10 ms·
San Jose: New law would make city first to allow “tiny homes” for homeless
- hiou 10y ago> the former accountant ended up outdoors after a divorce and a brain tumor. Sounds like our current resource allocation system here in the US is working great! Seems like a totally sensible reason for a human being to be forced to live without basic shelter. They obviously have no useful skills to provide society so let's just throw them away. What a time to be alive!
- grecy 10y agoIt is truly sad that in by far the richest country in the world, and ostensibly the best, millions of people are living this way. Why on earth Americans are not fixing America, I have no idea.
- Lintaris 10y agoYou are richer when you do not squander the wealth into social programs. /s
- ljf 10y agoAs a Brit and a left leaning type, it baffles me to see America. From talking to friends who live there (I won't pretend I know fully) but it seems between income, state and property taxes you guys pay a lot. Add in health care and it seems you pay in line with or above many European countries. Yet with your society's wealth there seems a resistance to supporting your own people, and almost actively seeking to add to the poverty through the prison and court system. It seems crazy, when getting these people up and productive, would not only be the moral (Christian?) thing to do, but would ultimately also add to the wealth of the nation. Is it because in America who are 'your own people'?
- noir_lord 10y agoAs a fellow left leaning Brit the pull yourself up by the bootstraps thing always seemed strange, sometimes people just don't have the bootstraps to start with!
- joesmo 10y agoAnd, just as the literal interpretation of the phrase, the figurative interpretation is impossible (even if you have bootstraps). That's why it's not happening. It's enough though, for the masses of people to be stupid enough as they are in America to believe that this is possible to create such a messed up society.
- shados 10y agoWell, most important is how inefficient the country is. All governments are corrupt: thats true in Europe, its true in Canada, but its 10x true in the US. It's no China or Russia, but its pretty bad. Second, you said "resistance to supporting your own people". Well, even if you don't resist, thats very difficult because figuring out who "your own people" is, is nearly impossible here because of the immigration situation. Regardless of stance on immigration, the fact is that the way to most efficiently reduce poverty will differ based on if someone has been here all along and got screwed, based on if they are refugees, or if they came by other means. You have to analyze the pipeline and allocate resources, people, and programs for both prevention, and for safety nets. People make it so damn hard to differentiate and allocate logically, its impossible to be efficient there. (Note that I'm a green card holder, I wasn't born in the US, so this is just what I'm seeing in polar contrast to my home country). When data is collected and surveys/analysis presented, most of the time everything will be mixed in without separating root causes (someone who fell into poverty because of medical bills, is a very different problem to solve than someone who came here being poor in the first place). And then there's the racism situation... So authorities are left with 1 size fit all programs that get abused left and right, with corruption sprinkled in to make it harder. Yeah, its impossible to fix things this way.
- mmmBacon 10y agoWe pay almost 50% in taxes which I think is close to what you guys pay in Europe. The lions share goes to Washington where as far as I can tell it either evaporates or gets spent on very expensive jobs programs like the F-35. Our states do a better job generally and provide the bulk of the services. However in many cities and states the budgets are consumed by pensions leaving less for services each year. A person who works in government can retire with 80% pay at 55 after 20 years with their pension based on last 2 years. As people live longer, many people are collecting pensions for more years than they worked. The problem is that we already pay a lot in taxes and we get poor returns on this money as it is. I think there would be more people willing to pay more if they thought money was the answer and it would help people. Most people think the money would just be wasted. At the same time we also have large numbers of people who pay no taxes, 51%. So as our population grows, the demand for services increases but the percentage of tax paying citizens is not increasing. We have a real mess here.
- enraged_camel 10y agoLooks like the conservative crowd on HN is downvoting you, but that's probably because the truth makes them uncomfortable. The United States is by far the richest country in the entire history of the world. Every American should be deeply ashamed and embarrassed by the sheer number of people who don't have access to the most basic needs.
