10 ms·
Taiwan is not the counterexample to this article to prove that China needs the sweatshops and they are excusable because the ends justify the means. First you
by krschultz 17y ago
Taiwan is not the counterexample to this article to prove that China needs the sweatshops and they are excusable because the ends justify the means.
First you overestimating the extent to which the sweatshops in Taiwan are the cause of its progress and ignoring what other factors were involved. There are plenty of countries in the world teaming with sweatshops, few are growing into Taiwan 2.0
What are those other factors?
1) It is a smaller country.
2) Taiwan's opposition to China was/is very valuable to and respected by western nations. Is it a coincidence that the country that most antagonizes China is supported by the US and gets a lot of business/help from the US? I know companies that refuse to outsource to China but will to Taiwan in a heartbeat.
3) etc
Second, it doesn't _have to be this way_. There are manufacturers in China in less competitive industries that follow more western practices. The really competitive industries have these sorts of problems (and yes, slave wages and total control of a workers life are problems even if they aren't living in a toxic waste dump). The only way to solve that problem is systematic change because fixing any single factory just puts it out of business. Since systematic change from within China the way it happened in Western countries is not happening due to the lack of free speech and political forces, activists put pressure on western companies to stop outsourcing to these places.
And where would they go instead? Probably Taiwan.
- eru 17y ago> 1) It is a smaller country. So if you carved up China into smaller countries, that might help?
- aswanson 17y agoIt probably would, decentralizing control and allowing competitive economic regimes to emerge, rather than the counterproductive nepotism rampant there now.
- eru 17y agoThat might be true. As long as they can preserve a free trade area / customs union, pushing authority down to the lowest level possible is probably a good idea.