7 ms·
4chan, a popular hub for offensive posts, shows signs of distress
- oldmanjay 10y agoI'm not certain, CNN, should I find 4chan offensive? Could you please hammer the answer into my head about a billion fucking times in one article
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- btrfsck 10y agoI don't think anyone involved in writing, or anyone mentioned in this article has any idea what 4chan actually represents, with the exception of Nisimura and Shkreli. I think it's really dishonest to represent 4chan as "ground zero for orchestrated harassment" and "[a site where] some of its users created a set of code words to help users make racist and bigoted slurs". It's like saying Earth is a place where people have their organs stolen and sold and where babies die. It is technically correct, of course, but it's very disingenuous to describe it that way to outsiders. I would go on and talk about what I think 4chan really stands for, but I assume most people on HN are pretty familiar with the site, so just know that I am in the camp that likes how it is (or used to be?) a last bastion of freedom and anonymity (not Tor-like, but where the UX is designed to not have profiles and usernames) and free discourse on the internet. The main thing I want to mention is that having money problems is absolutely nothing new to 4chan. Moot's comments have traditionally been along the lines of "4chan will always consume all available bandwidth". The nature of the site limits it to either leery advertisers, or people like JList (where 4channers are almost exactly their target audience). So advertising has always been hard for 4chan. Personally, I think the 4chan pass is the key way to move forward for 4chan, or solicit donations more openly (perhaps a progress bar that shows % of monthly fees that have been paid?). Funding 4chan is definitely a hard problem, but it has existed for more than a decade, and has been mostly well-handled for that entire period. Time will tell, though.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>I would go on and talk about what I think 4chan really stands for, but I assume most people on HN are pretty familiar with the site, so just know that I am in the camp that likes how it is (or used to be?) a last bastion of freedom and anonymity (not Tor-like, but where the UX is designed to not have profiles and usernames) and free discourse on the internet. Well, noisy discourse, shitposting, and doubles threads. Actually, not really discourse at all. Mostly just heresy.
- tarancato 10y agoThere are boards and boards. And even in the worst boards there are good threads. It's a culture of its own, though.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoYes, I know. I just also don't really have any illusions that the "4chanish" population have any right to a subsidized forum for, well, being 4chanish. Deep down, it's a business run for profit by a private individual, not a piece of public property maintained with tax money.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoYeah, but have you considered that there's a developmental benefit to having somewhere you can go and just say "vile" things? I know having that kind of space online as I was coming-of-age was huge for me, it gave me somewhere to experiment with opinions without consequences. Somewhere to say truly, truly disgusting things. And I did, a lot. But over time, it became clear where I was just being offensive and experimenting with "naughty" ideas, where I was trolling, and where I genuinely disagreed with the norm. That free experimentation with opinions and language is a lot harder to find these days, but it really shaped and honed my ability to even form arguments, my ability to explain my position to people who don't agree with me, and my ability to listen to positions I find offensive. Not all discourse needs be Discourse, full of profundity and consequence; experimentation, freedom, and privacy are core to the human developmental and creative processes.
- ClassyJacket 10y ago>And the forum is pointed to as the origin of GamerGate, the controversial movement that views female gamers as ruining the gaming industry, leading to vitriolic online attacks on women. Laughably biased and wrong. Not even close to attempting an accurate description the situation.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoI'm not sure which of those you think is wrong, that excerpt seems pretty accurate to me.
- oolongCat 10y agoBecause the whole "gamergate" thing was not about attacking female gamers. If I recall correctly they were after people who were villainizing video games.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoYou recall incorrectly. (Originally it started about "ethics in video game journalism", but it took about two minutes for them to pivot to attacking women.)
- crooked-v 10y agoAny "ethics" stuff in the original allegations against Zoe Quinn was false in the first place, as anyone involved could have verified with about five minutes of research.
- crooked-v 10y agoYou don't recall correctly. The whole thing started with false accusations of unethical conduct against a particular female game developer (Zoe Quinn), followed by harrassment campaigns and personal threats against that same person.
- 10y ago
- h4nkoslo 10y agoI assume this article is designed to signal that the regime finds 4chan most distasteful, and would prefer for it not to be purchased, if you want to remain on their good side. Which makes total sense, since 4chan-derived memes have apparently broken into the mainstream against all odds, to the point where actual US presidential candidates (CNN's favored candidate, come to think of it) are declaring war on goddamn Pepe for excessively challenging their narrative control. The incredibly Darwinian environment is to memes what Chinese farms are for influenza, and we are beginning to see the real-world effects. In any event a few entities at varying levels of seriousness have inquired about the possibility of purchasing 4chan and received no response, so it's unclear what's actually going on.
- oolongCat 10y agoWhat's with CNN attacking 4chan so much these days? Funny how a media channel that used to do actual reporting has gone down to this level. I bet 4chan and its users are really happy with the free publicity.
- orionblastar 10y agoCNN is a liberal leaning news media company. 4Chan is a target for them because CNN is allies with SJWs and Femiists who are criticized on 4Chan. It is sort of like The Amazing Atheist on Youtube, he's negative and attacks Feminsts, so the Feminists attack him back. He's a Liberal, but he finds what Feminists and SJWs are doing is like another religion that makes females superior to males, and he says they should be equal with no one being superior.
- sctb 10y agoPlease resist introducing flamewar topics on HN like this.
- complaint 10y agoHopefully the final nail in the coffin of that vile site.
