15 ms·
Farm grows vegetables in a desert using sun and seawater
- rmason 10y agoWhen I saw the headline I knew instantly how they did it. But the one thing unexplained in the story was their claim that the seawater piped in eliminated the need for pesticides. I would bet it was the desert climate that reduced the need for pesticides. I am willing to predict that they will eventually need to use pesticides.
- proee 10y agoif the plants are inside a greenhouse, i think this is a major barrier to most pests.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoGreenhouses can amplify pest problems as they are a closed system where things can get crazy very quickly with no natural checks and balances. They are some of the biggest consumers of pesticides.
- jrapdx3 10y agoGrowing tomatoes one time under cover had a huge problem with white fly, not an unusual infestation, but a very stubborn one. While using the natural kinds may be better, pesticides are often a necessity in that situation. Your comment was completely on target for many commercial producers.
- niftich 10y agoThis may turn out to be a silly question, but how does a pest infest a closed system in the first place? Do they arrive in the soil? Do they fly in the door? Could there be ways to mitigate or prevent the mechanism of infestation in the first place?
- ldp01 10y agoI imagine it boils down to a question of expense. Pests can probably arrive through: - People's boots/clothes. - The water. - The soil/fertiliser. - The air. Each of those inputs would need to be filtered. And the cost of filtration (or the entry/exit protocols for the workers) would need to be balanced against the cost of losing a crop.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoFungal spores are everywhere. And in hot humid high CO2 environment where there are no other kinds of fungal spores to compete with, and a big giant buffet of the kind of food they like... Nom nom nom nom. Same thing goes for insects. Nature is constant warfare. Farming is like picking a side and arming it.
- rmason 10y agoYou also must contend with diseases. Mono cropping something like tomatoes is a good way to amplify them.
- Scarblac 10y agoThat's a problem if you re-use the same land again and again, but probably not so much when planting in regularly replaced coconut husks.
- losvedir 10y agoThis comment explains it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12658321 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12658321
- rmason 10y agoThank you, that really does explain a lot. If the economics are good I am surprised that this hasn't been tried in other places in the world. Saudi Arabia installed center pivots in the desert to grow wheat back in the seventies. I believe at the time the US price of wheat was $3.00 per bushel and the Saudi's production cost was $12 a bushel but they still thought it was worthwhile to have some home grown wheat.
- delbel 10y agoTo pay for the infrastructure, they will probably need to sell the tomatoes for $100 a pound for twenty years.
- mattnumbe 10y agoThe beginning of most major scientific breakthroughs have high starting costs.
- daveguy 10y agoWell, the articles states the greenhouse is expected to yield 17,000 tonnes per year or 37.47 million pounds of tomatoes. The infrastructure costs 200 million dollars. So if they sell the tomatoes for $5.34 per pound they will pay off the infrastructure in a year. 53.4 cents per pound and they will pay off the infrastructure in 10 years. I expect it will be somewhere in between. Pretty close though.
- ac29 10y agoThe video states they have locked in an exclusive agreement with a national grocery chain to provide tomatoes for 10 years at a fixed price. My guess is its a win-win for the respective companies.
- mikekchar 10y agoEdit: Is my price right??? After posting I began to doubt it and I am having terrible problems trying to find out what the current market prices for tomatoes is... Commodity prices are usually expressed in tonnes. It seems at the moment the price is between $70-$80 per tonne. At $70 per tonne, the price would be about $1.2 million. You also need to pay operating costs. If the infrastructure is $200 million, I don't see how they will possibly pay it back. Even at current low interest rates, I don't think you would be able to pay off your loan. And yes, commodity prices for food are ridiculously low. All of the money goes to distributors. Fix that and we can have nice things like this.
- jonknee 10y ago
- achow 10y agoSeems like this idea is couple of decades in making.. A seawater greenhouse is a greenhouse structure that enables the growth of crops in arid regions, using seawater and solar energy. The technology was introduced by British inventor Charlie Paton in the early 1990s and is being developed by his UK company Seawater Greenhouse Ltd. The technique involves pumping seawater (or allowing it to gravitate if below sea level) to an arid location and then subjecting it to two processes: first, it is used to humidify and cool the air, and second, it is evaporated by solar heating and distilled to produce fresh water. Finally, the remaining humidified air is expelled from the greenhouse and used to improve growing conditions for outdoor plants. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seawater_greenhouse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seawater_greenhouse Making Namibia’s desert green using seawater https://www.newera.com.na/2016/07/08/making-namibias-desert-green-seawater/ https://www.newera.com.na/2016/07/08/making-namibias-desert-...