- oldmanjay 10y agoI never feel shame and embarrassment over actions other people have taken. Why would I?
- enraged_camel 10y agoWhat about pride? Do you feel proud when your country does something good?
- usaphp 10y agoWell just look at the president candidates for the most powerful and richest country in the world. How is that possible that in a whole country of many smart people these two individuals could get someone's votes.
- TaylorAlexander 10y agoI've found that America makes a lot more sense when you think of it as a country run by rich people, with a whole lot of workers. For the rich, this place is amazing. The rich have all the political power, so this makes sense. You'd think the working class has political power but their opinions are controlled by the wealthy. So for the people running America, there's nothing to fix. The system is designed to produce exactly what it produces. The fact that there's no shelter or health care for the poor is a result of the fact that the poor in America are discarded. We don't have a cultural respect for human life here. We have business. And business doesn't need poor people. They're not good workers or good consumers. I'd like things to be different, and I'm working on it, but I don't have much power at the moment.
- grecy 10y ago> I've found that America makes a lot more sense when you think of it as a country run by rich people, with a whole lot of workers. For the rich, this place is amazing. That's an excellent insight, and it agrees with my experience. When I lived there I was earning minimum wage, as were all my (local) friends and I was not impressed. Friends who needed surgery could not afford it, could not afford car insurance, etc. etc. A few years later I met an Aussie working in a very high paying Engineering job and he loved the country because when you have money, you can own and do anything you want. You are a god. >We don't have a cultural respect for human life here. We have business. It blows my mind that masses have not voted to do something about this to better their lot.
- Roboprog 10y agoI think there are often several candidates in the primary election for any given office (not just president) that would like to, but it only takes one stalking horse funded by the rich in either party to ad-bomb the election, fragment the vote between the better alternatives, and rake in a plurality of the votes for the win. There are probably several ways around that, but why change it, since the system is "working"?
- TaylorAlexander 10y ago>It blows my mind that masses have not voted to do something about this to better their lot. The media is very powerful here.
- prostoalex 10y ago> by far the richest country in the world Based on what criteria? You can tell who the richest person in the world is by subtracting his liabilities from his assets and arriving at a large number. US budget liabilities exceeded US budget revenues for quite a bit now.
- internaut 10y agoYou could also read it as a societal trouble that family didn't look after her.
- plandis 10y agoSeattle has already been doing this for at least a year.
- uxcn 10y agoSeattle has set up more than one tiny house village [1], at least that I know of. Some of them even have internet access. We still have a very real homeless problem though, and you'll see panhandlers if you drive through the city. People have even set up camps along I-5. [1] http://www.kiro7.com/news/seattles-first-tiny-house-village-homeless-open-we/40000629 http://www.kiro7.com/news/seattles-first-tiny-house-village-...
- Chronic9q 10y agoDo democratic/left/liberal states generate or attract more homelessness? Seems to happen with many other liberal city hubs.
- SomewhatLikely 10y agoThe homeless problem is worst in cities that are doing the best.
- ocschwar 10y agoRed states have a habit of having the police "suggest" to homeless people that they should get on the Greyhound bus to places like SF and Seattle. And add to that the factor of both cities have weather that doesn't kill the homeless as quickly.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoAre the building codes really so restrictive as to prevent building housing for homeless people without ignoring them?
- brianwawok 10y agoAlmost anywhere in the US has very strict building codes.
- apsec112 10y agoYes. That's largely why they exist. Zoning codes were often created with an explicit goal of keeping poor/black people out of rich/white neighborhoods. https://www.flickr.com/photos/seattlemunicipalarchives/3588926209 https://www.flickr.com/photos/seattlemunicipalarchives/35889...
