12 ms·
The Nobel Peace Prize 2016: Juan Manuel Santos
- jjfigueredou 10y agoI am Colombian. This is a really difficult situation, and this Nobel prize was really unexpected. When the plebiscite results where announced last Sunday, the whole country was astonished, even those who where for the No vote, as polls predicted and overwhelming support for Sí. I was very dissapointed with the result, even ashamed, as it was barely a win for No, but shown mostly an abstention level not seen in two decades. I cannot understand that a majority of Colombians didn't want to take part in one of them is important decisions in a century. Unbelievable. Regarding the No: I can understand that people feels this peace deal brings impunity to the victims, that will be difficult to support financially, and puts a handful of insurgents directly on the congress. It does, and I believe basically no one is happy with that. But we are negotiating with a 50-year old billionaire militar criminal enterprise with strong Marxist roots and an original mission to take the power by force. And maybe it's own existence is due to the government actions in what was called Operation Marquetalia, which doesn't help with trust. It is worth remembering that Colombia is one of the most unequal countries in the world, with a top ten Gini coefficient. Regarding Alvaro Uribe: even if successful in weakening the guerrillas, has a complicated history with the paramilitary, which have been at least as vicious as the guerrillas itself. His brother has been convicted due to ties with this groups, and his government and way of thought is from the hard right, and his way of talk is based on populism and loaded language. He is the major proponent of the No, and as a I see it, only to get his name on the deal, and even more, to push for a constitutional reform so that he is able to become president, for a third time. I feel that's sabotage. Regarding Juan Manuel Santos: I did not vote for Santos in 2010, but for Mockus. He is not without scandals, mainly due to his actions under Uribe, who is know his strongest opposition. But I did vote for him in 2014, because he is a outstanding negotiator: and I was right, he got the peace deal signed, which no one was ever able to do before. Sadly he is a very bad political leader for the people, lacking good rhetoric and sympathy, and was not ably to rally the masses for the Sí. I'm simply unable to judge at this point if this Nobel prize should have been given to him. Regarding the Sí: This is not the best deal we could have dreamed, maybe not even the best we expected, but was what could be achieved at that table at that time. I don't think we can get a peace deal without high sacrifice, and coming out smiling from the negotiation. This is a matter of opportunity cost: what reality did you prefer, the one where we painfully finish this conflict throughout the next decade, or the one where we perpetuate the longest lasting conflict in the Americas. Those most affected by it chose the Sí. I did too. I just hope that we find a way out of this, with peace as a final outcome.
- cowsandmilk 10y ago> I cannot understand that a majority of Colombians didn't want to take part in one of them is important decisions in a century. Many people are willing to stand on the sidelines rather than take action when there don't seem to be any good solutions. This is partly why the work Santos is doing is important. There are no solutions that would make everyone happy, but passively doing nothing is not a good option, only the easy option. Santos has had the courage to put forward a path to peace, even if it is not popular.
- jpkeisala 10y agoIf Colombia some day get peace deal with FARC, isn't there other paramilitary groups still active? Do they have significant presence? Also, another thing I wonder as European looking Colombia from the distance is that is FARC that organized and controlled that they are able to tell their soldiers put weapons down? I always thought that those kidnappers are simply crooks making money through extrusion not really Marxist idealists?
- forinti 10y agoI was in Colombia in 2010 (what a beatiful country and people - I loved it). There were elections and I saw "De la U" posters all over. So I asked a few people what the U stood for. Nobody seemed to know. This is the party that won the presidency. Did I just happen to ask the wrong people or is political awareness that low in Colombia?
- javpaw 10y agoThis was one of the parties that supported former president Uribe back then, so many people think that the "U" is for him. But in fact "De la U" is for "De la Unidad Nacional" (National Unity). And yes, political awareness in Colombia is low. The abstention for this plebiscite was greater than 60%.
- forinti 10y ago> The abstention for this plebiscite was greater than 60%. That surprises me as people weren't at all shy about how much they disliked the FARC.
- okket 10y agoThe Norwegian Nobel Committee has decided to award the Nobel Peace Prize for 2016 to Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos for his resolute efforts to bring the country's more than 50-year-long civil war to an end, a war that has cost the lives of at least 220 000 Colombians and displaced close to six million people. The award should also be seen as a tribute to the Colombian people who, despite great hardships and abuses, have not given up hope of a just peace, and to all the parties who have contributed to the peace process. This tribute is paid, not least, to the representatives of the countless victims of the civil war. See also the answer to the question: "Does this year's prize encourage a process more than a result, since a slim majority of Colombians voted no?" https://twitter.com/NobelPrize/status/784323887374831617 https://twitter.com/NobelPrize/status/784323887374831617
- gman83 10y agoI thought the White Helmets would win.
