4 ms·
I'm going to get hammered into the ground for saying this but... The US spying wouldn't be nearly as bad if it was more transparent about it. I know, that soun
by Someone1234 10y ago
I'm going to get hammered into the ground for saying this but...
The US spying wouldn't be nearly as bad if it was more transparent about it. I know, that sounds crazy, but let me explain. Right now we have secret information dragnets collecting godknowswhat, with no independent oversight (that we, citizens, can examine) and no public definition for when an item moves from automated analysis into the realm of strangers looking at it.
Plus there's no strict definition for where the dragnet's flags begin and end. For example is an illegal poker game a justified flag? Cheating on your taxes? Cheating on your wife? Where is the line? Is it only when human life is endanger? And what about the awkward subject of industrial espionage? Will the US help US companies beat foreign ones? Will it help one US company beat another US company? How much does the US Gov really value free capitalist markets if they cheat?
My point is, the public themselves won't ever allow this spying to stop for the simple reason that people value security over privacy, and they constantly demand more security (e.g. after every terrorist attack ever "why didn't you stop this?!"). So if it is here to stay, we need to have the most transparent and checks-and-balances system we can.
Yes, sure, criticise me. But do you know how many US spying programs have closed since Snowden? ZERO. So if we aren't going to close them let's at least make them less secret, provide better oversight, and provide better controls.
- paulddraper 10y agoSee, and I think "If we aren't going to provide better oversight and controls [as has been the attempt], let's shut them down."
- marcoperaza 10y agoThe transparency that you're suggesting would totally defeat the purpose of the program. Terrorists would just use the channels that they know are not being watched.
- jwtadvice 10y agoYou seem to be under the persuasion that these programs are intended to catch criminal behavior. They are not. The NSA engage in what's known as "strategic listening". This is the 'measuring half' to strategic communication - which means propaganda. Propaganda messaging gets tracked to see how well it penetrates target societies and knowledge from surveillance about personal associations, trust networks, how information generally flows through society allow propaganda programming to be adaptively retargetted and remessaged. Similarly, these surveillance programmes are used to give American businesses a leg up in competition (the international oil auctions from a few years ago are a well known example of this). Surveillance capabilities were installed by the CIA in their fake Twitter application "ZunZuneo" because having dossiers on potential future political activists gives US intelligence leverage over potential future public servicepeople. Surveillance is and has been about power and control - it's a misunderstanding to think that the line stops with some kind of criminal behavior or other. Therein, I think the framing of the question - as much as I like the approach - will inevitably fall short of really addressing the issue.
- Zigurd 10y agoLaw enforcement and intelligence use this information for what amounts to blackmail. There is no safe way to do this.