3 ms·
Many people have strong support for a single payer system. Seeing this simple failure illustrates a risk in moving that direction. Who do you trust to do a be
by colechristensen 10y ago
Many people have strong support for a single payer system. Seeing this simple failure illustrates a risk in moving that direction. Who do you trust to do a better job keeping costs in control? The greed (or fiduciary duty) of an insurance company or the governance of bureaucrats?
I trust the market more because the government has proved to be far more corruptible. There should be a government option for sure, but regulations should focus more on making the healthcare market healthy.
* Open straightforward pricing
* Removal of trademark protections for named drugs
* Reducing patent terms, adding affordability conditions
* Publicly funding research with open access requirements
* Mandating manufacture of unpopular or poorly competitive drugs to get patent protections
* Adding efficiency to approval and regulation process
It seems all too obvious that a single payer system in America would get overrun with regulatory capture and skyrocket costs in sweetheart deals.
- DasIch 10y agoThe US is the only first world country that has these problems. You don't need to come up with a fancy solution, just copy what another country does. It's not like it can get worse.
- colechristensen 10y agoThe US isn't the same as the rest of the first world (outmoded as that term is). A disproportional amount of research and medical industry happens in the US. In a way, many of the developed nations' medical systems are made possible by the American medical economy. We end up paying for more of the development and exporting our technology for as much as we can get. The cost structure wouldn't be the same worldwide if America switched. We have 50 states. Each one of them is capable of setting up a single payer healthcare system on it's own, yet none of them have. Not for lack of trying, but none have been successful. I don't think we should even have the national conversation at all until at least one state finds success implementing it themselves.
- DasIch 10y agoThere are a large number of medical companies outside of the US as well. Additionally governments encourage research in general through patents and subsidies and provide direct funding. Not to mention that a lot of research happens at universities. Additionally many of these companies are located outside of the US. Ignoring all of that just from a purely financial perspective, the amount of money spent on health care simply can't be explained through research, both in quantity and when it comes to the reality of what people actually pay for which treatments. Medical research doesn't explain why people think twice about calling an ambulance or go as far as taking a taxi or driving themselves or a loved one to a hospital in an emergency. If you do that in Germany, you'll get a lecture and will be considered an idiot who has unnecessarily endangered themselves.
- maxerickson 10y agoForeign companies can access the US market though. For instance, Mylan is registered in the Netherlands. http://www.bizjournals.com/pittsburgh/news/2015/02/27/mylan-inversion-deal-completed.html http://www.bizjournals.com/pittsburgh/news/2015/02/27/mylan-... Still, research investment doesn't come close to explaining the much higher healthcare costs seen in the US.
- kalleboo 10y agoSo the answer is "American consumers are suckers who are paying for the rest of the world, and there's nothing we can do about it"? How about US prescription drug marketing costs (something that's illegal in most other countries)? Drug marketing costs are similar or higher than R&D costs in many cases - why does drug marketing even exist?
- aianus 10y agoDrug marketing isn't illegal in most other countries, just marketing to consumers. You're free to market to physicians pretty much everywhere which is where the real money is spent anyways.
- chez17 10y ago>Seeing this simple failure illustrates a risk in moving that direction. Right. There are currently no known failures in the private system. Let's stick with that.
- tracker1 10y agoThe point isn't to have no rules... It's to ensure the ability to compete... right now certain protectionist rules only serve to help incumbents, and are only aided by lobbying efforts. To countermand that, what is needed are policies to ensure competition. Compulsory patent licensing for starters, and a dual-source requirement for prescription medications paid for by the state would be another. What we have had, and continue to have is not a free market, and it doesn't serve you to have it continue as such.
- Frondo 10y ago"I trust the market more because the government has proved to be far more corruptible." Proved? Has the U.S. government actually been proven to be more corruptible than private industry? I realize you might have been using a bit of overly-strong language, and not actually meant that in a literal way. Still, frankly speaking, I trust the government a heck of a lot more than private businesses like Comcast or the health insurers. Your statement, all the same, leaves me wondering if somehow I've missed out on some news stories or something, that shows how the government is corrupt while BCBS or UnitedHealth act with integrity.