- hyperpallium 10y ago> On a sunny day, up to 39 megawatts of energy can be produced – enough to power the desalination plant... They don't appear to be using evaporation and distillation, but instead generate electricity and run the desalination plant with that... I'm guessing, by pressured osmosis, as used elsewhere in Australia. My question is: why don't they do it as you assumed? Whatever a solar still might lose in efficiency, it must surely make up in the reliability and simplicity of no moving parts.
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoDuring the pilot project Sundrop decided to simplify the design. The equipment for the distillation of the hot humid air proved to be complicated to produce with the resources available at the time and they decided to go with a more conventional method. Personally I think the original design could be made to work, but it needed more R&D than Sundrop was prepared to spend at the time.
- stuaxo 10y agoIndeed, trying too many new processes all at once would be setting yourself up for failure. Now this works, the other parts can be addressed and further efficiencies made.
- femto 10y agosun, seawater .... and fertiliser. As made clearer in other articles [1], they are adding nutrients to the water. In response to delbel: As mentioned in [1], the farm has a 10-year contract with Coles, one of Australia's big supermarkets, and that was what enabled the farm to be funded. Consequently, you can go to Coles and buy these tomatoes for about A$7 per kg. [2] [1] http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-10-01/sundrop-farms-opens-solar-greenhouse-using-no-fresh-water/7892866 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-10-01/sundrop-farms-opens-so... [2] https://shop.coles.com.au/online/SearchDisplay?storeId=10601&catalogId=10576&langId=-1&beginIndex=0&browseView=false&searchSource=Q&sType=SimpleSearch&resultCatEntryType=2&showResultsPage=true&pageView=image&supermarketRefer=yes&searchTerm=tomatoes https://shop.coles.com.au/online/SearchDisplay?storeId=10601...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- roel_v 10y agoWhich ones are they? There's only one type of tomato not labeled 'product of Australia' on that page, and it's $23/kg. I'd love to pick some up when I go home tonight, just to try.
- jonknee 10y ago> sun, seawater .... and fertiliser. As made clearer in other articles, they are adding nutrients to the water. Yes, that is how plants work.
- ChristianBundy 10y agoWhy so smarmy? The article specifically says "using only sun and seawater", so it's worth mentioning that they're also adding nutrients to the water. There are three necessary ingredients. If the title was "using only sunlight and nutrients" or "using only seawater and nutrients" it would make sense to mention the third ingredient, so I'm confused at why you jumped straight to condescension.
- jonknee 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ars 10y agoThis would be awesome for Israel! And if they could only fix their political problems (to put it mildly) Gaza as well. It could make a real difference in their future.
- jrpt 10y agoSo it's basically a desalination process in a greenhouse powered by solar? I'm not sure why this is better than leveraging existing infrastructure to get freshwater and electricity. Also, farming somewhere other than a desert, then transporting the food to the population (if they live in a desert).
- mastazi 10y agoI guess it makes sense in places like SA, NT or WA, where, in 90% of their territory, all the alternative resources you mentioned are hard to get by.
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoThere are plenty of economically unproductive coastal deserts in the world where this could be used.
- tuananh 10y agoCombine with this and we're golden http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/japanese-plant-experts-produce-10000-lettuces-a-day-in-led-lit-indoor-farm-9601844.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/japanese-plant-exp...
- EGreg 10y agoWow, simply wow. Humanity is turning the world into farms, destroying natural forests but then engineering new types of habitats. I wonder what the Earth would look like in 200 years. What I am worried about is the rapid growth of the human population and its energy use. You can't have exponential growth forever. Most of the issues come from that. Farms and monocultures sound nice, but are they sustainable? Are the resources being recycled somewhere, or are we going to be plugging holes with bacteria digesting plastic and producing plant food?
- kiba 10y agoOur problems come with growing consumption per capita than our number per se.
- 35bge57dtjku 10y ago> You can't have exponential growth forever. We don't. Look at the more developed nations.
- oh_sigh 10y ago...and most importantly, fertilizer (this is covered in the article, but the headline forgets that part)
- DavidWanjiru 10y agoWhere are the nutrients for plants coming from? They say plants are grown in coconut husks instead of soil. Does the coconut husk act merely as a plant holder, or is it the one that provides the nutrients that the plant would otherwise obtain from soil (with/without fertilizer)? That part is not clear to me. Edit: "There is no need for pesticides as seawater cleans and sterilises the air..." What does this even mean? Do we normally use pesticides to clean and sterilize the air? Are the pests that we fight with pesticides eliminated when the enclosed air in a greenhouse is cleaned and sterilized in this manner?