- astrodust 10y ago4chan ran its course, and it's long overdue for disruption. Even moot had to run away because of how much trouble it had become.
- chillingeffect 10y ago> Some of it is benign, like cat memes and the site LOLCats. But much of it is offensive. :) It's clever sleight of mouth to counterpose "benign" with "offensive," implying that offensive isn't benign. Sticks and stones. As a visitor for over a decade, I can say almost all of 4chan is benign as it's recipes, endless blather about anime and video games, fashion and music. Typical teenage stuff. The big difference between 4chan and most other places is the threshold for banning. In most forums, e.g. HN, if you speak against the forum, you get banned. On 4chan, you just get ignored and people get exposed and steeled against your ignorant behavior. It's really the logical conclusion of "not in my backyard" style management. If you keep pushing people out of your neighborhood, they'll end up somewhere and that place is 4chan. And typically people grow up and out of it. This article is testing peoples' reactions to a possible "victory for cleanliness" in the HRC victory. I imagine the center-right (which call themselves Democrats) will enjoy a good bit of muscle-flexing and creative interpretation of "freedom of speech" in the next 4-8 years. Finally, getting condemned by the Anti-Defamation League is not difficult. http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Anti-Defamation_League http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Anti-Defamation_League
- formula1 10y agoI understand that many on HN want to defend 4chan. While I am a firm believer in free speech what I find fascinating is that they paint offensive and disgusting content as humorous and worth debating. That being said, the board disappearing or losing popularity to the point of unusability is significant in a couple of ways to me. The first is that the wild west of the internet is coming to a close. Everything is being watched and "safe havens"/"rotting pools" are threats to an organized leadership. The second is that these kinds of groups have staying power outside a name. Can they migrate to new ownership or will they stay? I personally believe that 4chan will slow to a crawl and eventually viewership will die out. The third is about trust. 4chan is not anonymous unless you are behind trusted proxies and/or share ip addresses with harmless strangers. However, since the data is stored on the site, they have free reign over what they can do with your content. As a result, 4chan is only a "safe haven" because it is notoriously caustic. A fourth thing I found interesting was that the solutions to the 4chan problem were financially motivated rather than technically. Selling passes or threatening slowdowns sounds like a bullying. Im confident there are ways to offload parts such as using torrents as the post/image/video database rather than keep it. Turning 4chan into a "protocol" rather than a "website". But Im not suprised the site will be put in this position. Its basically a place for people to look im the mirror and wank off. It will probably not evolve to anything more than a place of contreversy because thats what makes it successful. Theres so much goo that can come out of free speech but the only things 4chan attracts are insecure rodents that want to pretend they are bigger than they are.
- orionblastar 10y agoI don't know how to defend 4Chan, but not everything is racist or offensive on it. Reddit was like 4Chan for a while until they started to ban users and subreddits, and the users hated it. Free Speech means that even offensive and racist and sexists things can be said, if you censor that stuff then you don't have freedom of speech. The Feminist, SJW, etc movements want a safe space on the Internet and that includes censoring and banning people. They will get companies not to advertise on a site that they don't like. Reddit had to do that to get more advertisers, 4Chan might have to do that too, but they are losing revenue and haven't done it yet. Sure I'm against sexist, racist, offensive stuff. I used to be a troll on some sites, and a mock conservative using Poe's Law that people thought I was a real one. In a way I am still a troll on some sites, just not as bad as the ones on 4Chan and others. I remember Republicanville was founded to compete with the Daily Kos, but a lot of racists got on there and ruined it, and it shut down. It was because The Daily Kos had a censorship and banning policy and Republicanville did not.
- pessimizer 10y agoAnd nothing of value was lost. The center of the internet cesspool wandered away from 4chan at least 5 years ago. Eventually, the site will shut down after passing through six to ten more hands. This will not affect 8chan, 420chan, anonib, 7chan, or any of the other dozens of sites that have popped in and out of existence for nearly as long as 4chan has existed, a number of which that are still around being only a couple of years younger. There will for the forseeable future be a place to post what you'll do when the id of a reply ends in 7, Jennifer Lawrence's hacked nude selfies, or your deeply held and extensively researched views on issues involving ethics in video game journalism. It's never going to be anyone's money factory, which I guess is what "CNN Money" would be concerned about.
- tfnw 10y agoI find 4chan valuable because it seems to give an insight to raw humanity without the self censoring common in normal human interaction. I would rather people tell me what they really think, and I hope that as humanity evolves, normal interaction will become more direct.
- k__ 10y agoYes. I think so too. The post are all that count. You can't vote someone up or down, like on HN just because you agree or disagree. You don't have to think about your personal reputation when you post and how much upvotes you get. Simply plain information. Yes there is a whole bunch of BS going on, if you visit stuff like /r9k/ and /pol/, full of nazis who think hate-speach is the essence of free speach. But the topic boards like /fit/ or /fa/ or /ck/ have really good distilled informations.
- tfnw 10y agoI don't like the endless repetition by people trying to exploit flaws in the human brain for their own purposes, but if you are able to mentally filter the inanity, you can experience the rare patches of awe inspiring creativity, well, at least I have been able to on occasion, I don't go there often and not recently so don't know if this is still true. As for the expression of unpopular opinion, I feel that a society that is able to handle it's members freely expressing the most offensive viewpoints is infinitely more robust than one where these things are left to simmer just below the surface.