- colechristensen 10y agoThere's no way to say "proved" about anything but mathematics that meets with it's usage in that context. It's not overly strong language, just used in a different context therefore with different meaning. I trust an insurance company and healthcare provider because they are adversaries. Insurance vs insurance, insurance vs provider, provider vs provider. They're being driven with competition and ultimately greed. If one of them does a bad job, another that's doing better will replace it. They're all playing with their own money. A government bureaucrat tough doesn't really have any skin in the game. They might be driven by good natured ideals, but I think that's far too vulnerable to compromise. From politicians being bought by lobbyists to a revolving door between industry and bureaucracies personal greed leads only to healthcare providers and government colluding for their own individual benefits to the detriment of the citizen who has no option but to pay taxes and get the services of the single healthcare system. In theory a benevolent dictator is the ideal form of government, but in reality the people with power just aren't angels. You can use competition and greed for the greater good if you do it properly, you just have to recognize what you're doing and how to manipulate human behavior for the best outcome.
- csydas 10y ago>I trust an insurance company and healthcare provider because they are adversaries. Insurance vs insurance, insurance vs provider, provider vs provider. They're being driven with competition and ultimately greed. If one of them does a bad job, another that's doing better will replace it. They're all playing with their own money. I mean, alternatively, doesn't the ultimate utilization of what the market can bear mean "no aggression pacts" between companies? As far as I've observed change in local options and markets in recent years hasnt been from innovation or disruptive new comers in many healthcare fields but instead buyouts and mergers consolidating the power until you're left with giants that just sort of leave one another alone. This doesn't breed competition, it breeds complacaency and a market with extremely few choices. I don't know the answer but this idea that corporations will fight for our dollar doesn't sit well with me, as the current state of healthcare options shows this to not be the case. The barrier of entry just on cost (equip, doctors, medicine) excluding regulatory issues is prohibitive, and doubly so for insurers. Disruptive forces that would provoke competition or a change in pricing just seems too difficult to get off the ground.
- makomk 10y agoIt's true that insurance companies have been fairly effective at keeping their costs down - mostly by finding clever (and often dubious) justifications for refusing to pay for treatments. This is of little consolation to the customers who've found that they can't get life-saving medical treatment due to insurance company shenanigans.
- sbov 10y agoWhen I was 24 I got in a skiing accident. I broke my femur into 4 pieces. Ski patrol took me down the hill. They threw me in an ambulance. They gave me some pain drugs which blurred my memory. The ambulance took me to the nearest hospital. When I arrived there, they gave me several options to remedy my shattered leg. I chose one - the next day I could not remember the other options nor why I chose the option I did. So I'm just curious. Where in that equation would open straightforward pricing have helped? Would I have refused an ambulance ride? Would I have done the research to call my own? Would I have requested to be taken to another hospital - the next closest one, by my guess, being an hour away? Should I call ahead and make sure their prices are reasonable? I don't understand how the free market can work with medical care. People oftentimes are not in a position to make decisions based upon price. The free market answer to "not dying" is "I'll pay everything I have".
- colechristensen 10y agoPeople sometimes aren't able to making decisions, but dire emergencies don't make up all of hospital care. Even then, a counter anecdote, I live in a city with maybe 4 hospitals within minutes at any given time and another dozen within a half hour or so. In the most dire situations I would have a choice and with anything less than critical I have a wide variety of options to choose from. If I need medications there are dozens of pharmacies to choose from. Yeah if you break your leg in the back woods, you're not going to have a choice for the initial care. But you will have a choice for any follow-up care. Also other people who aren't you using that same hospital will have choices between it and it's further away competition. You're right the "I'm dying and far away from urban areas" is a pretty location-based captive market, but it's far from the whole market. When I was a young teenager I broke my arm at a school event and ended up sitting in a hospital bed for hours waiting for them to find my parents to give consent for treatment. Even most broken bones have some pretty wide time periods to find and travel to the best hospital option. (Just not a broken femur, that shit is serious)