5 ms·
Right. We shouldn't pretend that the US doesn't do this to other countries. What happened in the Ukraine, for example, almost certainly wasn't an organically
by empath75 10y ago
Right. We shouldn't pretend that the US doesn't do this to other countries. What happened in the Ukraine, for example, almost certainly wasn't an organically grown domestic insurrection. That was nurtured by NGOs and foreign intelligence agencies.
Nonetheless-- it's one thing when the superpowers do that to smaller countries, and another, far more dangerous thing when they start doing it to each other. We're in uncharted territory here. As you saw in the Ukraine (and Syria, and Egypt, and so on and so forth), when the political system fails, you have violence, and the US isn't going to stand by and watch Russia destroy the integrity of our elections. And our means for retaliating are untested, and the risk of escalation is pretty high.
- Mikeb85 10y ago> What happened in the Ukraine, for example, almost certainly wasn't an organically grown domestic insurrection. That was nurtured by NGOs and foreign intelligence agencies. And it happened twice I might add... > and the US isn't going to stand by and watch Russia destroy the integrity of our elections To be fair, exposing the corruption of one of the major parties isn't exactly going to 'destroy the integrity' of your political system. If anything he's doing you guys a favour. Also, the US has been trying to manipulate elections in Russia for years. It hasn't worked yet because all the opposition to Putin are a bunch of clowns, and because enough Russians still remember the 90's.
- empath75 10y agoThey're hacking into election systems as well, not just the DNC: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/fbi-is-investigating-foreign-hacks-of-state-election-systems/2016/08/29/6e758ff4-6e00-11e6-8365-b19e428a975e_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/fbi-i...
- Mikeb85 10y ago"Russians". They could just as easily be hackers looking to sell to the highest bidders, criminals, etc... The fact the US even allows electronic voting machines is beyond absurd. Honestly, living outside the US, your whole election system looks like a joke.
- dogma1138 10y agoHackers don't tend to target states these days unless they have a state to hide behind, hence being state sponsored. If you are a bored teenager in Poland you'll get to to join the mile high club on one of the fine aircraft of Premier Executive Transport Services or whichever front the CIA uses these days. If you are a bored teenager in the horn of africa you are likely to be placed at the wrong end of the sensor to shooter loop of a UAV. Governments are very good at tracking down intrusions these days, and there is nearly no way of selling this information without being caught, intelligence agencies monitor all the channels, markets, and they operate both undercover agents and informants within virtually any social ring that hackers hang out in. Cyber Crime pays when the risk is considerably smaller than the reward, just like any other type of crime, steal money from a bank and while you'll be hunted down by law enforcement you won't be hunted down by spies and the military, and since the money is insured no one really cares enough to invest too much effort into tracking you down in the first place.
- xixi77 10y agoIt was absolutely domestically grown -- had the foreign intelligence and NGO's been as strong as you suggest, things would have never gotten to that point, as the money and effort spent on influence by Russia absolutely dwarfed everything else: Ukraine has never been high on anyone else's radar. The reason Russians have not been particularly successful is mostly due to certain widespread delusions in Russian society, that result in people at all ranks seeing the entire Russia/Ukraine split as unnatural. What I mean is, when you are coming from a prior that there were no underlying differences in 1991, and Ukraine before then was simply a province of a Russian state operating under a different name, of course any disagreement could only be seen as a result of external meddling since that time. Of course, when this view conflicts with reality, the failures are attributed to foreign meddling being stronger than unticipated...
- dogma1138 10y agoYou would be surprised https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Endowment_for_Democracy#Ukraine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Endowment_for_Democra... And this is just one NGO. The "West" forced Ukraine to choose between it and Russia, including the looming free trade deal with the EU being contingent on that. There is/was also a plan to bypass the Russian controlled oil and more importantly natural gas pipelines that are keeping the lights in Europe both the conflict in the Ukraine and the previous one in Georgia are directly connected to the proposed caspian pipelines. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Caspian_Gas_Pipeline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Caspian_Gas_Pipeline While you can make Russia look antagonistic it is just as easy to make the west look that and even worse, the west effectively violated the non-formal agreement that maintained peace after the fall of the soviet union and that is that the former states would effectively be a buffer zone. The EU and NATO have (and it is very important to note that Russia does not distinguish between the two, and effectively nor should they) been expanding into these buffer states and worse they are expanding into the caspian region and beyond leaving Russia effectively surrounded. Russia is a landlocked country, it always was, it always was missing a single important thing and that is a warm water port in an open sea, this is why Russia invaded Manchuria/Korea multiple times since the 19th century and this is why Russia would not tolerate any loss of it's ports in the black sea or syria. The black sea is enclosed by the bosphorus which controlled by NATO, Kaliningrad is a tiny enclave surrounded by NATO and any ship sailing out of it would have to go through the fjords and the northern sea another NATO controlled territory, on the other side of the globe Vladivostok is not a warm water port (although global warming might help Russia with that problem soon enough), effectively Russia has to rely on the "kindness" of NATO to allow it's ships to get out into the ocean, this puts them at a huge disadvantage. Another key aspect of Russian geopolitics is their "monopoly" on gas pipelines into Europe both from their own reserves and those coming from the caspian region and beyond, this is what keeps Russia relevant and what gives them some power over what is going on around them. With NATO effectively being able to shut down all Russian sea travel and make Russia's only "diplomatic tool" other than it's strategic nuclear arsenal irrelevant we are not heading into a pleasant direction.