6 ms·
It's a book, a real book, quite long. It has a lot of topics on applied math. Some of its main topics are linear algebra, probability theory, and Markov proce
by graycat 10y ago
It's a book, a real book, quite long.
It has a lot of topics on applied math.
Some of its main topics are
linear algebra,
probability theory,
and Markov processes.
Really, the book just touches on
such topics. Usually in college
each of those topics is worth
a course of a semester or more.
So, what the book has on such
topics is much less than such
a course. E.g., for linear algebra,
the book gets quickly to the
singular value decomposition
but leaves its treatment of eigenvalues
for an appendix and otherwise leaves
out about 80% of a one semester
course on linear algebra.
Similarly for probability and
Markov processes.
Some of the topics the book
has or touches on
are unusual with, likely,
few other sources in book form.
E.g., early on the book has
Gaussian distributions on
finite dimensional vector
spaces where the dimension
is larger than is common.
So, for the topics rarely
covered in book form,
the book could be a good
reference.
For topics such as from linear
algebra, a reader might get
misled without an actual
course in linear algebra
from any of the long
popular
books, e.g., Halmos,
Strang, Hoffman and Kunze,
Nering or more advanced
books by Horn, Bellman, or
others.
Usually in universities,
probability and Markov processes
quickly get into graduate material
with a prerequisite in measure
theory and, hopefully, some on
functional analysis, e.g., to
discuss some important cases of
convergence.
So, the book seems to have
some good points and some
less good ones.
A good point is that the book
is a source of a start on
some topics rarely in book
form. A less good point is
that the book gives very
brief coverage of topics
otherwise usually covered
in full courses from
popular texts.
A student with a good math
background could use the
book as a reference and
maybe at times get some value
from the coverage of some of the
topics rarely covered elsewhere.
But I would suspect that
students without courses in
linear algebra, probability, etc.
would need more background
in math to find the book very
useful.
E.g., early in my career, I
jumped into various applied
math topics using very brief
treatments. Later when
I did careful study of good
texts with relatively full
coverage, I discovered that
the brief treatments had been
misleading. E.g., no one would
try to learn heart surgery in
a weekend and then try to
apply it to a real person.
Well, for applied math, maybe
learning singular value decomposition,
etc.
in a weekend might not be
enough to make a serious
application.
It is good to see a book on
applied math try to be a little
closer to real, recent
applications than
has been traditional
in applied math texts.
I'm not sure that the
being closer is crucial
or even very useful
for making real applications,
but maybe it will help.