3 ms·
Then we'll just build steam engines again. Maybe nuclear instead of coal-fired? The Germans haven't banned those, they just got quickly replaced by ICEs. Why ba
by petre 10y ago
Then we'll just build steam engines again. Maybe nuclear instead of coal-fired? The Germans haven't banned those, they just got quickly replaced by ICEs. Why ban? Why not just let the market handle things?
- y4mi 10y agobecause the German government is in a different situation compared to the american parliament. one of their founding principles is to literally lead the population in controversial topics after taking counsel from experts and forcing sane actions on the population. i'd actually be glad if this would be passed, not that it has any kind of chance of ever passing. it would decrease the car noise significantly inside cities, and i neither need nor own a car anyway.
- Sylos 10y agoBecause there's a good chance that the economy couldn't handle it on their own, or that they would take very long. There's the chicken-egg-problem of no one driving electric cars, therefore no one building charging stations, therefore no one buying electric cars. This problem isn't going to solve itself without someone investing a lot of money into building charging stations. And so far, such an investment was an extreme risk. There was no guarantee that you'd make a dime off of your money. With this ban upcoming, you're essentially guaranteed to make money in at most 15 years.
- petre 10y agoMaybe electric cars are not that great then? If an electric car would cost somethilng like a regular car and offer 600 km range on a "tank" full of electricity or hydrogen, everyone would buy one without the need of banning regular cars. This is exactly how railway steam engines lost ground to diesel and then to electric. Electric cars already have other advantages such as the lack of needong a gearbox, very good torque/seed characteristic which enables fast acceleration. I'm all for electric cars, but outright banning regular cars at EU level just feels plain wrong. What about forcing this upon other less wealthy EU member states, just like they did with migrant quotas? Selectively banning them at city level by the local authorities due to pollution and noise is a much better idea.
- dsfyu404ed 10y ago>What about forcing this upon other less wealthy EU member states, just like they did with migrant quotas This. If you can handle the economic fallout from doubling down on teslas, volts and leafs and legislating away everything else then good for you but don't make everyone else do it.
- jdietrich 10y ago>Why not just let the market handle things? Unpriced externalities represent a huge market failure. Respiratory illness, floods and droughts due to climate change, resource wars in the middle east. Fossil fuels impose a cost on other people that is not priced in. Gasoline is cheap like dumping toxic waste in a river is cheap. You pass the real costs on to some schmuck downstream. You could put a tax on dumping toxic waste in rivers. You could establish some kind of toxic waste credits scheme, where dumpers of toxic waste buy credits from people who clean it up. Most of us would agree that the more sensible option is simply to ban the dumping of toxic waste. http://www.ucsusa.org/clean-energy/our-energy-choices/coal-and-other-fossil-fuels/hidden-cost-of-fossils http://www.ucsusa.org/clean-energy/our-energy-choices/coal-a...