- throwaway729 10y agoNot sure why you're being down-voted, other than that the evidence you provided isn't very compelling. For people who think this is hyperbole, it is not. Zoning codes also exist for a lot of other (good) reasons, but there are large sections of zoning codes (esp. regarding the type of housing allowed within a residentially zoned area) that were absolutely created with explicitly and openly racist intent. Sometimes those sections of code are still with us today. Sometimes they've been removed. But in both cases, the effects of those zoning laws on communities reverberates today: http://reason.com/archives/2014/04/02/zonings-racist-roots-still-bear-fruit http://reason.com/archives/2014/04/02/zonings-racist-roots-s... http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/05/the-racist-housing-policy-that-made-your-neighborhood/371439/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/05/the-raci...
- throwaway_911 10y agoResidential segregation is the large scale observable effect of small biases. http://ncase.me/polygons http://ncase.me/polygons. To end residential segregation is to either end the biases themselves or the freedom to express them. Either approach is rather distopian, with strong reverberations in the worst abuses of the Soviet regime.
- unethical_ban 10y agoThere are a lot of building codes that are incredibly stupid. For things like this (homebuilding) where the competition is heavy and consumers have a choice (within a spending limit), I feel only the most bare of safety requirements should be law. All other standards related to efficiency, "above-and-beyond" safety and design considerations should be met and advertised via certifications. Almost every zoning law probably has a good reason behind it, ostensibly. Someone died in a fire because there wasn't a window, so every room needs a window, for example. But if we legislated like that for every accident, we'd be suffocated by regulations.
- wolfgke 10y ago> But if we legislated like that for every accident, we'd be suffocated by regulations. We are already suffocated by regulations.
- paulddraper 10y ago> Because we legislated like that for every accident, we're suffocated by regulations. FTFY
- prostoalex 10y agoIf I had to guess, it's also liability derived from the close proximity of houses in urban setting. The home owner might be cavalier about fire safety or noise containment, but his neighbor might have a strong opinion about those, the strength of the opinion being directly proportional to the proximity of two dwellings.
- notliketherest 10y agoThis is a mistake. As soon as you allow squatters to essentially start building shanty town communities, you are going to start exacerbating a lot of problems: drugs, crime, rape. All one needs to do is travel to Brazil and see the favelas to see the effects of an unchecked, institutionalized homeless population.
- 35bge57dtjku 10y agoPeople have pointed out that some crime concentrates in these tent cities in Seattle. But I have yet to hear evidence that it's actually creating more crime. And there's plenty of crime that happens outside of those places in Seattle, like a totally insane number of car break ins.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- h4nkoslo 10y agoA cluster of "tiny homes" is indistinguishable from a "trailer park". There are actually very nice trailer parks / prefab house / mobile home communities, that cater to specific populations (especially retirement communities). They have a bad reputation in general because of the modal kind of person who inhabits them, not some sort of inherent characteristic of the construction style.
- Roboprog 10y agoI guess it's quick, but the apartments they are supposedly planning would seem a much better use of land.
- nwenzel 10y agoHonest question: Do any class or all classes of people (citizens, legal immigrants, illegal immigrants, refugees, criminals, teachers, disabled, adults, children, or any other type of people) have a right to a home or some other minimum level of shelter? Seems like discussion on homelessness would be slightly easier if we started from first principles or at least some place where there is closer to a consensus.
- pboutros 10y agoMorally, yes (IMO), legally, no. Let's get the laws closer to what's right.
- daenz 10y agoWhat amenities does the legal definition of "home" include? Just a roof and walls? Running water? Electricity?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Redoubts 10y agoMaybe, but does location of choice count as part of that minimum level?
- bufordsharkley 10y agoIt's important to recognize that the problem isn't that shelter is expensive, but that land is expensive. And to reframe the question, do all people have a right not to be excluded from land (without a commensurate payment)? I believe the answer is a resounding yes. Note: I'm a Georgist. [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism
- internaut 10y agoHow about the people who decided that they didn't like their land in Nigeria, but decided to move to Dublin, Ireland because they like it there better. What then? Government creates property rights, which is what Land really is about, and there appears to be a limited supply to go around. Thereby only citizens of a country who pay taxes should have the right to own Land. Does this make sense?