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoSee comment here about the pesticides. The article is badly worded. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12658321 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12658321 Nutrients are added to the irrigation water.
- jessriedel 10y agoBut where do the nutrients come from? The things supplied by fertilizer are not free, which presumably is why the article made such a big deal out of not using fertilizer or soil.
- DougWebb 10y agoOnce the farm's in operation for a while, I'd assume they could compost a lot of the waste material picked up during harvesting. I'm not sure about tomatoes; are the plants destroyed during harvest and grown from seed each season? Some crops are certainly handled that way.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe plants will survive for more than 1 season but as practical matter they would be culled at the end of their productive period. The stems and such are mostly water and a little bit of carbon, I guess other sources of nitrogen would have an excellent ROI (a modest amount of fertilizer vs high capital and labor costs).
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoThere are several things which aren't covered well in the article. I have spent quite a lot of time looking at the feasibility of the Seawater Greenhouse in multiple locations, including a visit to this Australian location a few years ago. [1] I haven't been involved since the pilot installation in Port Augusta, so they may have changed a few things described below. The Seawater Greenhouse design is not a conventional greenhouse. It cools rather than heats a crop, it is an open design, rather than a conventional "closed" design. The system, as designed by Charlie Paton, uses evaporative cooling in the greenhouse. Essentially they have a cardboard wall, sort of like a thick honey comb with holes through it, over which they pour seawater. The air is pulled through the wall by large relatively slow fans. When the air moves through the "honey comb" wall, the air changes direction (30 degree angle channels). Particles and insects in the air essentially get stuck in the seawater. Seawater is particularly bad for insects and other small pests as the salt clogs up the exoskeleton and the breathing channels when the water evaporates. Even though the greenhouse was standing in an area of vegetation with a significant insect population outside, we hardly saw any insects on the inside. But you could often find quite a few insects in the seawater tanks used to hold the water for the evaporators. The stable climate created in the greenhouse and the seawater "barrier" created by the evaporators means the pest insect pressure is lie and you can easily control it with natural enemies (bio control). (There where poisonous spiders in the canopy of the crop but they don't affect the crop, but act as biocontrol. Just don't let them bite you.) Plants grow much better in a cooler and high humidity environment. The plants don't have to put so much effort into transpiration to keep an acceptable temperature for photosynthesis. The evaporators with seawater handles both of those things. The temperature during my visit peaked on Christmas Day at 43 C, but inside the greenhouse it was a much more acceptable 35 C. (We had our Xmas dinner just behind the evaporators, the most pleasant place in Port Augusta at that point.) The energy used for this cooling primarily comes out of the water and the surrounding air. Some energy is used for pumping water. Without the evaporative cooling the temperature in the greenhouse would have been at a level which would have killed the plants. During my visit the plants and crop grew so fast that we had to help harvesting to keep up. The evaporators are also covered by sea salt, which is hydroscopic (absorbs water) which means that when the temperature drops at the end of the day you don't get water (dew) collecting on the plants. This is important as dew on the plants and produce allows botrytis (mold) to grow and potentially destroy the produce. This also avoids having to burn sulphur in the greenhouse to kill the mold. [1] pictures from my wife during the visit https://www.flickr.com/photos/ankertje/7044271777/in/album-72157625710401409/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/ankertje/7044271777/in/album-7...
- pilooch 10y agoFor those interested in these matters, the books by Masanobu Fukuoka (1) are a must. They may challenge some of the HN crowd views on progress, technology and religion, as they did definitely challenge mine, but they carry significative scientific truths. His focus on fighting desertification was both genius and ahead of his time. (1) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masanobu_Fukuoka https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masanobu_Fukuoka
- xkarga00 10y agoThe One Straw Revolution has been very inspiring for me. Highly recommended to anyone who wants to learn about natural farming.
- oska 10y agoInspired me so much that I flew to Tokyo, caught an overnight ferry to Shikoku and then hitch-hiked across the island to visit his farm. Met the man and spent the day looking around the farm/orchard. It was very beautiful. Unfortunately he was then too old for me to stay longer (I'd had dreams of living and working on the farm). This was back in 1990.
- pilooch 10y agoBeautiful! If you have pictures and one day blog a few lines about this encounter, I'd be delighted to read it!
- oska 10y agoThanks for your interest. I should write it up. I also visited an organic mikan farming co-operative not far from Fukuoka's farm on Shikoku and stayed there a few days. Actually he suggested it to me.
- maplechori 10y agoThis should definitely be tried in the UAE!
- donarb 10y agoOr instead of wasting energy trying to remove the salt, you could just use diluted seawater. https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/science/2014/oct/18/humble-potato-poised-to-launch-food-revolution%3f0p19G=e https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/science/201...