- seesomesense 10y ago"During his time as Defence Minister, notable controversial events included a military raid inside Ecuador's territory that killed FARC leader Raúl Reyes on 1 March 2008. In 2008 the 'false positives' scandal was uncovered,referring to revelations concerning extrajudicial executions carried out by members of the military in order to artificially increase the number of guerrillas killed by the Army and claim rewards from the government. On 4 November 2008, Santos admitted that the military had carried out extrajudicial executions There was a misuse of an International Committee of the Red Cross symbol during Operation Jaque used to safely rescue hostages from FARC." Now extra-judicial killings are no bar to being given the Nobel "Peace" Prize. The least credible of the Nobel Prizes continues to deliver....
- tsaprailis 10y agoThis is a very complicated issue. There have been many crimes committed by both sides. The FARC themselves came out with an apology on all the victims they have kidnapped over the years. I think the point of the prize is not to delete his older actions but rather to congratulate him for his attempts to finally bring an end to a civil war that has costed hundreds of thousands of lives over the years. Just like the rest of the prizes are given for specific discoveries by scientists, and not for their every discovery during their life's work, similarly his action on trying to end the civil war was deemed worthy. Additionally actions are judged relative to one another and 2016 has not a good year for peace actions.
- chkuendig 10y agoRelated: http://edition.cnn.com/2016/10/05/americas/colombia-ceasefire-farc/ http://edition.cnn.com/2016/10/05/americas/colombia-ceasefir... This is quite unfortunate timing. But I guess they couldn't find somebody else on short notice after the referendum on the peace deal failed. (also, it's not the first time this prize has been awarded for intentions instead of results)
- gotofritz 10y agoWell, what did you expect from the people who have given a prize to Kissinger, Arafat, Obama?
- rurban 10y agoWell, they had to avoid Snowden at all costs.
- gotofritz 10y agoWhatever you think of Snowden, you can hardly claim that what he's done has directly affected any conflicts for the better
- techdragon 10y agoPeace is about far more than conflict. To suggest otherwise is in my opinion, utterly naive, but in the very least shortsighted.
- newjersey 10y agoYup. The sun engulfing the earth instantly today ending life would end all conflicts in one sweep. Conflicts aren't always bad. We just need conflict resolution.
- lake99 10y agoBut why is that relevant? Malala worked on education in war-torn areas. Plenty of laureates worked on alleviating poverty, Red Cross (and associated people) got the prize for health, as did Albert Schweitzer. Snowden blew the lid off US governmental surveillance. I don't care about the Nobel Peace Prize one jot, but if I did, I'd definitely want a prize for Assange, though he is a very controversial figure.
- wallace_f 10y agoYou're right. Conflicts involving equality and human rights between peoples and their governments has only happened in the past, and the USA is currently immune from such conflict, so we can hardly define it as such. I don't regret the sarcasm: your presumption that defining what can be classified as a veritable struggle for human welfare can, in turn, be used as an argument for which struggles are most deserving of praise is what is called a straw man argument, perhaps the most annoying fallacy to refute before an audience of undecided thinkers as it is effective despite being logically inconsistent.
- jagermo 10y agoInteresting choice, especially since the referendum itself fell through. But it is a strong signal for Santos and the FARC to work out a new deal. Ending a 50 year civil war would be amazing for Colombia. Kudos to the comittee for taking such an "old" conflict and not picking up a (for lack of a better word) "hip" topic. I do not mean that the White Helmets or every other Organisation on the short list would not have earned the price, however I think it is a good thing that they try to strengthen a peace process that would put an end to such a long-lasting conflict.
- antocv 10y agoArent White Helmets a subversive CIA group? There has been pictures of "rebels" with guns for a day, then a White Helmet the next day switching back and forth.
- tobltobs 10y agoDigging out the wounded and dying is a subversive act?
- berntb 10y agoIt probably is -- from the viewpoint of those that bombs civilians with barrel bombs. (That said, for all I know the white helmets is a front for ISIS. But either way, the Assad junta and the Russians have an obvious interest in tarring them black.)
- antocv 10y ago> of those that bombs civilians with barrel bombs. Of course, who wouldnt choose to be melted to pieces by an expensive explosive device with advanced guidance and autonomous systems rather than a cheap ones?
- berntb 10y agoYou are knowingly dishonest by ignoring the word "civilian". Here you have my standard reference, quite critical of the US, regarding the laws of war. Please compare the US behavior with the Syrian/Russian Rules Of Engagement. http://www.lrb.co.uk/v25/n04/michael-byers/the-laws-of-war-us-style http://www.lrb.co.uk/v25/n04/michael-byers/the-laws-of-war-u...
