3 ms·
This whole thread is deeply disturbing. The bald statement in the headline is deeply disturbing. The fundamental assumption that women can't possibly be deserv
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
This whole thread is deeply disturbing. The bald statement in the headline is deeply disturbing. The fundamental assumption that women can't possibly be deserving of management positions. That any objective measure of performance would certainly favor men. That any man that loses his job to a woman has been treated unfairly.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoIt's not just any man...it was a lot of men. This kind of discrimination could be excused if it brought a tangible value to the company, but this reshuffling did nothing to help this ailing company. Meyer's actions were discriminatory at worst; at best, it was merely gross incompetence.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoLots of companies fail to survive Silicon Valley forever. Yahoo!'s future aside, the conversation was about promotion, not ailing companies. A lot of women are routinely overlooked in management promotions. Since its 80% (or usually much more) men in every other company in Silicon Valley, we'll have to call discrimination and incompetence at all of them? The assumption that women can't possibly belong in management is galling. No mystery why Silicon Valley has the reputation it does.
- wfo 10y agoYes -- because people go to tech websites and spam entire comment sections with hundreds of comments saying exactly the same thing and telling everyone that they are sexist while intentionally missing the point.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y ago>The assumption that women can't possibly belong in management is galling. No mystery why Silicon Valley has the reputation it does. You're putting a lot of words in other people's mouths in this thread, and I believe you are equating skepticism and discomfort from the lawsuit's allegations with willful ignorance or even sincere sexism. If a CEO wishes to fire half the company and hire new people, sure. If the CEO wants to fire half the company (who happen to be men) and replace them with new people (who happen to be women), again, sure. If a CEO implements a review system designed to illegitimize honest work by a cohort of people and have them demoted and/or fired to minimize severance costs while bringing on or promoting people of a different cohort, then we have a discrimination problem. Honestly I am a little surprised at the accusations of sexism towards people that are expressing discomfort with what appears to be a primarily sexist act.
- shagie 10y agoOne of the things that has been only lightly touched upon: > ... and have them demoted and/or fired to minimize severance costs ... Tangential to this was the violation of the California and federal WARN act. Yahoo reduced the workforce by 600 employees without declaring the corresponding reduction in force under WARN acts. If a company has 100 (federal) or 75 (California) or more full time employees that have been employed for 6 of the past 12 months and lays off 50 or more employees during a 30 day period, the employer falls into the WARN act. This also isn't something that's new at all - its been brewing for months. http://www.californialaborandemploymentlaw.net/2016/yahoo-accused-warn-act-violations/ http://www.californialaborandemploymentlaw.net/2016/yahoo-ac... is from March 6th.
- terrywilcox 10y agoIf these men were good at the managerial jobs, why was the company ailing in the first place? Maybe firing them all was the right move, but it was too late to repair the damage.
- sp332 10y agoExactly! The previous CEO picked 80% of senior management of the same gender and that's fine, but Meyer does the exact same and suddenly it's sexist?
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoAgain, perhaps not the 'exact same'. How do we know this time it wasn't done fairly?
- sp332 10y agoIs picking senior management about fairness?
- JoeAltmaier 10y ago"Fair" in the sense of "gender-blind"
- zallen 10y agoI keep reading this positive stereotype about women needing to be twice as good to make it half as far, and yet this outcome would be a the natural consequence of that if assessment was to suddenly become fair. People need to better choose their 'ladies in the workplace' stereotypes methinks. Unless it's true, in which case... Let's see, 20% Women in STEM x 2 x 2 (twice as good; and, multiply by two to make up for half as far) = ... 80% Q.E.D.
- kelukelugames 10y agoJoe, no need to feel disturbed. HNers are good people. I used to think otherwise, but dang corrected me. The percent of misogynists or racists is far less than 100%. I would say at least 80% of the comments in this thread are not sexist in anyway. Which to be honest is pretty good.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoI'd be more comforted if even the not-overtly-sexist comments didn't have an assumption of the truth of the title: its a problem when significant numbers of women are promoted into management.
- int_19h 10y agoMost comments do not imply that. What they imply is that the magnitude and the speed of the change is suspicious (not necessarily a problem, but likely to be indicative of one). It would be just as suspicious if they went 80% to 20% in the other direction at the same rate.