3 ms·
That's awesome! Thanks for the link as it fills the big picture in nicely for me. Should be the original article given level of detail. Trips me out that NT was
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
That's awesome! Thanks for the link as it fills the big picture in nicely for me. Should be the original article given level of detail. Trips me out that NT was developed on OS/2 with mail servers running Xenix. Combined with other articles, I actually see Microsoft playing it smarter than I thought drawing from all the best tech families:
1. Create a better UNIX than UNIX. UNIX microcomputer market forms as a side-effect due to marketing.
2. Move UNIX features into CP/M in MS-DOS.
3. Clone OpenVMS architecture with enhancements and emulators for older OS's.
4. Develop on OS/2 for better reliability, pace, and inspiration. I'm sure OS/2 stuff ended up in NT past the emulator. I'd be interested in a link that went into that in detail.
5. Run mail and gateways on Xenix as UNIX was great at that sort of thing.
6. Run whole business on a single AS/400 that just gets shit done mainframe-style.
7. Replace all of the above with one product that has key attributes of all of them in usable package on cheaper hardware.
They don't look as dumb now as I thought when I was younger comparing MS-DOS to BSD's or Linux. ;)
re Linux
The author asserts multiple times that Linux comes from Xenix somehow but didn't seem to prove it. Says the architecture, standard, and microcomputer UNIX was first done by Xenix. Then Linux did one. Past that, nothing. Is there some resource with specific evidence that Linus got Linux design aspects from Xenix as opposed to another UNIX? And my original sources said he started with Minix changing stuff in his design that didn't suit his hardware or needs. So that needs to be factored in.
- xenadu02 10y agoOS/2 and NT were the same codebase at one time. It was a joint IBM/Microsoft project. Windows 3.x was way more successful than Microsoft anticipated. They wanted to pivot the Win32 layer in NT to be the primary API and make the user interface more Windows-like. IBM didn't want that so they parted ways. David Cutler (designer of VMS) was the architect for NT. Many people don't know it has a single root filesystem that takes the unix philosophy even further... objects like mutexes exist in the root, not just files. Everything has full ACL support. The IO completion ports and async support were way ahead of their time. It originally even ran things like the video driver in user space. Windows 3.x being so successful almost killed everything that was great about NT. It also caused Microsoft to completely miss the mobile revolution. Success hides problems indeed.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoAppreciate the tips. In case you don't have it, here's the reference showing all the VMS stuff in NT: http://windowsitpro.com/windows-client/windows-nt-and-vms-rest-story http://windowsitpro.com/windows-client/windows-nt-and-vms-re... Be interesting at some point to collect all the attributes of NT to see what came from VMS, OS/2, UNIX, DOS, Win 3.x, etc. Then one might also see how it could be done even better esp without baggage. :)
- pjmlp 10y agoAttending a session about the Windows internals at Microsoft was an eye opener for me, back when Windows 2000 was the latest version. For those of us that enjoy delving into OS details, Windows is full of interesting goodies. Even the way .NET is integrated with the OS, is somehow similar to how bytecode and JITs used to work in mainframes.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI always liked the architecture but just hated implementation and holdovers from prior business. Another goodie was how the DOS, etc subsystems are similar to the current container craze. I just wish BeOS advantages got merged in there early on. They buy them or something.
- m_mueller 10y ago... and when they finally noticed their problem in mobile, it seems like all the good stuff was thrown out (e.g. .Net) in order to chase that tail. Seems they're finally coming around now with the windows store being opened for all windows apps (wow... duh?), but at the same time smartphones seem abandoned and tablets are IMO still clunky compared to iPads. Was Gates the genius behind dominating PC? Was his absence during the mobile revolution the reason for MS's relative stagnation (when compared to Apple's and Google's growth)?
- pjmlp 10y agoAt least looking at the stores, they seem to be making a come back at least in what concerns tablets/hybrid laptops. Hybrid tablets have killed the netbooks and the majority of people are going for 2GB/4GB + 32/64 eMMC hybrids with Windows 10, and not to those Android ones that kind of look like a desktop. For most pockets across the world, an iPad Pro isn't an option. The whole thing with .NET, Longhorn, Windows 7 and 10, was also a causality of the typical Windows Dev vs DevTools "wars" and most of us that follow MSFT blogs and news, know to which side Sinofsky was sponsoring. Somehow UWP seems to be what .NET and eventually Longhorn should have been all along, lets see how it goes.