- whyagaindavid 10y agoKudos
- pipio21 10y agoI was in Colombia two weeks ago. I am Spanish so I could talk with the people. Not everybody supports the "peace process" like any Western media displays. In Colombia lots of terrible things have happened. There is people that had made a fortune simply murdering and stealing entire families, and of course drugs. Peace process means legalization of all this crimes, and laundering all the money and power gotten mainly by extortion. There are thousands of victim's families that are angry because it means no justice for them, the people that killed their family members will not go to jail and the properties that were stolen will not go back to the families. Uribe put the guerrilla on his knees by force, making it to want to make a deal in the same way the Germans or Japanese wanted a honorable peace deal when everything was lost. Now Santos gets all the Glory basically capitulating against the Guerrilla. The deal is a very bad deal, for example it makes Guerrilla a "democratic" party, but if the people do not vote them, it does not matter because representation is warranted by law, basically giving them the territories that they already controlled by force.
- notgood 10y agoI live in Colombia. No, they weren't in "his knees", that's a lie perpetuated by Uribe himself. Being elected doesn't give them any power over any territories, they will be just part of the Congress, so they will have power to vote there, but not over "specific" territories. By the way today an scandal is up in Colombia where one of Uribes friends declared all the tactics to emotionally manipulate the people to vote against the treaty with lies and overly exaggerated claims (https://www.google.com.co/amp/amp.noticias.caracoltv.com/acuerdo-final/hubo-tergiversaciones-en-campana-del-no-juan-carlos-velez-desata-escandalo?client=ms-android-motorola https://www.google.com.co/amp/amp.noticias.caracoltv.com/acu...)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- davidpelaez 10y agoThank your for a reasonable comment! There is indeed a lot of ignorance from the outside. There's a logic to many points and theories but definitely people should be more informed even here in HN.
- Dowwie 10y agoThe nobel peace prize award decision making process continues to boggle the mind.
- quickly 10y agoIsn't the Nobel Peace Prize widely considered a joke to begin with?
- magico 10y agoNo
- MrFeynmannsJoke 10y agoAt least since 2009 when Obama Receiver it.
- ghostDancer 10y agoKissinger was before that and much worse than Obama.
- runholm 10y agoWhat was the problem with awarding it to Kissinger? Generally curious? I don't recall the details, but as far as I understood he pretty much laid down the foundation to end the Vietnam war.
- tomhoward 10y agoHere's one take on it: https://theintercept.com/2016/02/12/henry-kissingers-war-crimes-are-central-to-the-divide-between-hillary-clinton-and-bernie-sanders/ https://theintercept.com/2016/02/12/henry-kissingers-war-cri...
- ceejayoz 10y agoCarpet bombings of Laos, helping Nixon interfere with negotiations in Paris to end the war, looking the other way while Pakistan massacred people in Bangladesh, supporting Pinochet, etc.
- ptaipale 10y ago
- xyzzy4 10y agoThe Nobel Peace Prize lost all credibility when it was given to Obama in 2009.
- hgdtcdt 10y agoThey've since changed the way it is decided and fired the person in charge. Norwegians were embarrassed about the way prizes used to be decided.
- runholm 10y agoHe was awarded the price for his use of diplomacy instead of provoking more new wars. There was a lot of controversy regarding the decision, but to say that it lost all credibility is simply not true.
- wbl 10y agoHe had had zero time to do any of that, being elected just a year before.
- jbuzbee 10y agoCough. According to Wikipedia[1] - "Nominations for the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize closed just 11 days after Obama took office." That must have been a busy 11 days doing diplomacy... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_Nobel_Peace_Prize https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_Nobel_Peace_Prize
- mavdi 10y agoI think he deserves it. It took years to set up the peace process. Had it not been down to the fact that democracy is the tyranny of the stupid, Colombia would finally see peace. I hope this helps restart the process, and change public opinion.
- qj4714 10y agoI am far from an expert on Colombia but there are many reasons to be skeptical of this peace deal, and the failure of the yes vote is a sign that many people did not support it for reasons related to immunity deals for guerrillas and political representation as well. The peace deal is full of unfunded promises that the GOC lacks the capacity to fulfill. For example, my understanding is that the GOC has agreed to add police forces to the 40 percent of the land that they do not control, but they lack trained officers and funds to pay them. Land reform has been at a standstill, this is a very significant issue that has not been resolved. Lastly, coca production is at an all time high in Colombia. This is after years of reductions under Plan Colombia. Coca fuels the FARC and corruption in Colombia. The perception is that the GOC was going to target development aid under the peace agreement towards areas of high coca development, they cut off aerial spraying and the result is massive increases in coca. I don't see any way you can have peace in Colombia without addressing the coca issue.