- aphextron 10y agoAm I alone in finding this "tiny home" trend insane? There's nothing wrong with downsizing, but just call it what it is: a mobile home or a trailer. Companies have been engineering mobile homes for decades to be highly efficient, long lasting, and fuel efficient for towing. Slapping a bunch of heavy wooden shingles on one and calling it a "tiny home" is just feel-good hipster nonsense.
- runamok 10y agoExcept that most cities criminalize living out of your vehicle. Renting a space to put your RV, mobile home, etc. is a non-trivial expense for many. I read an article about how emotionally draining it was for people to constantly have to move around, worry about police, get hassled by residents, not know where they could shower or eat, etc. but I can't find it now. Not to mention I can't imagine how hard it is to fall asleep and actually rest with all those fears. Some articles: http://mv-voice.com/news/2015/10/23/makeshift-rv-camps-spark-concern http://mv-voice.com/news/2015/10/23/makeshift-rv-camps-spark... http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/high-rents-force-silicon-valley-live-vehicles/ http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/high-rents-force-silicon-vall... http://www.businessinsider.com/inside-the-silicon-valley-van-dwellers-reddit-community-2016-6 http://www.businessinsider.com/inside-the-silicon-valley-van... http://www.siliconvalleydebug.org/articles/2015/03/04/only-affordable-place-live-san-jose-my-car http://www.siliconvalleydebug.org/articles/2015/03/04/only-a... https://www.quora.com/When-living-out-of-your-car-where-are-the-best-places-to-park-to-avoid-being-noticed https://www.quora.com/When-living-out-of-your-car-where-are-... https://www.quora.com/When-living-out-of-your-car-where-are-the-best-places-to-park-to-avoid-being-noticed https://www.quora.com/When-living-out-of-your-car-where-are-... http://gawker.com/you-better-not-outlaw-living-in-cars-unless-youre-givin-1561291148 http://gawker.com/you-better-not-outlaw-living-in-cars-unles...
- internaut 10y agoTiny Houser here. Could be insane. Mz called me eccentric recently. Sounds like a prelude to the full thing! > There's nothing wrong with downsizing, but just call it what it is: a mobile home or a trailer. You can call it whatever you like. There is a certain amount of class warfare between Tiny Housers and people living in RV parks which I won't try to justify. > Companies have been engineering mobile homes for decades to be highly efficient, long lasting, and fuel efficient for towing. This is not true at all. 1. It is not legal to live in trailers. 2. Most mobile phones are not capable of being 4 season dwellings because they don't meet air tightness and insulation levels of traditional houses. 3. Mobile homes were originally not supposed to be for permanent trailer parks. RV living is a hack like THs are. I think it started after the Great Depression, which would be analogous to the Great Stagnation we're in that produced the popularity of Tiny Houses. 4. The most important thing is the use case for a TH is totally different to an RV or mobile home. A TH is supposed to be lived in full time and quite rarely traveled around with. 90% of tiny housers would only move their house once a year and many of them never will. The people who have them light enough for frequent travel are the exceptions. 5. A properly constructed Tiny House will last > 60 years like a traditional house. RVs don't have that longevity. > Slapping a bunch of heavy wooden shingles on one and calling it a "tiny home" is just feel-good hipster nonsense. Traditional housing has identical materials and procedures to Tiny Houses. I suppose a house is just a bunch of material slapped together as well. I think if you stepped inside a well built and designed Tiny House, your skepticism would fade away. They really are different to mobile homes. The sills are thicker, the furnishings are more homely, the walls aren't plastic. There are some really nice mobile homes out there but they just don't have the same use case. One negative thing I shall say about Tiny Housers is that some of them think they 'chose' this lifestyle being they're superior beings. A minimalist lifestyle is fine but it is primarily about economics.