- sfifs 10y agoWell... you still need to have ready access to fresh-water to dilute seawater. This experiment is being done in a desert area where fresh-water is likely a high premium.
- didsomeonesay 10y ago> no soil, pesticides, fossil fuels or groundwater What about fertilisers? I would assume they still use conventional ones made from fossile fuels. Anybody got more information, did I miss sth in the article?
- molteanu 10y agoIn case you missed the article from yesterday, which was also posted here, named "The Dizzying Grandeur of 21st-Century Agriculture": http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/10/09/magazine/big-food-photo-essay.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/10/09/magazine/big-f...
- mikehines 10y agoPerhaps we could colonize the deserts on earth before Mars.
- Hondor 10y agoWhen the next comet strikes, solar powered desert farms will be wrecked just as much as everywhere else on Earth.
- onion2k 10y agoUnless a Mars colony is completely self-sustaining it'll be just as wrecked as anything on this planet without the support of Earth. Considering the lack of raw materials available there, that'd be effectively impossible.
- BHSPitMonkey 10y agoElon Musk disagrees with you, for what it's worth: http://www.spacex.com/mars http://www.spacex.com/mars
- vkou 10y agoElon Musk doesn't even have a proof-of-concept for how we can set up a sustainable, closed biosphere-in-a-bubble on Earth - let alone Mars. If he wants to put people on Mars in 8 years, this should have been a top priority a decade ago.
- carterehsmith 10y agoSure, but comet can strike Mars just as easily as it can strike Earth. Maybe even more easily - gravity, lack of atmosphere, etc.
- DougWebb 10y agoThat's an interesting idea... I think the thin atmosphere and lack of ocean might actually make comet strikes on Mars less devastating than on Earth. Less frictional heating during the impact, no global tsunamis caused by an ocean strike, much less wind and shockwave around the impact site, faster settling of post-impact dust and debris. You wouldn't want to be near the impact site on either planet, but if you're far away on Mars you might barely notice it, while on Earth you could be on the opposite side of the planet and still be killed by a tsunami or shrouded in darkness until all the plants around you are dead.
- kbart 10y ago"The $200 million infrastructure makes the seawater greenhouse more expensive to set up than traditional greenhouses, but the cost will pay off long-term" It's really nice experiment, but I don't see how that's gonna pay off. You need to sell a hell lots of tomatoes to earn $200 million back.
- lolive 10y agoRebrand it as a "Neural-network-AI-assisted seawater greenhouse". And VCs will fund your 200M$ in a minute.
- kbart 10y agoYou could've said the same about anything related to "web" in nineties and we know how it ends, sooner or later. That doesn't make something economically viable on the long run. I'm all up to self sustained, "green" farming in impossible places, but 200M$ for a moderate size greenhouse seems way too much to be something more than an experiment.
- dx034 10y agoWhy do they use concentrated solar power? Isn't that much more expensive and risky at current prices?
- ndonnellan 10y agoThat's a good question. Also kind of an interesting side note: the company behind the solar technology here is not Sundrop, but they're not mentioned at all. Which I find really curious. I may have worked for that company 4 or 5 years ago. 100 points for whoever can name them!
- dlss 10y agoFrom OP: > Sunshine and seawater. That’s all a new, futuristic-looking greenhouse needs to produce 17,000 tonnes of tomatoes per year in the South Australian desert > The $200 million infrastructure makes the seawater greenhouse more expensive to set up than traditional greenhouses, but the cost will pay off long-term, says Saumweber. Conventional greenhouses are more expensive to run on an annual basis because of the cost of fossil fuels, he says From the #1 google result for "cost of a ton of tomatoes" http://ucanr.edu/blogs/blogcore/postdetail.cfm?postnum=15889 http://ucanr.edu/blogs/blogcore/postdetail.cfm?postnum=15889: > Processors agreed to pay growers $83 per ton in 2014, up from $70 per ton last year. So assuming 100% profit margins (ie the tomatoes grow themselves, no human labor needs to be paid, nothing needs repairing or replacing, tomatoes deliver themselves to processing plants, etc, etc), the 17,000 tonnes produced would yield ~$1.4M annually. That's an awful (0.7%) annual return on $200M. Much less than you could get by investing the $200M in an index fund. Which is to say there's a 0% chance it will "pay off in the long-term".
- reitzensteinm 10y agoWell, it's in Australia... > Average costs of production were up sharply for tomatoes to $843 per tonne http://www.ausveg.com.au/resources/statistics/financial-performance/Cost_per_tonne http://www.ausveg.com.au/resources/statistics/financial-perf...