- mxuribe 10y ago<conspiracy-theory> What if...the idea for the award of this nobel prize was purposefully implemented by the world's secret/shady powers-that-be...in an effort to generate more social/political pressure to all but ensure that some resolution (perhaps ANY resolution, good or bad) gets completed before Santos' time as president finishes...? </conspiracy-theory> I don't mean to make light of this...I (like many others) just question the timing of this awarding of the prize. While I'm extremely happy that the world has taken notice of this very important challenge that Colombia has been facing, I would have expected the committee would have waited until a plan is actually implemented, etc. Nevertheless, the very fact of this award is a clear, positive signal of the collective world's desire for peace for Colombians. Disclaimer: I'm born, raised in the U.S. with Colombian parents (themselves naturalized U.S. citizens from years ago).
- davidpelaez 10y agoAs they claim in the Q&A posted on Twitter, this encourages the process and celebrates the effort of president Santos to reach this far. If we do not reach an agreement to end this war it's a problem of other forces in the country and the ignorance of our people but for sure not by Santos failure. If we don't solve this for good, his brutal shift of the conflict from war to negotiation is already a great result.
- simonmd 10y agoThis is just another version of the white savior complex. Developed countries support 'peace' processes that make them feel good about themselves, with little regard for the root causes of the conflict to begin with. Apparently they think us colombians are too backwards to deserve first-world justice, so they applaud compromises that they would NEVER accept themselves.
- cloverich 10y agoCan you contrast this with ceronman's comment below (or maybe above) that the areas most likely to vote for the compromise were the people most affected by the guerilla violence?
- simonmd 10y agoGladly. That is one of the favorite simplistic spins of the supporters of the FARC-Santos deal, when in reality it has little to do with the victims and a lot to do with internal colombian political structures. Most maps you will see supporting this idea mix together 'victims of conflict' without separating them between paramilitary/FARC or drug trafficking victims, so it would be inaccurate to conclude that the most areas affected by FARC violence were in favor of the deal. Add to that the states where Santos mobilized his political machinery to buy votes, which coincides more precisely with the states supporting the deal (http://www.elpais.com.co/elpais/colombia/proceso-paz/noticias/molestas-verdades-dejo-mapa-plebiscito http://www.elpais.com.co/elpais/colombia/proceso-paz/noticia...). For example, the state with most victims (Antioquia) voted overwhelmingly against (62.00%). To say that Antioquia, Santander, Norte de Santander, Risaralda, Caldas, Quindío, Tolima, Cundinamarca, Huila, Caquetá, Meta, Casanare and Arauca states saw little violence is just a lie and affront to their victims.
- davidpelaez 10y agoExcept they had. First world countries had the worst war on history and they rebuilt their societies making big concessions. Europe and Japan know a lot about accepting had agreements exactly as our peace process suggests. This is a great way of supporting the work a great president truly committed to changing our country because he was born rich and it's extremely obvious that the peace agreement with FARC and possibly ELN it his way to transcend. I applaud this price and the support of developed countries to the process.
- forgotpwtomain 10y agoAfter Obama got a peace prize, it's really hard to take any of this seriously.
- davidpelaez 10y agoI agree that Obama's was pretty shitty, but from my internal view as a Colombian I would really suggest that you find out about his work for peace. He's still a politician and hardly everyone's cup of tea, but he has really make a huge effort against many walls to find peace in Colombia. He has gone from defense minister all the way to finding an agreement we can implement. The patience to go between those such opposite positions is admirable.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- olau 10y agoOkay, this whole theme is getting a bit annoying: Only if you expect the peace prize to be awarded in the same way as physics prize. The people awarding the physics prize seem to be waiting until they are absolutely certain the discoveries are important. So correct me if I'm wrong, but it's mostly given to old men for things they've done decades ago, not for outstanding accomplishments in the past year. Unlike the peace prize works. Which is by the way awarded by politicians. Regarding Obama's prize, Wikipedia has this quote: Jagland said the committee was influenced by a speech Obama gave about Islam in Cairo in June 2009, the president's efforts to prevent nuclear proliferation and climate change, and Obama's support for using established international bodies such as the United Nations to pursue foreign policy goals.[11] The New York Times reported that Jagland shrugged off the question of whether "the committee feared being labeled naïve for accepting a young politician's promises at face value", stating that "no one could deny that 'the international climate' had suddenly improved, and that Mr. Obama was the main reason...'We want to embrace the message that he stands for.' I think it's hard to quite grasp how much Bush and his war rhetoric was despised in intellectual circles in Europe. Then he was re-elected, and it was really as if Americans were hellbent on the us-vs-them attitude. It's too bad that Obama later started executing people remotely, but that's the problem with giving out awards for something done in the past year, it may be a better motivator and much more relevant, but you might end up handing out a prize to someone who later doesn't look like he or she still deserves it.