3 ms·
I wonder if this is the reason: "I inspected the kernel source code. Samsung charges the note 7 battery at just over 4.35v Older models have 4.35v batteries b
by sschueller 10y ago
I wonder if this is the reason:
"I inspected the kernel source code. Samsung charges the note 7 battery at just over 4.35v
Older models have 4.35v batteries but only charge to 4.3v.
If you put a generic 4.2v lithium ion battery in, they survive 4.3v with a reduction in charge cycles but anything above that causes formation of metallic lithium dendrites, a non reversible process that eventually causes a fire. This policy makes sense if you have removable batteries as there are lots of fake genuine samsung batteries. But you want maximum battery life using special 4.35v cells. Perhaps they thought with a sealed battery they could hit 4.35v?
The chemistry is not hugely different, just uses more expensive elements. So a factory trying to minimise cost could easily introduce a defect from changing from one type to another etc.
So this tiny change could cause a defective battery to catch fire where it normally would not.
Doesnt matter how you charge it, more how long it sits above 4.30v at ~60-100% float charge.
So samsungs 60% charge resolves 2 issues, peak voltage above 4.3 and energy release on failure.
Imho they need to go back to 4.3v policy rather than just replace and assume its a once off.Lithium batteries used in phones dont catch fire without physical damage like a knife or overvoltage. That's why this is so unusual.
Ps kernel source is available from samsungs website because android is based on linux.
Tldr: policy change from 4.3v float charge to 4.35vwhich I have confirmed by examining source code available on samsungs website would explain the fires"
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/560luq/slug/d8fhh2s https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/560luq/slug/d8fhh2...
- micaksica 10y agoOther Reddit threads have stated that this is inaccurate, and the S6+ use 4.4V batteries.
- laurentdc 10y agoThat sound weird, a 0.05V fluctuation should be well within tolerance. Otherwise there'd be plenty of phones blowing up out of nowhere due to glitches or random overshoots from the charging circuitry.
- petertodd 10y agoCharge circuitry can easily maintain a ±0.05V voltage tolerance if needed. For example, googling for datasheets found this charge controller IC with 1% tolerance: http://cds.linear.com/docs/en/datasheet/4050f.pdf http://cds.linear.com/docs/en/datasheet/4050f.pdf I'm no expert on battery chargers, but I can certainly imagine a design using that kind of tolerance if it made the batteries work better; holding that kind of tolerance is fairly cheap these days. Re: glitches, I'd imagine that a battery isn't going to care about extremely short duration events; preventing longer-duration overshoots isn't all that hard.
- qb45 10y agoYour argument would be valid if they all exploded neatly when reaching 100% charge, not when there actually is "plenty of phones blowing up out of nowhere".