smart people of all age groups, specially the olds; I find it wrong. It could simply be personal belief thing instead of natural limit
- fma 10y agoWow, did you read the article or just the first sentence and only came here to post your pseudo scientific thoughts? I'm no neuroscientist but I just had a child and read up on brain development. Your assumption that main difference is time is not only wrong but dangerous. I was going to cite you some research but the article does a pretty good job in going into detail why it's not just time. Yes, if you spend enough time or something you can eventually catch up but you have it backwards. Neuroplasticity dwarfs time. If your assumption is all about time, then the feral children the article talks about would be able to acquire language. I'm sure they have plenty of time and teachers after being found in the wild! I seriously hope if you have kids or plan to have kids, you do not assume they can catch up later on and that you give them to proper learning environment when they are young. Otherwise your child may be closer to those feral children.
- wodencafe 10y ago>Wow, did you read the article or just the first sentence and only came here to post your pseudo scientific thoughts? Why are you so vehemently disagreeing with someone else's anecdotal experience? >I'm no neuroscientist but I just had a child and read up on brain development His opinion is wrong because you read something and just had a baby?
- JadeNB 10y ago> Why are you so vehemently disagreeing with someone else's anecdotal experience? > His opinion is wrong because you read something and just had a baby? To be clear, what I am about to say is a response only to your post, not to the debate about the accuracy of the article. Although it was supported by opinion and anecdotal experience, the main thrust of bsder's post (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12670315 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12670315) seemed to be that the article, not his or her opinion, was a matter of assumption: > I hate these kinds of assumptions ... and that his or her objection was a matter of fact: > The biggest difference between adults and children is not neuroplasticity--the biggest difference is TIME.
- coldtea 10y ago>Why are you so vehemently disagreeing with someone else's anecdotal experience? Because it was communicated while dissing on the article and the research results, as if personal experience trumps everything and those people that say otherwise are just lazy. >His opinion is wrong because you read something and just had a baby? No, but your comment is wrong because you put words in the other guy's month that he didn't say to manipulate people's perception of his argument. He doesn't say the other guy is wrong "because he read something and just had a baby". That is, he doesn't say: "You're wrong because I read War And Peace and also just had a baby, so I'm right". He says that the other guy is wrong because his anecdotal opinion doesn't agree with what brain development books say. So, (a) he only mentions the fact that he had a baby as an aside, to just convey us his motivation behind "reading up on brain development", and (b) he is not just saying he "read something", he's saying he read books about brain development. You can dispute whether he did or not, or come up with other books on brain development that say otherwise, but your framing of what he said is in bad faith.
- collyw 10y agoKids definitely learn languages more easily. I say this as a 42 year old living in a country where the language is different from my own.
- jbverschoor 10y agoI disagree... you just need to put in the proper time, and kind of activity. What approach did you take? How many hours per day were you actively exposed and trying to understand?
- fma 10y agoYou might disagree, but the scientific community disagrees with you. A new brain allows a child to learn language much faster than an old brain. The poster isn't saying he can't learn new language, but it's more difficult.
- Ericson2314 10y agoI've been told that the window for accelersted language learning is much shorter than general high neuroplasticity, and that the best language-learners are adults that practice learning new languages over and over again.
- BjoernKW 10y ago> I suspect there is some neuroplasticity involved in language--certain sounds seem to be indistinguishable to non-native speakers after a certain age. I suppose (just my personal not scientifically founded opinion) being able to distinguish foreign language phonemes is a skill akin to absolute pitch. If you acquire it early on you'll be able to apply it to whatever new language you encounter later in life. It'd be interesting to see if this also applies to phonemes that are formed in a manner entirely from the ones you're used to from your native language (like being able to grasp tonemes in Mandarin Chinese as a native English speaker). Then again a lack in pronunciation skills in a particular foreign language also often is simply about utility: Using your own native set of phonemes to mimic foreign language phonemes most of the time will get you far enough to be reasonably understandable while adopting truly native-sounding phonetics means a lot of additional work with often little perceived benefit. I suppose the Pareto principle applies in that case.
- lambdadmitry 10y agoSpeaking from my experience: I've just recently started to work with a phoneticist to improve my English accent and those lessons opened a whole new world of how people speak to me. I've started to discern a ton of new sounds, hearing things I'd never been able to hear before (e.g. how æn is almost a diphthong in American English). I hadn't any special training earlier in my life (I'm 26 now), so I think an ability to discern phonemes in a foreign language can be acquired while being an adult at least in some cases.
- wodencafe 10y ago100% this. My mother has been in college / school since I can remember, with brief periods of work in between. She is in her 50's now, has several degrees, but more to learn and master so she keeps on going. She is one of the few adults who has both the time, determination and opportunity to learn new subjects, study, do homework, put hours upon hours of time into learning - and consistently makes all A's. So basically, I see the requirements of learning in later life as hard work, time, determination and opportunity - not brain plasticity.
- Retric 10y agoI don't think you spend a lot of time around children they can pick up new things very quickly, but they are missing out on some basic skills. Playing an instrument is a mix of hand eye coordination which is hard for kids, and a new set of mental process which is easy. Adults have the opposite problem, they have plenty of hand dexterity but have a hard time without a background in music.
- sukilot 10y agoHand-eye coordination is a mental process. And somee adults don't have it -- can they learn it?
- Retric 10y agoI am not talking about throwing a ball. Learning to make a lowercase "e" takes ~0.1 cm presison which is just well outside what you need for most things. Now shure people can learn to write or thread a needle as an adult, but generally people learn how to stabilize their hands well before adulthood which is a major issue for kids.
- bsder 10y ago> I don't think you spend a lot of time around children they can pick up new things very quickly, but they are missing out on some basic skills. Ah, now this is something dear to my heart. Adults and children learn DIFFERENTLY. THAT I agree with. My personal bane for this was learning Japanese Kanji. Why in the world are we learning them in this stupid order? Because that's the order they are taught in Japanese schools. Except, I'm an adult. I'm not limited in my conception like a child is. I don't need to you stick to "concrete" vocabulary because I can't conceive of things like "self", "ward", or "length" (examples of low stroke count kanji taught in later grades). As an adult, learning kanji by either stroke count or radical (reinforces the patterns and chunks of the kanji) or by frequency of use (reinforces actual usage), is going to get me significantly better results. However, all the textbooks are written to learn kanji in school order.