- dlss 10y agowow, 10x more expensive? Well, 7% ROI isn't awful for them, though that's still assuming a 100% profit margins. If margins are less than 50% they're again losing to just investing in index funds.
- Scarblac 10y agoIt's also not unreasonable to assume that the cost of traditional ways to grow tomatoes will go up further, due to water becoming even scarcer, fossil fuel use being heavily regulated, etc. But more importantly, the second of these plants will probably be cheaper than $200m, and the 50th will be a lot cheaper.
- baq 10y ago> “It’s a bit like crushing a garlic clove with a sledgehammer,” he says. “We don’t have problems growing tomatoes in Australia.” that's an epic way to miss the point completely.
- Nanzikambe 10y agoThe headline claim is demonstrably poorly researched and as others point out the project seems to be incredibly poor value. There's a lower tech approach that's been extensively proven and in production since 1998, it produces not just veg, but firewood/biomass, shrimps, fish, fresh water and more: http://articles.latimes.com/2001/jan/06/news/mn-9169 http://articles.latimes.com/2001/jan/06/news/mn-9169 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_P1rPnVUME4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_P1rPnVUME4
- lolive 10y agoSolar mirrors need to be extremely clean to be efficient. And that requires a lot of soap and clean water. Could it be a deal breaker in that kind of systems?
- foxhop 10y agoIf this catches your interests, please research greening the deserts using permaculture. Here is one example but there are many examples and projects: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4Nb-rqGfWI&spfreload=10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4Nb-rqGfWI&spfreload=10 | Reversing Desertification With Sticks, Rocks, and Ancient Wisdom Permaculture is more practical in the long run, doesn't require much tech.
- schiffern 10y agoThis. Looking at the headline I half expected this to be a permaculture installation. >I think if we could get Earth in a living and stable state, not a constantly degrading and dying state caused by our actions, then we have won some right to go to the stars. But at present I don't think we'd be welcome anywhere else in the universe. You wouldn't welcome anybody who'd laid waste to their house and wanted to live in yours, I'm sure. -- Bill Mollison, Co-founder of Permaculture (4 May 1928 – 24 September 2016)
- ph0rque 10y agoSo, this is a hydroponic greenhouse. It would be neat if they went one step further and made it an aquaponic greenhouse. The use of salt water means they could consider growing saltwater fish (or shrimp, or fish for caviar). The only caveat is whether it would be easy to separate the salt from the water while keeping the other nutrients (nitrogen, etc) in the water for the plants.
- slfnflctd 10y agoI don't think it's been settled whether aquaponic setups are any more efficient overall than hydroponics when you consider all the inputs. A lot of it would depend on the local environment, the scale of your operation, and the availability of whatever you're feeding the water critters. It's more variety, though, which in itself is a nice thing.
- ph0rque 10y agoSince this is a commercial enterprise, the question is not one of efficiency, but of potential profit. You're right that there are a lot of factors that would play into profitability.
- wodencafe 10y ago>First farm to grow vegetables in a desert using only sun and seawater And Coconut Husks.
- pcmaffey 10y agoFor a headline that explicitly excludes the 3rd essential component of growing (light, water, nutrients), the article mentions nothing about how these plants are getting nutrients. I assume they're supplementing liquid nutrients, as they're growing hydroponically in coco husks? If so, that makes the headline seem ridiculous... The coolest thing in the story for me is using salty air to repel pests. Though I wonder about the longevity of that solution. I've never seen a bullet-proof solution to pest control, and especially in self-contained environments, it's usually just a matter of time. Nevertheless, makes me wonder about a saltwater humidifier....
- pm90 10y agoSalty air is highly corrosive. Unless you want rust in every bit of iron in your furniture, that may not be the best idea.
- apendleton 10y agoI wonder what they're doing with their desalination outflow? The prine produced during desalination can be nasty, toxic stuff: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination#Environmental https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination#Environmental
- bnolsen 10y agoThey built themselves a prime bird frying machine. Insects like heat, the birds follow them and voila, instant cooked meat! Extra bonus for this type solar.
- nikolay 10y agoJust becomes something looks like a tomato, it doesn't make it one! In order to have nutritious produce, you need a lot more than just macro ingredients!
- the_watcher 10y agoThis is fascinating. I grew up about 30 miles from the Salton Sea, which is in the middle of the desert of Southern California. We get tons of sun. I'd be very interested if these researchers are communicating with those investigating how to best clean up the Salton Sea. While those efforts are still in their infancy, there could be some overlap in application of the research.