5 ms·
For all the scientific writing I do (ie, 99% of my output that isn't blather on the internet), i use LaTeX or markdown. LaTeX primarily for peer-reviewed work,
by hprotagonist 10y ago
For all the scientific writing I do (ie, 99% of my output that isn't blather on the internet), i use LaTeX or markdown.
LaTeX primarily for peer-reviewed work, markdown for notes, informal documentation, and whitepapers. In both cases, i can use a powerful text editor (sublime or atom or emacs) with very rich and highly developed cross-platform support.
What are some compelling reasons to use this tool instead?
- capnrefsmmat 10y agoThe scientific publishing workflow is insane, and this tool seems like it could help. In the biomedical sciences (or any field that ends up on PubMed), articles have to be converted to JATS XML (http://jats.nlm.nih.gov/ http://jats.nlm.nih.gov/), a standard XML dialect for journal articles. It builds in citation metadata, cross-referencing, figure references, etc., and is supposed to be a stable archival format for long-term storage of articles. Individual publishers (PLOS, BMC, etc.) build their entire publication workflows around JATS, so articles can be typeset into PDF or rendered to HTML, or delivered to e-reader apps or whatever. Since it's semantic XML, you can do bibliography mining, automatic reference following, extraction of figures, or whatever you might want to make reading or text-mining easier. But articles are often written in Word, so there's a tremendous amount of work going into manually or semi-manually converting every manuscript to semantic XML from the Word soup it arrives as. Same goes for LaTeX: a few journals just publish LaTeXed PDFs directly, but big publishers like Elsevier and Springer have semi-automated processes for converting LaTeX to in-house formats so they can provide HTML versions of pages. So, short version: an editor supporting JATS XML can support all the features you need in a scientific document, and can dramatically simplify the publication workflow and hopefully save a bunch of money. And hopefully open-access journals pass that savings on to users. For users, it could mean better e-reading apps (so you don't have to zoom in on tiny fonts in a PDF on your iPad), better support for cross-referencing and figures than Word has, automated formatting (journals style the XML, so you don't have to do margin and layout crap), and a simpler submission process.
- hprotagonist 10y agoInteresting. This seems like a tool for journal staff and editors, then, rather than practicing scientists.
- dflock 10y agoIt's a tool for everyone in the writing-editing-publishing pipeline. They could all use the same tool, working on the same document & document format, throughout the process. This will remove a huge amount of reformatting/conversion work between steps in the pipeline.
- hprotagonist 10y agoThe rebuttal, guaranteed to come from anyone with tenure but also from distinctly untenured folks like myself is this: "I have all my manuscripts and biosketches and workflow in LaTex/Word. All my references are in mendeley/zotero/endnote/bibtex files i've hand-massaged. Until such time as my home journal requires me to use this format i've never heard about, and gives me the tools to convert everything I've built over the last 2-20 years, I am not interested in it unless you've got something more compelling than what you've shown me so far." getting traction is going to be _very hard_.
- dflock 10y agoOf course - that's the most obvious thing in the world. Getting traction against an entrenched workflow component - a people problem - is, almost universally, very very hard. The technical problem - writing your new tool - is trivial by comparison. But they do seem to be coming at this from the journal/pull end of the workflow, which is a very good place to start.
- jessriedel 10y agoThis is a very insightful comment.
- dmd 10y ago
- Someone 10y agoWhen I downloaded and unzipped this, I got a folder with what looked like a web site. I figured I would need to run it under a web server, but double-clicked the ‘index.html’ file anyways. That opened a simple page with 3 links to example files, and clicking either opened a working document editor, where ‘working’ seems to include the saving of changes (somewhere in browser history; edits survive closing the web page, but get lost on clearing history). (Tested on Safari, Chrome, and FireFox on Mac OS X Sierra) I guess that means this aims to be a powerful document editor with rich and highly developed cross-platform support. It’s not as flexible as LaTeX or markdown, but that is on purpose.
- hprotagonist 10y agoby rich and highly developed, i mean things like "having a package manager that hooks me into mendeley, zotero, and github, has an integrated linter, supports build and live-preview, and lets me run custom macros with whatever keybindings i prefer". "runs everywhere because it's in javascript" doesn't necessarily get me any of that-- the editing functionalities in this tool seem rudimentary so far.
- Someone 10y agoFor the hooks and key bindings: it is an alpha release of the initial version. Those things may come, and will come if it becomes successful and users want it. Certainly, it has to provide a way to really store documents. The cloud then is a natural choice for this kind of tool. Also, I think this doesn't need a linter, as the UI limits you to creating valid documents, and it has live preview because it is wysiwig (it isn't TeX and doesn't aim to be) I would guess (but it is not my project) macros are unlikely to come soon, if at all.
- duerrp 10y agoAs a side note, if you are already in emacs, you could write your articles in org-mode instead of LaTex. It's gotten to a point where I am starting to see Latex exclusively as a language to compile to, not something you want to write yourself. If you haven't used a well-configured org-mode, have a look at this demo for example https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2t925KRBbFc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2t925KRBbFc. There's nothing out there (open source or proprietary) that comes close for scientific work in my opinion.