4 ms·
Signing up for a job as an independent contractor agreed upon by both the contractor and the company...and then after the fact being told that they are actually
by brightball 10y ago
Signing up for a job as an independent contractor agreed upon by both the contractor and the company...and then after the fact being told that they are actually employees isn't protecting either party involved in the initial agreement. It's using the government to protect OUTSIDE parties by by crippling the business with additional expenses.
- wickawic 10y agoBut the children in the mines contractually agreed to their positions! Who is the government to interfere with this business partnership?
- biocomputation 10y agoCan't upvote you enough!
- brightball 10y agoAre the children adults legally able to enter a contract....?
- Spooky23 10y agoBefore the overreaching government stepped in and got in the way, parents had the freedom to get gainful employment for their idle children. Some parents even took it upon themselves to increase their productivity by having the kids do piecework at home. For example, 6 year olds were able to roll cigars at home.
- ZoF 10y agoWhat is the premise of your argument here? That bad things happened in the past so there's now no such thing as too much regulation? Because child labor existed we should now consider independent contractors employees...? Care to actually provide a somewhat coherent response instead of baselessly denigrating the parents ideology and implying it represents forced child labor. I find this kind of cheap, tangentially related strawman so intellectually lazy it's actually offensive.
- Spooky23 10y agoI guess you're easily offended. Society reached consensus a long time ago about what an employee is and isn't. Companies have been nipping at the edges of this for years to push more risks on "independent" contractors, which in reality means pushing business risk to society at large.
- RangerScience 10y ago...Which I think would be fine - employment liquidity seems good just like monetary liquidity - except that we do a shit job of providing benefits (like health insurance, and maternity/paternity leave) via the government. Making them employees of Uber isn't an answer. Making a Union isn't an answer (I don't think; again, too much overhead, and the point isn't negotiating power anyway). Government probably isn't an answer (regardless of "should", look at effeciveness). Maybe needs a rethink from first principles?
- Spivak 10y ago> employment liquidity seems good just like monetary liquidity Right, but such liquidity is formed either on the basis that individuals don't have to work to survive, or on the basis that employees are so scare and desirable that mobility becomes a non-issue. I don't disagree that we could address some of these problems by starting over from first principles, but that kind of change takes lifetimes to implement -- we still have to do something about the current people.
- thedufer 10y agoYour argument for why Uber's workers should be able to sign themselves up as independent contractors can be used to show that children should be able to work in mines, fast food workers should be able to work for minimum wage, and generally that employees should be able to sign off on giving up any and all employment rights. The point is that either you need a new argument, or you actually believe all of those things. Keep in mind that I have not actually taken sides on the issue at hand; I'm just claiming that your particular argument is a bit flawed.
- hinkley 10y agoThe thing about contract law is that a contract that requires one party to break the law isn't binding. If you build a business around invalid contracts that's on you or crappy legal advice. Not on the person who signed your predatory contract.
- brightball 10y agoAt what point does "I will perform this task for compensation in the amount of $X" become illegal?
- danharaj 10y agoWhen it's illegal. There's no underlying abstraction. The law is ad hoc.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIt has always been illegal if an employer tells you you're an independent contractor but without meeting the requirements of an independent contractor relationship. Last time someone ignored that, it cost them $240 million. I'm interested to see how much it costs Uber. http://www.reuters.com/article/us-fedex-settlement-idUSKCN0Z229Q http://www.reuters.com/article/us-fedex-settlement-idUSKCN0Z...
- brightball 10y agoSo what's the difference between that and using a personal LLC. It's legal nitpicking about a persons choice.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> It's legal nitpicking about a persons choice. That's actually what the law is: interpretation of statute, or what you call "nitpicking".
- brightball 10y ago