3 ms·
It is disingenuous to pretend DRM is about funding content creators, it's really about corporate revenue, which is not at all the same thing. Content creators
by ska 10y ago
It is disingenuous to pretend DRM is about funding content creators, it's really about corporate revenue, which is not at all the same thing. Content creators are and will continue to be treated as a cost to be minimized by these distributors.
It is also disingenuous to suggest that DRM is equivalent to paying for content. They are related, but separate issues.
- 794CD01 10y agoThey are not separate in any meaningful way. From the perspective of content owners, they want DRM because they want to ensure people who consume their content have paid for it. From the perspective of consumers, those who want to circumvent DRM in order to avoid paying for content overwhelmingly outnumber those who oppose DRM on principle to the point that the voices, and more importantly, the money, of the latter are completely drowned out.
- ska 10y agoThey absolutely are completely separable. DRM is one technological approach to enforcing a model on payment for content. There are other models, and other mechanisms to encourage payment or reduce non-payment. To pretend that DRM is unique, or in some way the natural approach is folly.
- 794CD01 10y agoDRM is not the implementation or the technology, necessarily. Those who own copyright want to deny the ability to copy to others, because they fear it devalues what they have. That doesn't make it right, or natural, as if any of that even matters. It just means that a group of people exist who want to be able to enforce copyright. And the opposition to that is, by definition, those who want to be able to make copies of things without the blessing of copyright owners. If DRM were perfect, there wouldn't even be a technology- or freedom- based argument against it.
- Noos 10y agoYou fund creators from corporate revenue, though. They aren't going to make any money if there is no DRM either. There also have been plenty of independent publishers and small studios that have been hurt by piracy and the lack of DRM, too.
- ska 10y agoSort of, as there are other models. What I'm objecting to is the claim that a) DRM is just necessary and b) we are talking about it as a mechanism to fund content creators. a) is simply not true b) is mostly not true - DRM is used to prop up a desired business model for many layers between consumers and content creators - the content creators incidentally get a small part of the revenue, but that isn't really what the conversation is about So if we are talking about these things, we should at least be honest about what we are talking about funding, and how.