5 ms·

Exactly that. I have issues watching copy protected dvds on my playstation where if I pause the film for a short while the copy protection kicks in and I can't

Exactly that. I have issues watching copy protected dvds on my playstation where if I pause the film for a short while the copy protection kicks in and I can't watch the film, instead have to restart and fast forward to when I'd paused. That's content protection preventing me - a purchaser - using it properly.

kiallmacinnes 10y ago
So, I have to ask! What makes you sure this is copy protection? It sounds more like a bug or fault rather than DRM.
- themihai 10y ago
  Even if it's not the DRM fault here there are plenty of other examples. E.g. You can't copy/backup a DVD on your computer/stick/cloud so once the DVD format is deprecated(i.e. Macs no longer have a DVD-drive) or the DVD is lost you can't play it anymore. Not to mention the convenience. The latest wonder from the DRM promoters is the HDCP: People with 4K TVs can't play 4K TV content anymore because of this new "feature"[0]. Apparently the only sane solution is to hack the HDMI cable. [0] http://www.howtogeek.com/208917/htg-explains-how-hdcp-breaks-your-hdtv-and-how-to-fix-it/ http://www.howtogeek.com/208917/htg-explains-how-hdcp-breaks...
- grahamel 10y ago
  True, it's likely a bug from either the disc or the player but if they weren't attempting DRM I wouldn't have the issue. Inconveniencing legitimate users because you can't implement the protections without it breaking isn't the way to go. I know I can download a copy of a film, push play/pause and it will just work. I know if I buy a dvd I'll have to sit through unskippable piracy messages and ads and not be sure the film will play after pausing.
  - plttn 10y ago
    How do you know that without a doubt it isn't just a bug in the software unrelated to whether or not DRM was implemented?
    - grahamel 10y ago
      because when I do the same on a non DRM disc it doesn't happen
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago
  > It sounds more like a bug or fault rather than DRM. Even if it isn't the DRM, it still is. Because the player could be open and someone could fix the bug if it weren't for the DRM.

kiallmacinnes 10y ago

So, I have to ask! What makes you sure this is copy protection? It sounds more like a bug or fault rather than DRM.

themihai 10y ago
Even if it's not the DRM fault here there are plenty of other examples. E.g. You can't copy/backup a DVD on your computer/stick/cloud so once the DVD format is deprecated(i.e. Macs no longer have a DVD-drive) or the DVD is lost you can't play it anymore. Not to mention the convenience. The latest wonder from the DRM promoters is the HDCP: People with 4K TVs can't play 4K TV content anymore because of this new "feature"[0]. Apparently the only sane solution is to hack the HDMI cable. [0] http://www.howtogeek.com/208917/htg-explains-how-hdcp-breaks-your-hdtv-and-how-to-fix-it/ http://www.howtogeek.com/208917/htg-explains-how-hdcp-breaks...
grahamel 10y ago
True, it's likely a bug from either the disc or the player but if they weren't attempting DRM I wouldn't have the issue. Inconveniencing legitimate users because you can't implement the protections without it breaking isn't the way to go. I know I can download a copy of a film, push play/pause and it will just work. I know if I buy a dvd I'll have to sit through unskippable piracy messages and ads and not be sure the film will play after pausing.
- plttn 10y ago
  How do you know that without a doubt it isn't just a bug in the software unrelated to whether or not DRM was implemented?
  - grahamel 10y ago
    because when I do the same on a non DRM disc it doesn't happen
AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> It sounds more like a bug or fault rather than DRM. Even if it isn't the DRM, it still is. Because the player could be open and someone could fix the bug if it weren't for the DRM.